정부

Self-Regulatory Organizations; MEMX LLC; Notice of Filing and Immediate Effectiveness of a Proposed Rule Change To Amend Its Rules To Permit the Listing of Binary Options Overlying Key Performance Indicators

Federal Register Notices
Public Domain
이 매체는 공공·자유 라이선스로 본문을 직접 표시합니다.

[Federal Register Volume 91, Number 223 (Friday, November 20, 2026)]
[Notices]
[Pages 75386-75409]
From the Federal Register Online via the Government Publishing Office [www.gpo.gov]
[FR Doc No: 2026-23650]

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION

[Release No. 34-106919; File No. SR-MEMX-2026-35]

Self-Regulatory Organizations; MEMX LLC; Notice of Filing and
Immediate Effectiveness of a Proposed Rule Change To Amend Its Rules To
Permit the Listing of Binary Options Overlying Key Performance
Indicators

November 17, 2026.
Pursuant to Section 19(b)(1) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934
(``Act'') \1\ and Rule 19b-4 thereunder,\2\ notice is hereby given that
on November 9, 2026, MEMX LLC (``MEMX'' or the ``Exchange'') filed with
the Securities and Exchange Commission (the ``Commission'') the
proposed rule change as described in Items I and II below, which Items
have been prepared by the Exchange. The Exchange filed the proposal as
a ``non-controversial'' proposed rule change pursuant to Section
19(b)(3)(A)(iii) of the Act \3\ and Rule 19b-4(f)(6) thereunder.\4\ The
Commission is publishing this notice to solicit comments on the
proposed rule change from interested persons.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\1\ 15 U.S.C. 78s(b)(1).
\2\ 17 CFR 240.19b-4.
\3\ 15 U.S.C. 78s(b)(3)(A).
\4\ 17 CFR 240.19b-4.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

I. Self-Regulatory Organization's Statement of the Terms of Substance
of the Proposed Rule Change

The Exchange is filing with the Commission a proposed rule change
to adopt new Chapter 30 of the Exchange Rules to permit the listing and
trading of binary options overlying key performance indicators
(``KPIs'') reported by certain issuers of stock (``binary KPI
options'') on the Exchange's options platform (``MEMX Options''), and
to make related changes to Exchange Rules 16.1, 16.2, 20.6, and 21.17.
The text of the proposed rule change is provided in Exhibit 5 and is
available on the Exchange's website at https://info.memxtrading.com/regulation/rules-and-filings/.

II. Self-Regulatory Organization's Statement of the Purpose of, and
Statutory Basis for, the Proposed Rule Change

In its filing with the Commission, the Exchange included statements
concerning the purpose of, and basis for, the proposed rule change and
discussed any comments it received on the proposed rule change. The
text of these statements may be examined at the places specified in
Item IV below. The Exchange has prepared summaries, set forth in
sections A, B, and C below, of the most significant aspects of such
statements.

A. Self-Regulatory Organization's Statement of the Purpose of, and
Statutory Basis for, the Proposed Rule Change

1. Purpose
The Exchange proposes to adopt rules to permit the listing of
binary options overlying key performance indicators (``KPIs'') reported
by certain issuers of stock (``binary KPI options'') on MEMX

[[Page 75387]]

Options. The proposed rules are substantially similar to rules of Cboe
Exchange, Inc. (``Cboe'') that the Commission recently approved.\5\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\5\ See Securities Exchange Act Release No. 106659 (October 13,
2026), 91 FR 65854 (October 16, 2026) (SR-CBOE-2026-061) (Notice of
Filing of Amendment No. 1 and Order Granting Accelerated Approval of
a Proposed Rule Change, as Modified by Amendment No. 1, to Permit
the Listing of Binary Options Overlying Key Performance Indicators
Reported by Certain Issuers of Stock) (``Cboe Approval Order'').
Amendment No. 1 to SR-CBOE-2026-061 replaced and superseded the
original filing in its entirety and is published in Sections II and
III of the Cboe Approval Order (as so amended, the ``Cboe
Proposal''). Cboe's rules governing binary KPI options are set forth
in Cboe Rules 1.1 (definition of ``underlying security''), 4.80
through 4.84, 5.1(b)(3)(F), 5.3(c)(3), 5.4(c)(1), 5.31(d)(1)(D),
5.34(d), 6.5, Interpretation and Policy .10, 6.20(g)(2), 8.36, and
8.43(f) (collectively, the ``Cboe Rules'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

By way of background, binary options are based on the same
framework as traditional, standardized options traded on the Exchange,
except the payout of a binary option is a fixed amount contingent upon
the occurrence of the option being in- or at-the-money rather than an
amount based on the degree to which the option is in-the-money. As a
result, payout at expiration of a binary option is an all-or-nothing
occurrence.
The Exchange does not currently list binary options. The Exchange
proposes to adopt rules to permit the listing of binary KPI options.
Binary KPI options are European-style, cash-settled options contracts
listed on an underlying KPI of an issuer. The exercise settlement value
of a binary KPI option is determined not by the market price of the
issuer's stock, but by whether a specific financial or operating metric
that is reported by the issuer in an earnings-related filing submitted
to the Commission meets or exceeds a pre-specified strike level.
Summary of Differences From the Cboe Rules
The proposed rules are based on, and are substantially similar to,
the Cboe Rules, and the Exchange proposes to list binary KPI options on
the same issuers and KPIs, with the same contract terms, as the binary
KPI options approved for listing on Cboe. Throughout this filing, the
Exchange has generally used the same language as the Cboe Proposal
where the Exchange is adopting the same approach as Cboe. In addition
to non-substantive differences (such as conforming changes to reflect
the Exchange's rule numbering, defined terms, and existing rules) and
other minor differences described in this filing, the proposed rules
differ from the Cboe Rules in the following material respects, each of
which is further described below:
Rule structure. Cboe adopted its binary KPI option rules
in part by amending its existing rules governing binary index options.
Because the Exchange does not currently list binary options, the
Exchange proposes to adopt the rules applicable to binary KPI options
in a single new Chapter 30, to add provisions applicable to binary KPI
options to Rules 20.6 (Nullification and Adjustment of Options
Transactions including Obvious Errors) and 21.17 (Additional Price
Protection Mechanisms and Risk Controls), and to make conforming
changes to Rules 16.1 and 16.2 to reflect that the Rules applicable to
options trading on the Exchange will include Chapter 30. The proposed
rules also make conforming changes to reflect the Exchange's rule
numbering, defined terms, and existing rules.
Clearing. Cboe intends to clear binary KPI options through
Cboe Clear US, LLC (``CCUS''), and the Cboe Proposal describes certain
provisions of CCUS's proposed rules. The Exchange proposes to define
``Clearing Corporation,'' for purposes of binary KPI options, as the
registered clearing agency designated by the Exchange to clear binary
KPI options, and to provide that references in the Rules to The Options
Clearing Corporation (``OCC'') mean the Clearing Corporation with
respect to binary KPI options. The Exchange will submit a separate
proposed rule change to the Commission to designate the registered
clearing agency that will serve as the Clearing Corporation for binary
KPI options. The Exchange represents that it will not list binary KPI
options for trading until the Clearing Corporation is registered with
the Commission and operationally ready to clear binary KPI options, all
applicable filings and documents of the Clearing Corporation related to
binary KPI options are approved by the Commission or effective after
review by the Commission, as applicable, the applicable disclosure
document required by Rule 9b-1 under the Act is in place, and the other
conditions described below are satisfied.
Maximum execution price. Proposed Rule 21.17(h) is
substantially similar to Cboe Rule 5.34(d), which permits Cboe to
designate a maximum execution price for a binary option class, except
that, pursuant to proposed Rule 21.17(h), the System will prevent
executions of binary KPI options at prices above the Exchange-
designated maximum execution price, rather than adjusting such
execution prices down to the maximum execution price, as provided in
Cboe Rule 5.34(d). Consistent with that rule, the Exchange will
designate the maximum execution price for each class of binary KPI
options and will notify Options Members of the designated maximum
execution price.
Opening. Cboe Rule 5.31(d)(1)(D) provides that the opening
rotation for binary KPI options is initiated at 9:30 a.m. Proposed Rule
30.6(f) instead provides that binary KPI options will open for trading
in accordance with Rule 21.7 (Market Opening Procedures), with the
stock of the issuer treated as the security underlying the option for
purposes of that Rule.
Trading functionality. Binary KPI options will generally
be subject to the same trading functionality on MEMX Options as other
options listed on the Exchange. The Exchange does not currently offer
complex order functionality, auction mechanisms, floor trading, or
flexible exchange options (``FLEX'') on MEMX Options, and, accordingly,
the discussion in the Cboe Proposal of the application of such
functionality to binary KPI options does not apply to the Exchange's
proposal.
Proposed Chapter 30 and Conforming Changes to Chapter 16
First, the Exchange proposes to adopt Chapter 30 (Binary KPI
Options) to describe binary KPI options. The Rules in proposed Chapter
30 apply only to binary KPI options. All other Rules apply to the
trading of binary KPI options, except as otherwise provided or the
context otherwise requires.\6\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\6\ The first two sentences of the introductory paragraph to
proposed Chapter 30 are the same as the introductory paragraph of
Cboe Chapter 4, Section I, other than a conforming reference to
Chapter 30. See Cboe Approval Order, supra note 5, 91 FR at 65854.
The final sentence of the introductory paragraph to proposed Chapter
30, which relates to references in the Rules to OCC and has no
counterpart in the Cboe Rules, is discussed below.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

The Exchange also proposes to make conforming changes to Rules 16.1
and 16.2 to reflect the addition of Chapter 30 to the Rules applicable
to options trading on the Exchange. Currently, the introductory
paragraph to Rule 16.1 provides that the definitions in Rule 16.1 apply
with respect to the Rules contained in Chapters 16 to 29, the
definition of ``Rules of MEMX Options'' in Rule 16.1 refers to the
rules contained in Chapters 16 to 29, Rule 16.2(a) provides that the
Rules contained in Chapters 16 to 29 are the Exchange Rules applicable
to the trading of options contracts on MEMX Options, and Rule 16.2(b)
provides that, to the extent the Rules relating to options trading
contained in Chapters 16 to 29 are inconsistent with any other

[[Page 75388]]

provisions of the Exchange Rules, the Rules relating to options trading
control. The Exchange proposes to amend each of these provisions to
refer to Chapters 16 to 30. These proposed changes will ensure that the
definitions in Rule 16.1 apply to terms used in proposed Chapter 30
(unless otherwise defined in Chapter 30), and that the Rules in
proposed Chapter 30 are treated in the same manner as the Exchange's
other options Rules.
Additionally, proposed Chapter 30 provides that, with respect to
binary KPI options, unless the context otherwise requires, references
in the Rules to The Options Clearing Corporation, OCC, or the Clearing
Corporation mean the Clearing Corporation (as defined in proposed Rule
30.1), and references to the rules or by-laws of The Options Clearing
Corporation mean the Rules of the Clearing Corporation. As discussed
below, proposed Rule 30.1 defines the term ``Clearing Corporation'' as
the registered clearing agency designated by the Exchange to clear
binary KPI options. Pursuant to the introductory paragraph to proposed
Chapter 30, all Rules (including Rules outside of Chapter 30) apply to
the trading of binary KPI options, except as otherwise provided or the
context otherwise requires. A number of those Rules outside of Chapter
30 refer to OCC, either expressly (for example, references to The
Options Clearing Corporation or to the rules or by-laws of OCC) or
through the terms ``Clearing Corporation'' and ``OCC,'' which Rule 16.1
currently defines to mean OCC (for example, the definitions of
``options contract'' and ``put'' in Rule 16.1 and the applicability
provision in Rule 16.2(a)).\7\ The purpose of the proposed provision is
to ensure that, when these Rules outside of Chapter 30 are applied to
binary KPI options, their references to OCC (and to the rules or by-
laws of OCC) will be read to refer to the registered clearing agency
designated by the Exchange to clear binary KPI options (and to its
rules), rather than to OCC specifically, without the need to amend each
such Rule. The ``unless the context otherwise requires'' qualifier
ensures that the provision will not apply to references in the Rules
that relate to OCC in a context other than the clearing of binary KPI
options (for example, references to OCC's calculation of national
cleared volume in Rule 21.5).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\7\ See Rules 16.1 (definitions of ``Clearing Corporation and
OCC,'' ``Options Contracts,'' ``Put,'' and ``Rules of the Clearing
Corporation and Rules of the OCC'') and 16.2(a).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Proposed Rule 30.1 (Definitions)
The Exchange proposes to adopt Rule 30.1 (Definitions). Like other
standardized options, binary KPI options have standardized terms that
are established by the Exchange. Standardized terms for binary KPI
options include the exercise criterion that is the condition or
criterion of a binary KPI option, the exercise settlement amount (i.e.,
payout amount), the strike price, the expiration date, the settlement
type as A.M.-settlement or P.M.-settlement, the exercise style (as
European-style), and the requirements used to determine if the KPI
condition or criterion of a binary KPI option has been met (the
``payout determination'' \8\). The Exchange proposes to establish these
terms in proposed Rule 30.1 and additional provisions related to binary
KPI options in proposed Chapter 30, as described below.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\8\ This is the term used in the options disclosure document
describing the characteristics and risks of binary KPI options that
was submitted to the Commission in accordance with Rule 9b-1 under
the Act in connection with the listing of binary KPI options on
Cboe. See Cboe Approval Order, supra note 5, 91 FR at 65854-55.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

The Exchange proposes to define a ``binary KPI option'' in proposed
Rule 30.1 as a cash-settled option contract listed on an underlying KPI
of an issuer with an exercise settlement amount that is established at
the creation of the option and with a settlement value that is
determined by whether a specific KPI disclosed by the issuer in an
earnings-related filing submitted to the Commission meets or exceeds
its exercise price. Binary KPI options are paid out if the reported
value of the applicable KPI (1) equals or is greater than (i.e., the
payout determination) the exercise price for a call binary KPI option
or (2) is less than (i.e., the payout determination) the exercise price
for a put binary KPI option.\9\ The Exchange also proposes to provide
that unless the context dictates otherwise, the terms underlying
security, equity, or index, or any variations of these terms, in the
Rules mean KPI for purposes of binary KPI options.\10\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\9\ This is the same as the definition of binary KPI option in
Cboe Rule 4.80.
\10\ Similarly, proposed Rule 30.1 defines the term ``underlying
security'' (or ``underlying'') to mean ``with respect to binary KPI
options, the applicable KPI that is the subject of the settlement,''
which is the same as the definition of underlying security with
respect to binary KPI options in Cboe Rule 1.1.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

The Exchange proposes to define a ``call binary KPI option'' as an
option contract that returns an exercise settlement amount if the
settlement value of the underlying KPI is at or above the exercise
price at expiration (i.e., in- or at-the-money).\11\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\11\ This is the same as the definition of call binary KPI
option in Cboe Rule 4.80.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

The Exchange proposes to define ``Clearing Corporation'' as the
registered clearing agency designated by the Exchange to clear binary
KPI options.\12\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\12\ The definition of Clearing Corporation reflects that the
Exchange may designate OCC or another registered clearing agency to
clear binary KPI options. References in proposed Chapter 30 and in
this filing to the Clearing Corporation therefore are intended to be
clearing agency-neutral. Upon designation of a registered clearing
agency to clear binary KPI options, the Exchange will submit a
separate proposed rule change to the Commission to reflect such
designation. The proposed definition does not alter the requirement
that clearing and settlement occur through a registered clearing
agency subject to the applicable provisions of the Act and the rules
and oversight applicable to that clearing agency. As discussed
below, the Exchange will not list binary KPI options for trading
until, among other things, the Clearing Corporation is registered
with the Commission and operationally ready to clear binary KPI
options and all applicable filings and documents of the Clearing
Corporation related to binary KPI options are approved by the
Commission or effective after review by the Commission, as
applicable.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

The Exchange proposes to define ``exercise price'' (also referred
to as ``strike price'') as the value \13\ to which the settlement value
of the underlying KPI is compared to determine whether the holder of a
binary KPI option is entitled to the exercise settlement amount.\14\
For binary KPI options, the exercise price is the exercise threshold of
an option contract that establishes the number that is compared against
the settlement value of the underlying KPI to determine if the cash
payout amount (i.e., the exercise settlement amount) will be paid out.
In other words, binary KPI options will have a threshold number as the
exercise price that will be used to determine if the exercise criterion
of the binary KPI option has been met, in which case the option will be
exercised and holders will receive the cash payout amount (i.e., the
exercise settlement amount). For binary KPI options, the exercise
threshold will be a number that reflects or is compared to the
underlying KPI of the binary option.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\13\ The value of an exercise price is measured in the
applicable units of the KPI (and is scaled, as further discussed
below). For example, some KPIs are measured in U.S. dollars while
others may be measured in percentages or numbers.
\14\ This is the same as the definition of exercise price in
Cboe Rule 4.80. The Exchange proposes to define ``exercise
settlement amount'' for binary KPI options as $1 (unless otherwise
adjusted pursuant to Rules 19.6 or 30.5 or modified pursuant to the
Rules of the Clearing Corporation), which is the same as the
definition of exercise settlement amount in Cboe Rule 4.80 (other
than conforming references to the Exchange's Rules regarding
adjustments).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

The Exchange proposes to define the term KPI (or ``key performance

[[Page 75389]]

indicator'') as a key financial or operating metric disclosed by an
issuer in its earnings-related filings submitted to the Commission
(i.e., Form 8-K, Form 10-Q, or Form 10-K, as applicable).\15\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\15\ This is the same as the definition of KPI in Cboe Rule
4.80.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

The Exchange proposes to define ``put binary KPI option'' as an
option contract that returns an exercise settlement amount if the
settlement value of the underlying KPI is below the exercise price at
expiration (i.e., in-the-money).\16\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\16\ This is the same as the definition of put binary KPI option
in Cboe Rule 4.80.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

The Exchange proposes to define ``settlement value'' as the value
of the underlying KPI that is used to determine whether a binary KPI
option is in-, at-, or out-of-the-money.\17\ The proposed definition
specifies that the ``settlement value'' is the value of the applicable
KPI as disclosed in the applicable issuer's earnings-related filing
submitted to the Commission on the applicable expiration date (for both
A.M.-settled and P.M.-settled binary KPI options).\18\ The Exchange
designates the applicable KPI and the relevant reporting period (for
example, a calendar quarter) at the time of listing a binary KPI
option.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\17\ This is the same as the definition of settlement value in
Cboe Rule 4.80, except as described below with respect to paragraph
(c) of that definition.
\18\ While the timing of an issuer's official disclosure informs
whether the Exchange will establish a binary KPI option as A.M.-
settled or P.M.-settled (as further discussed below), the Exchange
will use the KPI value included in an issuer's earnings-related
filing submitted to the Commission for the applicable reporting
period (and not the press release disclosing earnings results, for
example) as the settlement value. The Exchange believes, however,
these values are generally the same.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Proposed paragraph (b) of the settlement value definition provides
if the applicable KPI is not reported or is otherwise unavailable on
the expiration date,\19\ settlement (including any payout of the
exercise settlement amount) will occur in accordance with the Rules of
the Clearing Corporation.\20\ The Exchange will not list binary KPI
options for trading unless procedures are established that will apply
if the KPI value needed to determine whether a binary KPI option is at-
or in-the-money is not available (``alternative settlement
procedures''), which procedures will be subject to the applicable
regulatory process, including review and approval by the Commission, as
applicable.\21\ By way of example, the alternative settlement
procedures applicable to binary KPI options listed on Cboe (as
described in the Cboe Proposal) provide that if the KPI value needed to
determine whether a binary KPI option is at- or in-the-money is not
available, expiring contracts will be exercised but may result in
delivery of an alternative exercise settlement amount. The alternative
exercise settlement amount may be the last closing price of the binary
KPI option (i.e., the market valuation of the KPI event), meaning that
the alternative exercise settlement amount will be between $0.01 and
$1.00, rather than the expected $0.00 or $1.00. If an option closing
price is not available or is deemed by the clearing agency to be
unreliable, the exercise criterion for binary option contracts on that
KPI event will be deemed to have not been met, and the binary options
will expire unexercised and worthless.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\19\ For example, if an issuer does not report the applicable
KPI in its earnings-related filings submitted to the Commission,
will not be submitting such a filing for the applicable reporting
period, or delays its filing submission to the Commission.
\20\ This is the same as paragraph (b) of the definition of
settlement value in Cboe Rule 4.80. As discussed above, references
in the proposed Rules and this rule filing to the Clearing
Corporation mean the registered clearing agency designated by the
Exchange to clear binary KPI options.
\21\ See Cboe Approval Order, supra note 5, 91 FR at 65855
(describing the alternative settlement procedures applicable to
binary KPI options listed on Cboe).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Additionally, proposed paragraph (c) of the settlement value
definition states if an applicable KPI is restated after the expiration
date and settlement of a binary KPI option, the settlement value (and
the exercise settlement amount) of the binary KPI option does not
change.\22\ In other words, the value of the applicable KPI as reported
by the issuer on the applicable expiration date is final, and the
amount paid (or not paid) at settlement will not change, regardless of
whether the KPI is later restated by the issuer.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\22\ This is substantially the same as paragraph (c) of the
definition of settlement value in Cboe Rule 4.80, except that Cboe
Rule 4.80 includes the parenthetical ``(as set forth in the Rules of
the Clearing Corporation),'' which refers to the rules of CCUS.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Proposed Rule 30.2 (Designation of Binary KPI Option Contracts)
The Exchange proposes to add Rule 30.2 (Designation of Binary KPI
Option Contracts) to identify the binary KPI options that may be listed
for trading on the Exchange. Pursuant to proposed Rule 30.2(a), the
Exchange may from time to time approve for listing and trading on the
Exchange any of the following binary KPI options contracts for the
following issuers: \23\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\23\ The issuers and KPIs set forth in proposed Rule 30.2(a) are
the same as the issuers and KPIs set forth in Cboe Rule 4.81(a).

------------------------------------------------------------------------
KPI (each financial metric is
Company measured in $ unless otherwise
specified)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Apple, Inc........................ Earnings Per Share: Diluted.
Total Net Sales.
Net Sales by Category: iPhone.
Net Sales by Category: Services.
Net Sales by Reportable Segment:
Americas.
Net Sales by Reportable Segment:
Greater China.
Advanced Micro Devices, Inc....... GAAP Diluted Earnings per Share.
GAAP Revenue.
Net Revenue: Data Center Segment.
Net Revenue: Client and Gaming
Segment.
GAAP Operating Margin (%).
Alphabet Inc...................... Diluted Net Income per Share.
Revenues.
YouTube Ads Revenues.
Google Cloud Revenues.
Amazon.com, Inc................... Diluted Earnings per Share.
Total Net Sales.
AWS: Net Sales.
North America: Net Sales.
International: Net Sales.
Net Sales: Advertising Services.

[[Page 75390]]


Bank of America Corporation....... Diluted Earnings per Share.
Total Revenue, Net of Interest
Expense.
Net Interest Income.
Provision for Credit Losses.
Net Income.
Citigroup Inc..................... Diluted Earnings per Share.
Total Revenue, Net of Interest
Expense.
Net Interest Income.
Total Provision for Credit Losses.
Net Income.
Coinbase Global, Inc.............. Net Income per Share--Diluted.
Total Revenue.
Transaction Revenue.
Total Trading Volume.
Subscription and Services Revenue.
Ford Motor Company................ GAAP Earnings per Share--Diluted.
Total Revenues.
Ford Pro Segment: Revenue.
Ford Model e Segment: Revenue.
Ford Blue Segment: Revenue.
Intel Corporation................. GAAP Earnings per Share Attributable
to Intel--Diluted.
Net Revenue.
Revenue: Client Computing Group
(CCG).
Revenue: Data Center and AI (DCAI).
Revenue: Intel Foundry.
GAAP Operating Margin (%).
JPMorgan Chase & Co............... Earnings per Share--Diluted.
Net Revenue--Reported.
Net Interest Income.
Provision for Credit Losses.
Net Income.
Marathon Digital Holdings, Inc.... Earnings (Net Loss) per Share of
Common Stock--Diluted.
Revenues.
Number of Blocks Won (# Bitcoin
(BTC)).
Energized Hashrate (EH) (# EH/s).
Total Bitcoin Holdings (# BTC).
BTC Produced (# BTC).
BTC Purchased (# BTC).
Meta Platforms, Inc............... Earnings per Share: Diluted.
Revenue.
Family Daily Active People (DAP)
(#).
Revenue: Advertising.
Operating Margin (%).
Microsoft Corporation............. Diluted Earnings per Share.
Revenue.
Intelligent Cloud: Revenue.
Microsoft Cloud Revenue.
More Personal Computing: Revenue.
Netflix, Inc...................... Earnings per Share: Diluted.
Revenues.
United States and Canada (UCAN):
Revenue.
Europe, Middle East, and Africa
(EMEA): Revenue.
Operating Margin (%).
NVIDIA Corporation................ GAAP Diluted Earnings per Share.
Revenue.
Data Center Revenue.
Edge Computing Revenue.
Automotive Revenue
Palantir Technologies Inc......... Earnings per Share Attributable to
Common Stockholders, Diluted.
Revenue.
Net Income.
Closed Deals of at Least $1 Million
(#).
Robinhood Markets, Inc............ Net Income Attributable to Robinhood
Common Stockholders: Diluted.
Total Net Revenues.
Funded Customers (#).
Average Revenue per User (``ARPU'').
Robinhood Gold Subscribers (#).
SoFi Technologies, Inc............ Earnings per Share Attributable to
Common Stockholders--Diluted.
Total Net Revenue.
Total Net Revenue--Technology
Platform.
Total Net Revenue--Financial
Services.
Total Net Revenue--Lending.

[[Page 75391]]


Space Exploration Technologies Earnings per Share: Diluted.
Corp. Total Revenues.
Super Micro Computer, Inc......... Net Income per Common Share:
Diluted.
Net Sales.
Gross Margin (%).
Cash Flow Used in Operations.
Net Income.
Target Corporation................ Diluted Earnings per Share.
Net Sales.
Food & Beverage Net Sales.
Apparel & Accessories Net Sales.
Operating Income: Rate (%).
Tesla, Inc........................ Net Income per Share of Common
Stocks Attributable to Common
Stockholders: Diluted.
Total Revenues.
Total Automotive Revenue.
Model 3/Y Production (#).
Supercharger Connectors (#).
Free Cash Flow.
The Walt Disney Company........... Diluted Earnings per Share.
Revenues.
Entertainment Subscription Video On
Demand (SVOD) Operating Income.
Revenues: Experiences.
Segment Operating Income: Sports
------------------------------------------------------------------------

The Exchange proposes to add Rule 30.2(b) to clarify that binary
KPI options are a separate class from other options overlying the stock
of the issuer and are a separate class from other binary KPI options
with different underlying KPIs for the same issuer.\24\ The Exchange
believes this is reasonable given that an individual KPI is the
specific underlying of binary KPI options, and generally options with
different underlyings (e.g., different underlying security or index)
are different option classes.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\24\ This is the same as Cboe Rule 4.81(b).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Proposed Rule 30.3 (Terms of Binary KPI Option Contracts)
Next, the Exchange proposes to adopt Rule 30.3 (Terms of Binary KPI
Option Contracts) to describe the permissible terms the Exchange may
establish for binary KPI option series. Proposed Rule 30.3 provides
that binary KPI options listed and traded on the Exchange are
designated as to expiration date, exercise price, settlement type,
exercise style, exercise settlement amount, contract multiplier, and
underlying KPI.\25\ After approving a particular binary KPI option
class for listing and trading on the Exchange, the Exchange from time
to time may open for trading series of options in that binary KPI
option class. Proposed Rule 30.3(a) states the Exchange may designate
the settlement type for binary KPI options as A.M.-settled or P.M.-
settled.\26\ Binary KPI options for issuers \27\ that disclose their
earnings results before the open of Regular Trading Hours \28\ on a
given trading day are designated as A.M.-settled binary KPI options,
and binary KPI options for issuers that disclose their earnings results
after the close of Regular Trading Hours on a given trading day are
designated as P.M.-settled binary KPI options. The Exchange notes that
the proposed concepts of A.M.-settlement and P.M.-settlement for binary
KPI options differ compared to traditional options, for which ``P.M.-
settled'' generally means that the expiration of an option so
designated will settle to the closing price of the underlying security
or index value and ``A.M.-settled'' generally means that the expiration
of an option so designated will settle to the opening price of the
underlying. While different than how these terms apply to standard
options, the Exchange believes the proposed description of A.M.-
settlement and P.M.-settlement appropriately reflects the earnings
disclosure practices of issuers. Additionally, while the timing of the
event that will determine whether the Exchange designates a binary KPI
option as A.M.-settled or P.M.-settled is different than that for
traditional options, the trading hours on expiration dates for each of
A.M.-settled and P.M.-settled binary KPI options are consistent with
those of A.M.-settled and P.M.-settled index options today.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\25\ This is the same as the introductory paragraph of Cboe Rule
4.82.
\26\ This is substantially the same as Cboe Rule 4.82(a), other
than the use of the defined term ``Regular Trading Hours'' and a
conforming change to provide that the Exchange determines whether an
issuer discloses its earnings results ``before the open or after the
close'' of Regular Trading Hours, consistent with the preceding
sentences of that paragraph.
\27\ The Exchange determines whether an issuer discloses its
earnings results before the open or after the close of Regular
Trading Hours on a given trading day based on publicly available
information regarding the issuer's general disclosure practices.
\28\ Rule 1.5(bb) defines the term ``Regular Trading Hours'' to
mean the time between 9:30 a.m. and 4:00 p.m. Eastern Time, and such
definition applies to the Rules applicable to options trading
pursuant to Rule 16.1.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Proposed Rule 30.3(a) further states that the exercise style of
binary KPI options is European-style, which is the same as Cboe Rule
4.82(a).\29\ A European-style option may only be exercised on its
expiration date.\30\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\29\ See Cboe Rule 4.82(a).
\30\ See Rule 16.1 (definition of European-Style Option).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Proposed Rule 30.3(b) describes permissible expirations for binary
KPI options.\31\ Specifically, the proposed rule change will permit the
Exchange to list binary KPI option series that expire on the date on
which an issuer discloses its earnings results (that include the
applicable KPI) for the applicable reporting period (such as calendar
quarter). The expiration date for a binary KPI option will be the date
on which an issuer discloses its earnings results (that include the
applicable KPI) for the specified reporting period (such as the date on
which an issuer will issue its earnings results press release). The
specific expiration date for a binary KPI option series will be
finalized when an issuer announces the date on which it will disclose
its earnings results (that include the applicable KPI) for that

[[Page 75392]]

reporting period.\32\ If that date is a Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday,
or Friday and the Exchange is not open for business on that date, the
expiration date will be the first business day immediately prior to
that day. If that date is a Monday and the Exchange is not open for
business on that date, the expiration date will be the first business
day immediately following that Monday. The disclosed KPIs relate to a
specific time period (such as a month or calendar quarter), which KPIs
an issuer publicly discloses on a date following the end of the
applicable reporting period.\33\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\31\ This is the same as Cboe Rule 4.82(b).
\32\ For example, for a binary KPI option series, the Exchange
may designate the reporting period for a series to be the fourth
quarter of 2026. The expiration date for that series would be the
date the applicable issuer establishes as the date it will disclose
earnings results for that quarter. The Exchange will notify Options
Members regarding finalized expiration dates for binary KPI options
once known.
\33\ While earnings results are often reported with respect to
the time period covered by the issuer's earnings release, such as a
calendar quarter, certain issuers may disclose results for different
time periods. For example, it is possible in an earnings release for
an issuer to announce a KPI that covers a calendar month rather than
a calendar quarter.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

While an expiration date for a binary KPI option will be a specific
date, as is the case for traditional options, the Exchange's proposed
designation of expiration dates for binary KPI options will differ to
reflect standard issuer disclosure practices. In some instances, an
issuer might not establish the specific date on which it will disclose
its earnings results for a reporting period until weeks prior to the
disclosure date. Consequently, unlike standard equity and index options
that have an exact expiration date when strikes are first listed, a
binary KPI option will be listed for trading with a placeholder
expiration date if the date the KPI information will be released by the
issuer is not publicly known. If a placeholder expiration date is
required, it will be set as the first trading day following the date of
the deadline for the issuer's submission of its earnings-related filing
for the reporting period applicable to the series. Once an issuer
announces the disclosure date of the KPI information, the expiration
date will be updated as the finalized expiration date of the option
contract.\34\ Ultimately, the expiration date for a binary KPI option
is the issuer's earnings disclosure date, even if that date is unknown
at the time the series is listed.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\34\ Issuers have different practices as to when they disclose
their earnings results (and when they announce their earnings
disclosure dates); however, each issuer's practice is generally
consistent and predictable.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

The Exchange may designate binary KPI option series to expire up to
12 months from the time they are listed and may list up to two
expirations at one time for a binary KPI option (per KPI per issuer).
The Exchange may open for trading a series of binary KPI options at
least one business week prior to the expiration date of a binary KPI
option. The proposed permissible expirations for binary KPI options are
the same as those permitted for binary KPI options under the Cboe
Rules.\35\ First, the proposed rule change permits the Exchange to list
binary KPI options to expire up to 12 months from the time they are
listed. The proposed rule change also limits the Exchange to list up to
two expirations at one time for binary KPI options. As noted in the
Cboe Proposal, the proposed scope of permissible expirations for binary
KPI options is narrower than that permitted for binary index options
under Cboe's rules (as previously approved by the Commission), which
permit expirations out more than 12 months up to 36 months from the
time they are listed.\36\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\35\ See Cboe Rule 4.82(b).
\36\ See Cboe Rule 4.72; Cboe Approval Order, supra note 5, 91
FR at 65857.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

The proposal to list expirations at least one business week prior
to the expiration date of binary KPI option (as well as the proposed
language regarding shifting an expiration date to the business day
immediately before or after an expiration date that falls on a day the
Exchange is not open for business) is the same as Cboe Rule 4.82(b)(1)
and (3) and is substantially similar to current Exchange Rules
applicable to Short Term Option Series,\37\ as well as the rules of
another options exchange applicable to binary equity options.\38\ The
Exchange believes it is appropriate to permit listing of binary KPI
options that expire up to 12 months from the time they are listed to
accommodate different issuer reporting periods, as well as to permit
the Exchange to list expirations for consecutive calendar quarter
periods or for a calendar quarter and annual reporting period at the
same time. As discussed above, issuers disclose KPIs in their earnings-
related filings submitted to the Commission.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\37\ See Rule 16.1 (definition of Short Term Option Series) and
Rule 19.5, Interpretation and Policy .05.
\38\ See NYSE American, LLC Section 17, Rule 903ByRDs.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Proposed Rule 30.3(c) describes the automatic exercise feature of
binary KPI options. Specifically, proposed Rule 30.3(c) provides that
binary KPI options will be automatically exercised at expiration if the
settlement value of the underlying KPI is equal to or greater than the
exercise price of a call binary KPI option or less than the exercise
price of a put binary KPI option.\39\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\39\ This is the same as Cboe Rule 6.20(g)(2).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Proposed Rule 30.3(d) describes the permissible exercise prices (or
strike prices) the Exchange may designate for binary KPI option series.
Proposed Rule 30.3(d)(1) describes how the value of exercise prices of
binary KPI option series are measured.\40\ Specifically, the exercise
price of each binary KPI option series will be a fixed amount equal to
an underlying KPI value. Because the value of certain KPIs may be very
large (e.g., billions of dollars), the Exchange proposes that the
exercise price for a binary KPI option will be the underlying KPI
divided by a scaling factor based on the value of the KPI in the
issuer's most recent earnings-related filings submitted to the
Commission as of the time a binary KPI option class is listed as
follows:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\40\ This is substantially the same as Cboe Rule 4.82(c)(1),
other than the correction of a typographical error in proposed Rule
30.3(d)(1)(A).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

if the most recently disclosed KPI value is greater than
or equal to one trillion, the exercise price equals that value divided
by one trillion (e.g., for such KPIs, an exercise price of 27.00 is
equivalent to a KPI value of 27,000,000,000,000.00);
if the most recently disclosed KPI value is greater than
or equal to one billion but less than one trillion, the exercise price
equals that value divided by one billion (e.g., for such KPIs, an
exercise price of 112.00 is equivalent to a KPI value of
112,000,000,000.00);
if the most recently disclosed KPI value is greater than
or equal to one million but less than one billion, the exercise price
equals that value divided by one million (e.g., for such KPIs, an
exercise price of 900.00 is equivalent to a KPI value of
900,000,000.00);
if the most recently disclosed KPI value is greater than
or equal to one thousand but less than one million, the exercise price
equals that value divided by one thousand (e.g., for such KPIs, an
exercise price of 42.00 is equivalent to a KPI value of 42,000.00); and
if the most recently disclosed KPI value is less than one
thousand, the exercise price equals that value and is not divided by a
scaling factor (e.g., for such KPIs, an exercise price of 774.00 is
equivalent to a KPI value of 774.00).\41\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\41\ When applying the scaling factor, the Exchange will not
round the scaled KPI value and instead will truncate the value to
fit the scaled strike price value within standard strike listing
format.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

The Exchange will apply a different scaling factor to newly listed
binary KPI option series for a new expiration only after the value of
the KPI in the issuer's earnings-related filings submitted to the

[[Page 75393]]

Commission has a value in a different scaling tier for four consecutive
reporting periods or if the Exchange deems it necessary in the
interests of a fair and orderly market. Application of a different
scaling factor will not affect the exercise prices of any series of the
binary KPI options previously opened. For example, if the Exchange
begins listing a new class of binary KPI options and the most recently
disclosed KPI value for the issuer at the time of that listing was for
the third quarter of 2026 and was $892,000, the exercise prices for
that class of binary KPI options will be scaled by 1,000, and thus
exercise prices of 895, 995, and 1005, would represent $895,000,
$995,000, and $1,005,000, respectively. If the issuer discloses a KPI
value of $1,020,000 in its fourth quarter 2026 earnings disclosure, the
Exchange will continue to list exercise prices scaled by 1,000. If the
issuer then discloses KPI values of $1,112,000, $1,237,000, and
$1,064,000 for the first, second, and third quarters, respectively, of
2027, the Exchange will begin scaling the exercise prices by 1,000,000
for the fourth quarter 2027 expirations (or for the first quarter 2028
expirations if the Exchange had already listed fourth quarter 2027
expirations prior to the disclosure of the third quarter 2027 KPI
value). The Exchange believes this will permit consistency for listing
scaled KPI values while allowing the Exchange to update strike prices
to reflect long-term changes to an issuer's KPI values.
The Exchange will announce in a notice to Options Members if the
scaling factor applied to a binary KPI option class changes (for
example, the KPIs will be scaled in billions rather than in millions).
It is possible for a KPI to have a negative value, such as earnings
per share (which is equivalent to a loss per share). Proposed Rule
30.3(d)(1)(B) provides the Exchange may list binary KPI options series
with exercise prices representing negative KPI values.\42\ For these
series, the exercise price will equal the absolute value of the KPI and
will be scaled as described above. For example, if an issuer's earnings
per share in the last reporting period was -$3.52 (and thus was a loss
per share), a binary KPI option for such issuer with a strike of 3.58
will reflect an expected loss of $3.58 per share. The Exchange will
incorporate into symbology for binary KPI options whether the value of
the strike price is positive or negative, including if the Exchange
lists binary KPI option series with both positive and negative strike
prices. Whether a symbol reflects a positive or negative value will be
available in contract specifications.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\42\ This is the same as Cboe Rule 4.82(c)(1)(B).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Proposed Rule 30.3(d)(2) provides the minimum interval between
strike prices for binary KPI options series is: \43\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\43\ This is the same as Cboe Rule 4.82(c)(2).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

0.01 where the strike price is less than 10;
0.10 where the strike price is 10 or greater but less than
100;
1.00 where the strike price is 100 or greater but less
than 1,000;
10.00 where the strike price is 1,000 or greater but less
than 10,000; and
100.00 where the strike price is 10,000 or greater.
As discussed above, while KPI values above 1,000 are generally
scaled, there may be circumstances in which the Exchange lists strikes
above 1,000 or even 10,000 given the Exchange's proposal to maintain a
lower scale level until a KPI value is consistently above a certain
level (e.g., above one billion for four consecutive quarters). This may
occur when a KPI value is near the top of a scaling range; for
continuity, the Exchange will continue listing strike prices using the
lower scaling factor and not change to a higher scaling factor until
the KPI value is regularly within that higher range (as noted above).
Suppose a KPI value is 995,000,000; in this case, strike prices will be
scaled by 1,000,000. Thus, the Exchange may list binary KPI options
above and below 995 (995,000,000 divided by 1,000,000). However, it is
realistic that the KPI may increase to above 1,000,000,000. As
proposed, the Exchange may list strike prices, for example, of 1,000
(representing 1,000,000,000) and above, for expirations until the KPI
value is above 1,000,000,000 for four consecutive reporting periods. To
reduce confusion, the Exchange would not scale strike prices using
different scaling factors within a single expiration (and would not
change the scale until the KPI value is consistently at the higher
level). Therefore, it is possible the Exchange may list strikes greater
than 1,000. Similarly, while strikes above 10,000 may be rare, given
the Exchange proposes to maintain a lower scale level until a KPI value
is consistently above a certain level (e.g., above one billion for four
consecutive quarters, as proposed), depending on market factors and
demand, it is possible (although unlikely) the Exchange may determine
it is appropriate to list strikes above 10,000 if market factors or
expectations signify a significant increase of the KPI value. The
proposed strike intervals accommodate the listing of binary KPI options
in these circumstances before the Exchange shifts the strike prices for
an issuer's KPI to a different scaling level.
The proposed strike intervals are generally consistent with current
Rules for other options, which provide for larger strike intervals as
the values of strike prices increase. Given the scaling factors for
larger KPI values, it may appear the proposed rule change will permit
smaller strike intervals for larger KPI values if those intervals are
considered solely on a nominal basis. However, that is not the case if
the actual values of the strike intervals are considered. The
corresponding actual value of the strike interval for a strike price
that was subject to a larger scale value is higher than the actual
value of the strike interval for a strike price that was subject to a
smaller scale value. For example, suppose a strike price of 950
represents $950 million. The proposed rule change would permit strike
intervals of $1.00. However, that $1.00 corresponds to $1,000,000. In
other words, if the Exchange listed strikes of 950, 951, and 952, the
difference in the actual value between those strikes is $1,000,000, not
$1 (i.e., the strikes represent values of $950,000,000, $951,000,000,
and $952,000,000). Similarly, suppose a strike price of 3 represents
$3,000,000,000. The proposed rule change would permit strike intervals
of $0.01. However, in this case, that $0.01 corresponds to $10,000,000.
If the Exchange listed strikes of 3.00, 3.01, and 3.02, the difference
in the actual value between those strikes is $10,000,000, not $0.01
(i.e., the strikes represent values of $3,000,000,000, $3,010,000,000,
and $3,020,000,000, respectively). As a result, the permissible strike
intervals between strike prices representing values in the billions are
actually larger than the permissible strike intervals between strike
prices representing values in the millions. This is consistent with the
general premise underlying current strike intervals that larger strike
intervals apply to larger strike values.
Proposed Rule 30.3(e) provides that, notwithstanding Rule 21.4(a)
(which provides that orders are expressed in terms of dollars per unit
of the underlying security), bids and offers for a binary KPI option
with a multiplier other than 100 must be expressed in terms of dollars
per 1/multiplier of the total value of the contract.\44\ For example,
if a binary KPI option has a

[[Page 75394]]

multiplier of 1, an offer of ``0.50'' represents an offer of $0.50.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\44\ This is substantially the same as Cboe Rule 5.3(c)(3),
which applies to all binary options listed on Cboe.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Proposed Rule 30.3(f) describes the initial series of a binary KPI
option the Exchange may open for trading.\45\ Specifically, the
Exchange may open for trading one or more binary KPI option series with
a fixed KPI value as the strike price (scaled as described above), with
approximately the same number of strike prices being opened above and
below the at-the-money KPI value at the time the binary KPI option
series are opened. The ``at-the-money'' KPI value may be the value of
the KPI in the issuer's most recent earnings-related filing submitted
to the Commission, the issuer's disclosed estimate of the KPI for the
next reporting period, or analysts' consensus estimate as reported by
major market vendors, as the Exchange deems appropriate based on the
most recent market information available to the Exchange. Because KPIs
are static values, the Exchange believes it is appropriate to determine
strike prices based on all available information that would inform
expectations about the KPIs (as investors would do). The Exchange
understands that an issuer's previously disclosed KPI, as well as
issuer and analyst estimates of the KPI, are primary factors investors
may consider when determining in which direction the KPI value may move
in the next reporting period (similar to how investors consider the
then-current price of an underlying stock when considering their
options investment strategies and which direction the stock price may
move). Therefore, the Exchange believes using the most recently
available of these values is appropriate to use for determining which
strikes it should list for a specific issuer KPI. The Exchange believes
this flexibility to select the most appropriate at-the-money value is
similar to current Rules that permit the Exchange to list additional
series to maintain an orderly market, to meet customer demand, or when
the market price of the underlying security moves substantially.\46\
The Exchange believes the proposed definition of at-the-money will
allow the Exchange to list series with strike prices that are
consistent with investor expectations and demands and that are based on
information available in the market.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\45\ This is the same as Cboe Rule 4.82(d), other than a
conforming cross-reference.
\46\ See, e.g., Rule 19.5, Interpretation and Policy .05(d).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

The Exchange will list strike prices for binary KPI option series
that are reasonably close to the at-the-money KPI value at the time of
listing. A strike is ``reasonably close'' to the at-the-money KPI value
if (1) for KPIs less than or equal to 1, it is no more than 2; \47\ (2)
for KPIs greater than 1 and less than or equal to 10, it is no more
than 100% above or below the at-the-money KPI value; and (3) for KPIs
greater than 10, it is no more than 30% above or below the at-the-money
KPI value. The Exchange may also open binary KPI option series that are
more than 30% above or below the at-the-money KPI value (if the KPI is
greater than 10) if demonstrated customer interest exists for such
series, as expressed by institutional, corporate or individual
customers or their brokers.\48\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\47\ The Exchange believes this is appropriate given the
potentially small values of certain KPIs. For example, suppose the
second quarter earnings per share of a company was $0.04. In such a
case, if strikes were limited to 100% above this value, the Exchange
could only list strikes up to $0.08, which would provide investors
with minimal investment options. Therefore, the Exchange believes
this provision is appropriate to provide the Exchange with authority
to list meaningful strikes for smaller-valued KPIs.
\48\ See, e.g., Rule 19.5, Interpretation and Policy .05(c) and
(d) (permissible series for Short Term Option Series).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

The Exchange may add new binary KPI option series when the Exchange
deems it necessary to maintain a fair and orderly market or to meet
customer demand, and the opening of a new series of binary KPI options
on the Exchange will not affect any other series of options of the same
binary KPI option class previously opened.\49\ The Exchange may list
additional series using updated at-the-money KPI values, such as if the
Exchange lists binary KPI options series for an expiration before the
applicable issuer has disclosed the KPI value in a filing submitted to
the Commission for the immediately preceding reporting period and that
value is then disclosed in a filing submitted to the Commission or if
the issuer or major market data vendors publish estimates of the KPI
value. For example, before expiration of a binary KPI option series set
to expire on the date of an issuer's disclosure of its third quarter
earnings results, the Exchange lists series of that binary KPI option
to expire on the date of an issuer's disclosure of its fourth quarter
earnings results (using the KPI from the issuer's second quarter
earnings results as the at-the-money KPI value). After the issuer
discloses its third quarter earnings results in a filing submitted to
the Commission, including the applicable KPI, the Exchange may list
additional series for the fourth quarter binary KPI options using the
third quarter KPI result as the at-the-money KPI value. Suppose,
further, that after the issuer discloses its third quarter earnings
results, the issuer publishes an estimate of the fourth quarter KPI
value. As investors may see this estimate (and possibly factor it into
their investment decisions), the Exchange may determine it is
appropriate to consider this estimate the ``at-the-money'' value and
list additional strikes above and below this value. Any additional
strike prices the Exchange lists will be reasonably close (as defined
in proposed Rule 30.3(f)) to the at-the-money KPI value at the time of
listing.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\49\ This is substantially the same as Cboe Rule 4.82(e).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Continuing the above example, suppose the Exchange lists binary KPI
options for the fourth quarter before the binary KPI options for the
third quarter have expired. As proposed, the Exchange would list
strikes above and below the at-the-money strike, which at the time of
listing may be the settlement value KPI from the issuer's second
quarter earnings results disclosure (the most recently available KPI).
If the KPI for the option was net sales, and the second quarter value
was $45.093 billion, the at-the-money strike would be 45.10, and the
Exchange could list strikes within 30% of that value, and additional
series based on customer demand or market changes. After the Exchange
lists those series, the issuer discloses its third quarter earnings
results, including net sales of $57.241 billion. As proposed, after
that disclosure, the Exchange may list additional strikes within 30% of
$57.24 to reflect the change in value of the underlying (as well as
additional series based on customer demand or market changes).
This proposed framework for listing and adding series is similar to
the framework in current Rules for listing and adding series of equity
options.\50\ While the proposed strike intervals are narrower than
these rules, the permissible ranges are also narrower. The Exchange
acknowledges the proposed framework would permit the Exchange to list
many strikes per KPI per expiration. However, the Exchange intends to
apply its standard strike listing practices to binary KPI options.
Specifically, the Exchange generally lists strikes at wider intervals
as they move farther away from the at-the-money value, while listing
more granular intervals for strikes closer to the at-the-money value.
The Exchange also generally delists granular strikes that are deep out-
of-the-money if the Exchange determines they are

[[Page 75395]]

sufficiently covered by wider strike intervals that are close in value.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\50\ See, e.g., Rule 19.5, Interpretation and Policy .05(c) and
(d).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

These proposed provisions regarding the listing of binary KPI
option series are similar to provisions regarding permissible series of
other options. The Exchange believes it is reasonable to list binary
KPI options for a new reporting period prior to the expiration of then-
listed binary KPI options for the immediately preceding reporting
period (e.g., listing binary KPI options for the fourth quarter before
expiration of binary KPI options for the third quarter), and thus
before the settlement value of the applicable KPI is known for the
immediately preceding reporting period for these options, to permit
investors to roll positions from one expiration to the next. As
proposed, once the settlement value for the immediately preceding
reporting period is known (the third quarter in this example), the
Exchange may list additional series of the binary KPI options that
reflect that KPI value. This is consistent with current practice if
there is a change (including a substantial change) in the price of an
underlying security or value of an underlying index. For example, Rule
19.5, Interpretation and Policy .05(d) permits the Exchange to open
additional series of a short-term option series overlying a security
when the market price of the underlying security moves substantially
from the exercise price or prices of the series already opened, subject
to the ``reasonably close'' parameters set forth in that Rule.
Disclosure of, as an example, the third quarter KPI value after the
fourth quarter binary KPI options series were listed based on the
second quarter KPI value (if the third quarter KPI value differs from
the second quarter KPI value) is similar to a move in the price of an
underlying security, which may result in the Exchange listing
additional series based on the updated price of the underlying
security. Similarly consistent with current practice for other options
(as set forth in Rule 19.5, Interpretation and Policy .05(d), for
example), opening of binary KPI options based on this later-disclosed
KPI value will not affect any other series of options of the same
binary KPI options class previously opened.
Proposed Rule 30.3(h) provides that the contract multiplier for
each class of binary KPI options is one.\51\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\51\ This is the same as Cboe Rule 4.82(f).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Proposed Rule 30.4 (Determination of Settlement Value)
The Exchange proposes to add new Rule 30.4 (Determination of
Settlement Value) to establish that binary KPI options that are ``at-
the-money,'' ``in-the-money,'' or ``out-of-the-money'' are a function
of the settlement value of the underlying KPI in relation to the type
of binary KPI option (i.e., put or call) and the exercise price.\52\ As
described above, the settlement value for a binary KPI option is the
value of the KPI for the applicable reporting period as disclosed in
the applicable issuer's earnings-related filing submitted to the
Commission. While the Exchange factors the timing of an issuer's
disclosure of a KPI value into the determination of whether the
Exchange lists a binary KPI option as A.M.-settled or P.M.-settled, the
Exchange will source the settlement value from the earnings-related
filing for the applicable reporting period that the issuer submits to
the Commission. Generally, companies issue press releases that contain
earnings results and near contemporaneously submit a Form 8-K to the
Commission with the press release as an exhibit. Therefore, it is
unlikely the value of the KPI in the Commission filing will differ from
the value in the initial disclosure; however, the value in the
Commission filing will be the ultimate settlement value.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\52\ This is the same as Cboe Rule 4.83.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Proposed Rule 30.5 (Adjustment)
Proposed Rule 30.5 (Adjustment) provides that binary KPI option
contracts are subject to adjustment only in accordance with and to the
extent specified in the Rules of the Clearing Corporation. When any
such adjustment has been determined, the Exchange will announce this
adjustment, which will become effective as of the time specified in
that announcement.\53\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\53\ This is the same as Cboe Rule 4.84. This is also consistent
with how adjustments are handled for other options listed on the
Exchange. See Rule 19.6.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Proposed Rule 30.6 (Binary KPI Options Trading Hours)
Next, the Exchange proposes to adopt Rule 30.6(a), which provides
that Regular Trading Hours for binary KPI options are from 9:30 a.m. to
4:00 p.m.\54\ Further, proposed Rules 30.6(b) and (c) provide that the
last day of trading for P.M.-settled binary KPI options is the day of
expiration, and the last day of trading for A.M.-settled binary KPI
options is the trading day prior to expiration.\55\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\54\ This is the same as Cboe Rule 5.1(b)(3)(F) and is
consistent with the hours during which other options listed on the
Exchange may be traded. See Rule 21.2(a). As set forth in Rule
1.5(bb), Regular Trading Hours is the time between 9:30 a.m. and
4:00 p.m. Eastern Time, and all times referenced in proposed Rule
30.6 are Eastern Time.
\55\ This is the same as Cboe Rule 5.1(b)(3)(F)(i) and (ii).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

The Exchange recognizes it is possible, although unusual and
unlikely, that an issuer's KPI information may become available at
unexpected times. Proposed Rules 30.6(d) and (e) address the impact on
trading and expiration that such disclosure may have.\56\ First, the
proposed rule change provides if the Exchange confirms an issuer
discloses the KPI prior to the expiration date (i.e., the date on which
the issuer had announced it would disclose its earnings results for the
applicable reporting period), trading in the applicable binary KPI
options series will cease, and the expiration date for the option
accelerates to a date on or shortly after the date of that disclosure
in accordance with the Rules of the Clearing Corporation.\57\ This may
occur if, for example, the applicable issuer releases the KPI
information in advance of the expiration date of the option. If the
issuer releases KPI information after the expiration date, which may be
the case if, for example, the issuer's disclosure of its earnings is
delayed, trading in the option will not be impacted and will cease as
of the expiration date. While the expiration date will not change,
expiration and settlement processing of such options will be delayed
until the KPI information becomes available, in accordance with the
Rules of the Clearing Corporation. Additionally, the proposed rule
change provides if there is an unofficial disclosure \58\ of the KPI
prior to the expiration date, the Exchange may determine to halt (and
resume) trading in the applicable binary KPI options series in
accordance with Rule 20.3. In certain circumstances, the expiration
date for the option may accelerate in accordance with the Rules of the
Clearing Corporation; if this occurs, trading in the binary KPI option
series will cease.\59\ This proposed provision addresses the unlikely
event that KPI information becomes available through sources other than
the issuer in

[[Page 75396]]

advance of the expiration date. If the Exchange determines the KPI
information reported from the unofficial source is unreliable, trading
in the binary KPI option may resume until it expires.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\56\ Proposed Rules 30.6(d) and (e) are the same as Cboe Rules
5.1(b)(3)(F)(iii) and (iv) (other than the conforming reference to
Rule 20.3 and the correction of a typographical error in proposed
Rule 30.6(e)).
\57\ The proposed acceleration of binary KPI options is similar
to the existing acceleration process for equity options when the
underlying security of such options has been converted entirely to
cash. See OCC Rule 807.
\58\ Unofficial disclosure of a KPI may include, for example, an
unsanctioned leak of the KPI or disclosure of the KPI by a source
other than the issuer.
\59\ Rule 20.3(a) provides that the Exchange may halt trading in
any option contract in the interests of a fair and orderly market,
and sets forth factors the Exchange will consider in determining
whether trading in an option contract should be halted.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

The Exchange proposes to adopt Rule 30.6(f), which provides that,
for binary KPI options, the System shall open for trading in accordance
with Rule 21.7 (Market Opening Procedures), with the stock of the
issuer treated as the security underlying the option for purposes of
that Rule. Rule 21.7(a) provides that the System opens options (other
than index options) for trading after the System's observation after
9:30 a.m. of both (i) the first transaction on the primary listing
market in the security underlying the option and (ii) the Limit Up-
Limit Down price bands applicable to the security underlying the option
as disseminated by the applicable securities information processor.
Rule 21.7(b) provides that, in the event the underlying security has
not opened within a reasonable time after 9:30 a.m., the Exchange will
determine the cause of the delay, and the beginning of trading in the
options class will be delayed until the market for the underlying
security has opened unless the Exchange determines that the interests
of a fair and orderly market are best served by opening trading in the
options contracts. Rule 21.7(c) provides that the Exchange may delay
the commencement of trading in any class of options in the interests of
a fair and orderly market.
Rather than adopt a fixed-time opening trigger,\60\ the Exchange
proposes to apply its existing opening procedures for equity options to
binary KPI options, using the issuer's stock as the reference security
for purposes of those procedures. The issuers of the KPIs that may
underlie binary KPI options are large, actively traded issuers whose
stocks generally open for trading on their primary listing markets
promptly after 9:30 a.m. Therefore, under normal market conditions, the
Exchange expects binary KPI options to open for trading at or shortly
after 9:30 a.m., consistent with the opening of binary KPI options on
Cboe. The Exchange believes the proposed approach is appropriate and
conservative, as it will use the opening of trading in the issuer's
stock as an objective and readily observable reference point for the
commencement of trading in binary KPI options, and will permit the
Exchange to delay the opening of binary KPI options pursuant to Rule
21.7(b) if the opening of the issuer's stock is delayed (for example,
because of unusual circumstances relating to the issuer). The proposed
approach will also allow the Exchange to use its existing, well-
established opening process for binary KPI options without requiring
development of a separate opening process for a single product.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\60\ See Cboe Rule 5.31(d)(1)(D). Cboe noted that its fixed-time
trigger is analogous to the opening process for its VIX options. See
Cboe Approval Order, supra note 5, 91 FR at 65861.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Proposed Rule 30.8 (Minimum Increments for Bids and Offers)
The Exchange proposes to adopt Rule 30.8, which provides that,
notwithstanding Rule 21.5, the Exchange shall establish the minimum
increment for bids and offers on orders for binary KPI options on a
class-by-class basis, which may not be less than $0.01.\61\ Because
binary KPI options have a maximum exercise settlement amount of $1, the
Exchange believes it is necessary to permit the Exchange to establish
minimum increments as small as $0.01 to permit binary KPI options to be
quoted and traded at prices that meaningfully reflect the market's
valuation of the applicable KPI outcome.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\61\ This is substantially the same as Cboe Rule 5.4(c)(1),
which provides that Cboe establishes the minimum increment for bids
and offers on orders for binary options (including binary index
options and binary KPI options) on a class-by-class basis, which may
not be less than $0.01.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Proposed Rule 21.17(h) (Maximum Execution Price Protection)
The Exchange proposes to adopt a maximum execution price protection
mechanism for binary KPI options. Specifically, proposed Rule 21.17(h)
permits the Exchange to apply a maximum execution price protection for
binary KPI options on a class basis, pursuant to which the System
prevents an execution of a binary KPI option at a price above the
Exchange-designated maximum execution price for that class.\62\ Binary
options have a maximum value equivalent to the exercise settlement
amount (i.e., the cash payout amount). Therefore, the Exchange believes
it is reasonable to prevent executions from occurring at prices above
that maximum value, as it protects investors from execution prices that
are potentially erroneous.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\62\ This is substantially similar to Cboe Rule 5.34(d), which
applies to all binary options listed on Cboe, except that Cboe Rule
5.34(d) provides that the System adjusts any execution price for a
binary option above the Exchange-designated maximum execution price
for that class down to that maximum execution price, whereas
proposed Rule 21.17(h) provides that the System prevents an
execution of a binary KPI option at a price above the Exchange-
designated maximum execution price for that class. Under either
approach, binary KPI options will not execute at prices above the
designated maximum execution price.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

The Exchange will notify Options Members of the maximum execution
price it designates for each binary KPI option class, and, pursuant to
Rule 21.17, the Exchange will maintain the maximum execution price for
each binary KPI option class in publicly available specifications and/
or publish it in a Regulatory Circular.\63\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\63\ See Rule 21.17 (providing that all numeric values
established by the Exchange pursuant to Rule 21.17 will be
maintained by the Exchange in publicly available specifications and/
or published in a Regulatory Circular).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Proposed Rule 20.6(m) (Obvious Errors)
The Exchange proposes to add Rule 20.6(m), which provides that Rule
20.6 does not apply to binary KPI options.\64\ While the obvious error
provisions set forth in Rule 20.6 will not be applicable to binary KPI
options, the Exchange believes the proposed maximum execution price
protection in proposed Rule 21.17(h) may prevent executions at
potentially erroneous prices, obviating the need for an obvious error
process for binary KPI options.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\64\ This is the same as Cboe Rule 6.5, Interpretation and
Policy .10, other than a conforming reference to Rule 20.6.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Proposed Rule 30.7 (Position Limits for Binary KPI Options)
The Exchange proposes to adopt Rule 30.7 to set forth position
limit requirements for binary KPI options. Proposed Rule 30.7(a)
provides that, in determining compliance with Rule 18.7 (Position
Limits), the position limit for binary KPI options is 25,000 standard
option contracts per expiration and 100 binary KPI option contracts
equal one standard option contract.\65\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\65\ This is the same as Cboe Rule 8.36(a)(3), other than a
conforming reference to Rule 18.7.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Proposed Rule 30.7(b) provides that positions in binary KPI options
on the same KPI that have different expiration dates are not aggregated
(as proposed position limits are calculated per expiration), and
positions in binary KPI options for the same issuer with different
underlying KPIs are not aggregated (as binary KPI options overlying
different KPIs, even for the same issuer, are different classes, as
discussed above).\66\ Proposed Rule 30.7(c) provides that binary KPI
options are not aggregated with non-binary options contracts overlying
the stock of the issuer.\67\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\66\ This is the same as Cboe Rule 8.36(b)(2).
\67\ This is the same as Cboe Rule 8.36(c)(2).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Proposed Rule 30.7(d) provides that, for purposes of the position
limits established under proposed Rule 30.7, long positions in put
binary KPI options

[[Page 75397]]

and short positions in call binary KPI options are considered to be on
the same side of the market, and short positions in put binary KPI
options and long positions in call binary KPI options are considered to
be on the same side of the market.\68\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\68\ This is substantially the same as Cboe Rule 8.36(d), which
applies to all binary options listed on Cboe. This is also
consistent with how positions are combined for purposes of
determining compliance with position limits for other options listed
on the Exchange. See Rule 18.7(a)(1).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Proposed Rule 30.7(e) provides that binary KPI options are not
subject to any hedge exemptions from standard position limits,
including any such exemption granted by another options exchange upon
which an Options Member may rely pursuant to Rule 18.8.\69\ Proposed
Rule 30.7(e) further provides that, notwithstanding paragraph (a), a
binary KPI option short put position coupled with a binary KPI option
short call position held by a Market Maker, regardless of the binary
KPI option strike price, shall be exempt from the established position
limits prescribed in Rule 30.7.\70\ Given the retail nature of binary
KPI options, the Exchange expects investors to primarily buy binary KPI
options. Liquidity providers, as a result, may amass short positions to
facilitate investors' purchases of binary KPI positions. The proposed
hedge exemption is intended to exclude offsetting pairs of these short
positions from counting towards position limits so that such position
limits do not restrict liquidity providers' ability to provide
liquidity in the market. Traditional equity hedge exemptions, such as
those set forth in Cboe Rule 8.30, Interpretation and Policy .04
(Equity Hedge Exemptions), upon which Options Members may rely for
equity options listed on the Exchange pursuant to Rule 18.8, are
inapplicable to the proposed binary KPI options. For example, under
Cboe Rule 8.30, Interpretation and Policy .04(a)(2), a long call
position accompanied by a short put position, where the long call
expires with the short put, and the strike price of the long call and
short put is equal, and where each long call and short put position is
hedged with 100 shares are exempt from position limits. The Exchange
proposes a hedge exemption specific to binary KPI options. The Exchange
believes that exempting offsetting short binary KPI option will provide
liquidity providers with an opportunity to exempt their hedge positions
from position limits in a similar manner as they can for equity
options.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\69\ Cboe Rule 8.36(e) provides that binary options are not
subject to the hedge exemption to the standard position limits found
in Cboe Rule 8.30. The Exchange's Rules do not include equity hedge
exemptions. Rather, Rule 18.8 provides that an Options Member may
rely upon any available exemptions from applicable position limits
granted from time to time by another options exchange for any
options contract traded on the Exchange, subject to certain
conditions. Proposed Rule 30.7(e) makes clear that an Options Member
may not rely on Rule 18.8 to apply a hedge exemption granted by
another options exchange to binary KPI options, which achieves the
same result as Cboe Rule 8.36(e).
\70\ This is substantially the same as Cboe Rule 8.36(e)(2).
Rule 16.1 defines ``Market Maker'' as an Options Member registered
with the Exchange for the purpose of making markets in options
contracts traded on the Exchange and that is vested with the rights
and responsibilities specified in Chapter 22 of the Rules.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Proposed Rule 30.7(f) addresses reports related to position limits
for binary KPI options. Rule 18.10(a) provides that, in a manner and
form prescribed by the Exchange, each Options Member shall report to
the Exchange the name, address, and social security or tax
identification number of any customer who, acting alone, or in concert
with others, on the previous business day maintained aggregate long or
short positions on the same side of the market of 200 or more contracts
of any single class of option contracts dealt in on the Exchange.
Proposed Rule 30.7(f) provides that, in computing reportable positions
in binary KPI options under Rule 18.10, (1) positions in binary KPI
options are not aggregated with non-binary option contracts overlying
the stock of the issuer and (2) for purposes of the report required by
Rule 18.10(a), 100 binary KPI option contracts equal one standard
option contract.\71\ The Exchange believes this is reasonable given
that binary KPI options have a multiplier of 1 while standard equity
option contracts have a multiplier of 100.\72\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\71\ This is substantially the same as Cboe Rule 8.43(f), which
provides that, in computing reportable binary options, positions in
binary options are not aggregated with non-binary option contracts
on the same or similar underlying security or index, and that, for
purposes of the report required by Cboe Rule 8.43(a), 100 binary KPI
option contracts equal one standard option contract.
\72\ This is consistent with the proposed rule change discussed
above that 100 binary KPI option contracts equal one standard option
contract for purposes of determining compliance with Rule 18.7.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Proposed Rule 30.9 (Margin)
Pursuant to current margin rules, binary KPI options listed on Cboe
will be fully funded.\73\ Specifically, Cboe Rule 10.3(m) provides that
no binary option carried for a customer is considered of any value for
purposes of computing the margin required in the customer's account;
that the initial and maintenance margin required on a binary option
carried long is 100% of the purchase price of the binary option; and
that the initial and maintenance margin required on a binary option
carried short is the exercise settlement amount (subject to specified
spread and straddle/combination provisions). Cboe Rule 10.3(m) also
sets forth the circumstances in which a short binary option is deemed a
covered position eligible for the cash account (including if cash or
cash equivalents equal to 100% of the exercise settlement amount are
held in the account). Rule 28.3 requires each Options Member or
associated person to be bound by the initial and maintenance margin
requirements of either Cboe or the New York Stock Exchange (``NYSE''),
as elected in writing by the Options Member or associated person, and
provides that, upon such election, the Options Member or associated
person shall be bound to comply with the margin rules of Cboe or the
NYSE, as applicable, as though such rules were part of the Rules. To
ensure that the same margin requirements apply to all binary KPI
options listed on the Exchange (and that such requirements are the same
as those that apply to binary KPI options listed on Cboe), the Exchange
proposes to adopt Rule 30.9, which provides that, notwithstanding Rule
28.3, an Options Member or associated person must comply with the
margin requirements applicable to binary options set forth in Cboe Rule
10.3(m), as the same may be in effect from time to time, with respect
to binary KPI options, regardless of whether it has elected to be bound
by the margin rules of Cboe or the NYSE. Proposed Rule 30.9 further
provides that such requirements shall apply as though they were part of
the Rules, consistent with the existing framework in Rule 28.3. As a
result, binary KPI options listed on the Exchange will be fully funded
in the same manner as binary KPI options listed on Cboe.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\73\ See Cboe Approval Order, supra note 5, 91 FR at 65877
(citing Cboe Rule 10.3(m)); Cboe Rule 10.3(m).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Trading of Binary KPI Options on the Exchange
Except as otherwise described herein, all binary KPI options will
be listed and traded on the Exchange in a substantially similar manner
to standard equity and index options listed and traded under current
Rules. The Rules that apply to the listing and trading of non-binary
options on the Exchange, including those related to customer accounts,
margin requirements (pursuant to proposed Rule 30.9, binary KPI options
will be fully funded), and

[[Page 75398]]

trading halt procedures,\74\ which are designed to prevent fraudulent
and manipulative acts and practices, will apply to the listing and
trading of binary KPI options. The Exchange has analyzed its systems
capacity and represents that it believes the Exchange has the necessary
systems capacity to handle any potential additional message traffic
associated with the listing of binary KPI options.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\74\ Binary KPI options will not be automatically tied to the
trading state of the issuer's stock (other than with respect to the
opening of trading in binary KPI options pursuant to proposed Rule
30.6(f), as discussed above), and, thus, trading in binary KPI
options may not be affected by halts in the issuer's stock. The
binary KPI options will halt in accordance with current Rules,
including Rules 20.3 and 20.4.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Binary KPI options will be traded electronically on MEMX Options in
generally the same manner as other options listed on the Exchange, and
orders in binary KPI options will be executed in accordance with the
Exchange's existing order display and book processing rules.\75\ The
Exchange expects that the order types, order instructions, and times-
in-force available for other options listed on the Exchange will
generally be available for binary KPI options; however, pursuant to
Rule 21.1, the Exchange may determine which order types, order
instructions, and times-in-force are available for binary KPI options
on a class or system basis.\76\ Consistent with current practice, the
Exchange will notify Options Members if it chooses to restrict order
types, order instructions, or times-in-force available for binary KPI
options. Market Makers appointed in a binary KPI options class will be
subject to the obligations set forth in Chapter 22 of the Rules,
including the continuous quoting obligations in Rule 22.6(d). The
Exchange does not currently offer complex order functionality, auction
mechanisms, floor trading, or FLEX options on MEMX Options, and,
accordingly, such functionality will not be available for binary KPI
options.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\75\ See Rule 21.8.
\76\ See Rule 21.1(d), (e), and (g) (defining the order types,
order instructions, and times-in-force available on MEMX Options and
providing that the Exchange determines which are available on a
class or system basis).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

The Exchange will send quotation and transaction price information
for binary KPI options to The Options Price Reporting Authority
(``OPRA'') in the same manner it sends this information to OPRA for all
other options the Exchange lists. Additionally, the Exchange believes
that OPRA will disseminate information regarding binary KPI options in
the same manner it does for all other options the Exchange lists. The
Exchange intends to follow OPRA's standard capacity monitoring process
for binary KPI options (in accordance with OPRA instructions), which
includes submission of quarterly capacity projections (the Exchange
will include its projected binary KPI option volume in the applicable
submission). Further, the Exchange does not believe that technical
changes are required to accommodate the reporting to OPRA of quotation
and transaction information regarding binary KPI options (the Exchange
represents, if later required by OPRA, it will adhere to any new
technical requirements OPRA deems necessary to accommodate binary KPI
options).\77\ The Exchange does not believe Options Members will
experience any capacity issues as a result of this proposal and
represents that it will monitor the trading volume associated with
binary KPI options and the effect (if any) of binary KPI options on
market fragmentation and the capacity of the Exchange's automated
system.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\77\ OPRA may need to update how it disseminates open interest
information for binary KPI options to the extent the Clearing
Corporation is a registered clearing agency other than OCC, as
OPRA's current process incorporates information from OCC. In that
case, the Exchange will work with OPRA and the Clearing Corporation
to implement a process to provide OPRA with binary KPI option open
interest so OPRA may incorporate it into its dissemination process.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Surveillance
Today, the Exchange has an adequate surveillance program in place
for options. The Exchange intends to apply the same program procedures
to binary KPI options the Exchange applies to its other options
products. Additionally, the Exchange is a member of the Intermarket
Surveillance Group (``ISG'') under the Intermarket Surveillance Group
Agreement. ISG members work together to coordinate surveillance and
investigative information sharing in the stock, options, and futures
markets. In addition, the Exchange has a Regulatory Services Agreement
with the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority, Inc. (``FINRA'') for
certain market surveillance, investigation and examinations functions.
Pursuant to a multi-party 17d-2 joint plan, all options exchanges
allocate amongst themselves and FINRA responsibilities to conduct
certain options-related market surveillance that are common to rules of
all options exchanges.\78\ All options exchanges are also parties to
the Options Regulatory Surveillance Authority plan under Regulation NMS
Rule 608, pursuant to which FINRA conducts options-related insider
trading surveillance, investigations, and enforcement for the U.S.
options markets. The Exchange believes its existing surveillance
procedures are designed to deter and detect possible manipulative
behavior which might potentially arise from listing and trading the
proposed binary options. Further, the Exchange will implement any new
surveillance procedures it deems necessary to effectively monitor the
trading of binary KPI options, including cooperation with FINRA to
update insider trading surveillances to incorporate the unique
characteristics of binary KPI options.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\78\ Section 19(g)(1) of the Act, among other things, requires
every self-regulatory organization (``SRO'') registered as a
national securities exchange or national securities association to
comply with the Act, the rules and regulations thereunder, and the
SRO's own rules, and, absent reasonable justification or excuse,
enforce compliance by its members and persons associated with its
members. See 15 U.S.C. 78q(d)(1) and 17 CFR 240.17d-2. Section
17(d)(1) of the Act allows the Commission to relieve an SRO of
certain responsibilities with respect to members of the SRO who are
also members of another SRO (``common members''). Specifically,
Section 17(d)(1) allows the Commission to relieve an SRO of its
responsibilities to: (i) receive regulatory reports from such
members; (ii) examine such members for compliance with the Act and
the rules and regulations thereunder, and the rules of the SRO; or
(iii) carry out other specified regulatory responsibilities with
respect to such members.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

The Exchange will report any information regarding binary KPI
options required to be reported to the Consolidated Audit Trail
(``CAT'') in the same manner it reports this information to CAT for all
other options the Exchange lists.\79\ The Exchange does not believe
that technical changes are required to accommodate the reporting to CAT
of information regarding binary KPI options (the Exchange represents,
if later required by FINRA CAT, the administrator of the CAT, it will
adhere to any new technical requirements FINRA CAT deems necessary to
accommodate binary KPI options).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\79\ CAT reporting requirements will apply to broker-dealers
with respect to binary KPI options in the same manner as they apply
to any other options the Exchange lists. The Exchange believes that
there will be no changes to the reporting specifications for broker-
dealers to accommodate the reporting of information regarding binary
KPI options to CAT.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

[[Page 75399]]

Linkage Plan
Pursuant to the Options Order Protection and Locked/Crossed Market
Plan (``Linkage Plan''),\80\ participant exchanges to the Linkage Plan
established a framework to provide order protection. The Linkage Plan
(and Exchange Rules 27.1 through 27.3 regarding intermarket linkage)
applies to the trading of multiply listed options. Rule 21.9 (Order
Routing) addresses order routing away from the Exchange to promote
compliance with the Linkage Plan. If the proposed binary KPI options
become multiply listed options, Users may designate a binary KPI option
order for routing (or not available for routing) in the same manner
they do for other multiply listed options, and the Exchange System is
designed to prevent trade-throughs and avoid displaying locked/crossed
markets in accordance with the Linkage Plan for all multiply listed
options (and Exchange Rules 27.1 through 27.3 regarding intermarket
linkage).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\80\ The Linkage Plan requires U.S. options exchanges to
establish a framework for providing order protection and addressing
locked and crossed markets in eligible options classes. The Linkage
Plan is a national market system plan approved by the Commission
pursuant to Section 11A of the Act and Rule 608 thereunder. The full
text of the Linkage Plan is available at https://www.theocc.com/getcontentasset/7fc629d9-4e54-4b99-9f11-c0e4db1a2266/dfc3d011-8f63-43f6-9ed8-4b444333a1d0/options_order_protection_plan.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Clearing, Options Disclosure Document, and OLPP
Upon launch, binary KPI options will clear through the Clearing
Corporation (i.e., the registered clearing agency designated by the
Exchange to clear binary KPI options), which will serve as the central
counterparty to each transaction and facilitate risk mitigation through
established clearing, settlement, contract adjustment, and other
standardized operational processes. The Exchange will submit a separate
proposed rule change to the Commission to designate the registered
clearing agency that will serve as the Clearing Corporation. As
discussed above, the proposed rule change provides that, with respect
to binary KPI options, references in the Rules to OCC mean the Clearing
Corporation. Accordingly, once the Clearing Corporation is designated,
the existing references to OCC in the Rules will apply to the Clearing
Corporation with respect to binary KPI options, without the need to
amend each such reference. The Exchange represents it will not list for
trading binary KPI options until the registered clearing agency
designated as the Clearing Corporation is registered with the
Commission and authorized and operationally ready to clear binary KPI
options and until all applicable filings and documents of the Clearing
Corporation related to binary KPI options being cleared through the
Clearing Corporation are approved by the Commission or effective after
review by the Commission, as applicable.
The Exchange intends for binary KPI options to be treated as listed
standardized options. Rule 9b-1 under the Act \81\ establishes a
disclosure framework for standardized options pursuant to which
investors receive a disclosure document describing the terms,
characteristics, and risks of the product before trading. Depending on
which registered clearing agency is designated as the Clearing
Corporation, the applicable Rule 9b-1 disclosure document may be based
on an existing options disclosure document utilized by that clearing
agency, as modified or supplemented, as appropriate, or another
comparable disclosure document prepared in connection with the
clearance of binary KPI options. In either case, the disclosure
document would contain substantially similar information regarding the
terms, characteristics, risks, settlement mechanics, and other material
features of binary KPI options and would be tailored, as necessary, to
address the product's unique features and distinctions from traditional
listed options. The Exchange will not list binary KPI options for
trading until the applicable Rule 9b-1 disclosure document is in
place.\82\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\81\ 17 CFR 240.9b-1.
\82\ Cboe has submitted to the Commission an options disclosure
document describing the characteristics and risks associated with
the trading of binary KPI options in accordance with Rule 9b-1 under
the Act. See Cboe Approval Order, supra note 5, 91 FR at 65864. In
the Cboe Approval Order, the Commission also designated the binary
KPI options described in the Cboe Proposal as standardized options
for purposes of Rule 9b-1. See id. at 65886. The binary KPI options
proposed herein have the same terms as those binary KPI options and
will similarly be traded on a national securities exchange with
specific expiration dates and exercise prices and cleared through a
registered clearing agency.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

The Options Listings Procedure Plan (the ``OLPP'') sets forth
procedures to facilitate the listing and trading of standardized
options. The OLPP currently describes procedures with respect to
options issued by and cleared at OCC. If the Clearing Corporation
designated by the Exchange is a registered clearing agency other than
OCC, the Exchange will work with the other participants in the OLPP, in
accordance with the procedures set forth in the OLPP, to propose
amendments to the OLPP to reflect listing procedures applicable to
options that will be cleared by the Clearing Corporation, including
binary KPI options. If an amendment to the OLPP to apply those
procedures to the Clearing Corporation is not effective before the
Exchange begins listing binary KPI options, that will have no impact on
the listing or trading of binary KPI options, as the Exchange will
certify and list binary KPI options following the same procedures at
the Clearing Corporation as it does for other options at OCC.
If binary KPI options listed on the Exchange or another options
exchange are cleared by more than one registered clearing agency (for
example, if the Exchange designates a registered clearing agency other
than OCC as the Clearing Corporation and OCC submits a proposal to the
Commission to amend its rules to clear binary KPI options, or vice
versa), the Exchange acknowledges that the OLPP will require amendment.
Certain provisions of the current OLPP (including, but not limited to,
the ability for additional registered clearing agencies to become OLPP
Sponsors, the process for requesting a new series of binary KPI
options, and the application of the indemnification clause to clearing
agencies other than OCC as it relates to those options exchanges that
clear binary options through such clearing agencies) reference only OCC
as a clearing agency for listed options. The purpose of such an
amendment would be to update these OLPP provisions to account for the
fact that more than one registered clearing agency could clear binary
KPI options. Accordingly, to the extent such an amendment has not
already been filed, the Exchange will work with the other participants
in the OLPP to file with the Commission a proposed amendment to the
OLPP, in accordance with the procedures set forth in the OLPP and Rule
608 of Regulation NMS,\83\ as promptly as practicable following
Commission publication of a notice of filing of a proposed rule change
by a registered clearing agency to amend its rules to clear binary KPI
options that results in binary KPI options being cleared by more than
one registered clearing agency, and will operate in good faith in
cooperating with the Commission and the applicable registered clearing
agencies to ensure such proposed amendment reflects the changes
referenced above as well as any additional changes the Commission may
deem necessary or appropriate in light of the foregoing in the interest
of

[[Page 75400]]

maintaining fair and orderly markets and the protection of
investors.\84\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\83\ 17 CFR 242.608.
\84\ Cboe made a similar commitment with respect to the OLPP in
the Cboe Proposal. See Cboe Approval Order, supra note 5, 91 FR at
65864.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Implementation
The Exchange will not commence listing and trading of binary KPI
options until (1) the Exchange has designated the Clearing Corporation
pursuant to a proposed rule change submitted to the Commission, and the
registered clearing agency so designated is registered with the
Commission and authorized and operationally ready to clear binary KPI
options; (2) all applicable filings and documents of the Clearing
Corporation related to binary KPI options are approved by the
Commission or effective after review by the Commission, as applicable;
(3) the alternative settlement procedures described above have been
established; (4) the applicable disclosure document under Rule 9b-1 is
in place; and (5) any changes relating to CAT, FINRA, OPRA, the Linkage
Plan, and the OLPP that are necessary for the listing and trading of
binary KPI options on the Exchange have been completed. The Exchange
will announce the implementation date of the proposed rule change by
notice to Options Members.
2. Statutory Basis
The Exchange believes the proposed rule change is consistent with
the Act and the rules and regulations thereunder applicable to the
Exchange and, in particular, the requirements of Section 6(b) of the
Act.\85\ Specifically, the Exchange believes the proposed rule change
is consistent with the Section 6(b)(5) \86\ requirements that the rules
of an exchange be designed to prevent fraudulent and manipulative acts
and practices, to promote just and equitable principles of trade, to
foster cooperation and coordination with persons engaged in regulating,
clearing, settling, processing information with respect to, and
facilitating transactions in securities, to remove impediments to and
perfect the mechanism of a free and open market and a national market
system, and, in general, to protect investors and the public interest.
Additionally, the Exchange believes the proposed rule change is
consistent with the Section 6(b)(5) \87\ requirement that the rules of
an exchange not be designed to permit unfair discrimination between
customers, issuers, brokers, or dealers. The Exchange also believes the
proposed rule change is consistent with Section 6(b)(1) of the Act,\88\
which provides that the Exchange be organized and have the capacity to
be able to carry out the purposes of the Act and to enforce compliance
by the Exchange's Members and persons associated with its Members with
the Act, the rules and regulations thereunder, and the rules of the
Exchange.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\85\ 15 U.S.C. 78f(b).
\86\ 15 U.S.C. 78f(b)(5).
\87\ Id.
\88\ 15 U.S.C. 78f(b)(1).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

As described above, the proposed rule change is based on, and is
substantially similar to, the Cboe Rules, which the Commission recently
found to be consistent with the Act, including Sections 6(b)(1),
6(b)(5), and 6(b)(8) and Section 11A of the Act.\89\ The proposed
binary KPI options will overlie the same KPIs of the same issuers, and
will have the same standardized terms, as the binary KPI options that
the Commission approved for listing and trading on Cboe. As such, the
Exchange believes the proposed rule change is consistent with the Act
for the same reasons as the Cboe Rules. The limited differences between
the proposed rules and the Cboe Rules, which are described above,
either reflect the Exchange's rule structure, existing rules, and
systems, and the fact that the Exchange has not yet designated the
registered clearing agency that will clear binary KPI options, or are
designed to achieve the same result as, or provide additional investor
protection beyond, the Cboe Rules (including that the System will
prevent, rather than adjust the price of, executions of binary KPI
options above the maximum execution price, and the use of the opening
of trading in the issuer's stock as the reference point for opening
binary KPI options), and the Exchange believes these differences are
consistent with the Act for the reasons discussed below.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\89\ See Cboe Approval Order, supra note 5, 91 FR at 65876. See
also 15 U.S.C. 78f(b)(8) and 78k-1.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

The Exchange believes the proposed rule change will remove
impediments to and perfect the mechanism of a free and open market and
a national market system, and, in general, protect investors and the
public interest because it establishes a clear and transparent
framework for a new category of listed options (binary KPI options)
that are tied to financial and operating metrics of issuers that are
publicly disclosed in earnings-related filings issuers submit to the
Commission. Currently, investors wishing to position their investment
strategies around earnings disclosures must rely primarily on equity
options, whose pricing is affected by a wide range of variables beyond
the reported financial or operating measure of interest (e.g., implied
volatility, delta, time value, and general market movement). Binary KPI
options allow investors to take a targeted, defined-risk position
directly on a specific financial or operating measure (i.e., an issuer
KPI) for a particular reporting period. The Exchange believes this
additional investment tool will protect investors and the public
interest because it will promote market efficiency, enable more precise
price discovery around earnings events, allow investors to hedge
against potential idiosyncratic risks, and close a gap in current
national securities exchange-listed products available to market
participants.
The Exchange believes the proposed list of issuers and KPIs on
which the Exchange may list binary KPI options will prevent fraudulent
and manipulative acts and practices, remove impediments to and perfect
the mechanism of a free and open market and a national market system,
and, in general, protect investors and the public interest. First, as
noted above, the Exchange is proposing to list binary KPI option
contracts based on specific financial and operating metrics reported by
the following issuers in their earnings-related filings submitted to
the Commission: Apple, Inc.; Advanced Micro Devices, Inc.; Alphabet
Inc.; Amazon.com, Inc.; Bank of America Corporation; Citigroup Inc.;
Coinbase Global, Inc.; Ford Motor Company; Intel Corporation; JPMorgan
Chase & Co.; Marathon Digital Holdings, Inc.; Meta Platforms, Inc.;
Microsoft Corporation; Netflix, Inc.; NVIDIA Corporation; Palantir
Technologies Inc.; Robinhood Markets, Inc.; SoFi Technologies, Inc.;
Space Exploration Technologies Corp.; Super Micro Computer, Inc.;
Target Corporation; Tesla, Inc.; and The Walt Disney Company. The
Exchange believes offering investors an additional investment tool on a
national securities exchange related to some of the most actively
traded stocks and options will perfect the mechanism of a free and open
market and benefit investors by allowing them to further refine their
investment strategies, including using binary KPI options to hedge
idiosyncratic, event-specific risk embedded in the specific KPIs (as
further discussed below), for these actively traded companies.
The Exchange believes the proposed universe of issuers will prevent
fraudulent and manipulative acts and practices, because the proposed
issuers are large, well-capitalized, and widely followed issuers with
highly liquid underlying securities and options markets. Securities
with high market capitalizations and liquid markets are

[[Page 75401]]

generally less susceptible to manipulation because of the substantial
capital required to artificially influence prices of those securities.
The depth and breadth of trading activity for securities with
significant market capitalizations, such as the stocks of the proposed
issuers, make it unlikely that a single market participant would be
able to exert undue influence on the price of such a stock, as large
volumes of buyers and sellers are what ultimately continuously reflect
the true market value of the stock. The Exchange believes the KPIs of
issuers with high market capitalizations proposed to underlie binary
KPI options are similarly less susceptible to manipulation because any
attempt to distort a financial metric of such an issuer would require
an enormous and economically impractical deployment of capital, which
would likely exceed the fixed payout of a binary KPI option. Therefore,
like stocks of large-cap issuers, KPIs of large-cap issuers are less
susceptible to manipulation due to the structural barriers that would
make manipulating KPI values operationally difficult and financially
irrational (in addition to the rigorous financial oversight to which
these issuers are subject, as further discussed below).
In addition to the proposed issuers being highly capitalized and
having actively traded stocks and options on such stocks, the Exchange
also believes the proposed limited universe of issuers for binary KPI
options to those proposed will prevent fraudulent and manipulative acts
and practices because each issuer is subject to current and periodic
reporting requirements under the Act. Therefore, each of the proposed
issuers must file annual reports on Form 10-K, quarterly reports on
Form 10-Q, and current reports on Form 8-K with the Commission, which
as discussed above disclose information the issuer believes is
necessary for an investor to understand its financial condition,
changes in financial condition, and results of operations, which can
include KPIs. Further, each issuer maintains audited financial
statements prepared in accordance with U.S. Generally Accepted
Accounting Principles (``GAAP'') and is subject to executive
certification requirements under the Sarbanes-Oxley Act. As a result,
the settlement-determining KPI values for each eligible issuer are
produced within the Commission's supervisory jurisdiction, are publicly
verifiable from a Commission-regulated source, and are subject to
relevant anti-fraud provisions under the Act, which the Exchange
believes will reduce the potential for manipulation of the underlying
KPIs as well as the applicable issuer's stock.
Further, the Exchange believes the proposed limited universe of
issuers will introduce binary KPI options in a well-developed, well-
understood, and transparent Commission-regulated market environment.
Each issuer is among the most widely followed, actively traded, and
extensively analyzed issuers in its respective sector, with deep and
liquid equity and derivatives markets and a broad institutional and
retail investor base. The depth of existing market activity surrounding
these issuers supports fair and orderly pricing by ensuring that binary
KPI options are listed in markets where price discovery is well-
established, liquidity is readily available, and participants have
broad access to the information necessary to form and express informed
views on KPI outcomes. The Exchange believes the continuous public
scrutiny to which these issuers are subject substantially reduces the
likelihood that any market participant could obtain or maintain an
informational advantage sufficient to manipulate the settlement value
of the binary KPI options.
The Exchange believes the proposed KPI metrics will similarly
prevent fraudulent and manipulative acts and practices, remove
impediments to and perfect the mechanism of a free and open market and
a national market system, and, in general, protect investors and the
public interest. The Exchange's proposal limits eligible KPIs to GAAP
and non-GAAP measures and other statistics related to an issuer's
financial condition and operational results, all of which the proposed
issuers disclose in their earnings-related filings (i.e., Forms 8-K,
10-Q, and 10-K) submitted to the Commission. As such, the settlement
values of the proposed binary KPI options are derived exclusively from
information that issuers deem as material information required to be
disclosed in filings submitted to the Commission. These metrics are
routinely referenced and tracked in the investment community, which the
market recognizes as meaningful and central indicators of issuer
performance. The Exchange believes the inclusion of well-established
metrics as eligible KPIs expands the value of binary KPI options for
investors without compromising the integrity of trading processes,
including the settlement process.
The Exchange proposes new Rule 30.2 to list the specific binary KPI
option contracts with the KPI criteria for each option contract. Such
KPI criteria are established as the set KPI events that will be used to
determine whether an option contract should be exercised by comparing
the strike price of the binary KPI option to the KPI settlement value.
The proposed KPI metrics are among the most widely followed and
extensively analyzed measures for the proposed issuers. Specifically,
the Exchange proposes to be able to list a binary KPI option on
earnings per share (prepared in accordance with GAAP) for each proposed
issuer. This metric is among the most widely followed and extensively
analyzed figures in public company financial disclosures and is
disclosed in each issuer's current or periodic Commission filings.
Similarly, the Exchange proposes to list binary KPI options on revenue,
prepared in accordance with the applicable GAAP, for each issuer. As is
the case for earnings per share, revenue is a widely followed financial
metric for public reporting companies and is the subject of extensive
analyst coverage.
The Exchange proposes KPIs representing revenues broken out by
applicable reportable segment, business unit, or product category,
including cloud and artificial intelligence infrastructure revenues,
streaming and geographic subscription revenues, automotive segment
revenues, financial services segment revenues, consumer product
category revenues, and digital asset exchange transaction and
subscription revenues, among others, for several of the proposed
issuers. Each such metric is a GAAP-defined figure required to be
disclosed in the issuer's current or periodic Commission filings. The
Exchange understands these metrics enable market participants to
express views on specific high-profile business lines that are
extensively covered by analysts and subject to a high volume of
publicly available forecasts.
The Exchange proposes KPIs for the proposed financial institution
issuers that are specific to financial institution income statement
presentation, including net interest income, provision for credit
losses, and net income. Each such metric reflects the distinct GAAP
reporting framework applicable to banking institutions and is subject
to the same current and periodic disclosures as other proposed KPIs.
The proposed rule change also includes operating margin, gross
margin, or cash flow from operations KPIs for several issuers, each of
which is computed directly from GAAP financial statement line items
disclosed in the issuer's current and periodic Commission filings.
These metrics provide market participants with insight into issuer
profitability and capital

[[Page 75402]]

generation and complement other revenue and earnings figures when
market participants are evaluating the value of an issuer and its
stock.
The Exchange also proposes several non-financial operational KPIs
that issuers disclosed in their current and periodic Commission
filings, including relevant production volumes, network and
infrastructure counts, user engagement metrics, deal counts, digital
asset trading volume, and digital asset mining and holdings metrics.
Each designated non-financial operational metric is closely tied to the
core economic activity of the respective issuer's business and is a
figure the issuer has affirmatively chosen to disclose to the public as
a key indicator of business performance. Issuers typically designate
and disclose such metrics because they are understood by the market to
be among the most meaningful measures of issuers' business activities.
As discussed above, this is consistent with Commission guidance that an
issuer should include KPIs in its earnings-related filings submitted to
the Commission that the issuer believes an investor needs to gain
understanding of its financial condition, changes in financial
condition, and results of operations, as such KPIs present the
``pulse'' of the issuer's business. The market significance of these
metrics is further reflected in the extensive analyst coverage and
investor attention, particularly near each earnings disclosure date.
Each metric is subject to executive certification as part of the filing
in which it appears and is widely tracked by financial data services
and equity research analysts.
Overall, the Exchange believes that the proposed well-established,
publicly reported metrics as eligible KPIs will expand the value of
binary KPI options for investors without compromising the integrity of
trading processes, including the settlement process. As a result, the
Exchange believes the proposed KPIs will protect investors and the
public interest, as the ability to list binary KPI options overlying
these issuer KPIs will permit the Exchange to offer investors
additional investment and hedging tools on the Exchange that investors
can incorporate into their investment strategies regarding the proposed
issuers.
The Exchange believes the proposed contract terms for binary KPI
options will promote just and equitable principles of trade, remove
impediments to and perfect a free and open market and national market
system, and protect investors. As discussed above, the proposed
contract terms for binary KPI options are standardized option terms.
Like traditional option contracts currently listed for trading on the
Exchange and binary option contracts listed for trading on other
options exchanges, each proposed binary KPI option will be a call or a
put, will have an underlying, exercise price, an expiration date, a
settlement type, an exercise style, and a multiplier. As is the case
for binary index options listed on other options exchanges, each
proposed binary KPI option will have an exercise settlement amount paid
depending on how the settlement value of the underlying KPI compares to
the exercise price.
The proposed binary KPI options will function in substantially the
same manner as, and have the same contract terms as, the binary KPI
options the Commission approved for listing and trading on Cboe. The
proposed definitions of binary KPI option, call binary KPI option,
exercise price, and put binary KPI option are the same as those terms
in the Cboe Rules.\90\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\90\ See Cboe Rule 4.80.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

The proposed definition of settlement value for binary KPI options
is the same as the definition in the Cboe Rules (other than the
clearing agency-neutral change to paragraph (c) described above). The
proposed $1 exercise settlement amount for binary KPI options is the
same as the exercise settlement amount for binary KPI options under the
Cboe Rules. The Exchange believes the proposed $1 exercise settlement
amount is reasonable given the retail nature of the proposed binary KPI
options. The Exchange notes binary KPI options differ from standardized
index options (which are also cash-settled) in that the exercise
settlement amount is $1.00 rather than a cash amount equal to the
difference between the settlement value of the index and the strike
price of an option. Since the $1.00 exercise settlement amount will be
paid out to the option holder if the criterion of the binary KPI option
has been met, a binary KPI option has a fixed exercise settlement
amount.
The Exchange believes alternative settlement procedures of the type
described above in the Purpose section (which, as discussed above, must
be established before the Exchange lists binary KPI options for
trading) are appropriate in that they establish a process to address an
unexpected condition, taking into consideration fairness to both option
writers and holders. Pursuant to such alternative settlement
procedures, as described in the Cboe Proposal, the payout amount of a
binary KPI option may be based on the market's last valuation of the
binary KPI option. If a KPI value is unavailable at settlement, the
Clearing Corporation may delay expiration processing in accordance with
its Rules. In certain circumstances, if it is determined that the KPI
value is unavailable (and will not become available, such as if an
issuer announces it will no longer disclose the KPI value or will not
be submitting its earnings-related filing to the Commission for the
relevant reporting period), alternative settlement procedures may
apply. Certain events may trigger the alternative settlement
procedures, including but not limited to company announcements that a
KPI event will no longer be available; a delay in company earnings
announcements for an indefinite period; illiquid markets where there is
no bid/offer or other data for price discovery. The timing of the
triggering of alternative settlement procedures depends on when any
such determination of the lack of availability of the KPI is made,
which will often be the expiration date (but may be at other times as
set forth in the applicable alternative settlement procedures and
further described in the options disclosure document for binary KPI
options). If, when applying the alternative settlement procedures, it
is determined that the last closing price is unreliable or
inappropriate to use because the binary KPI option has not recently
traded or traded with sufficient liquidity, the KPI will be deemed as
not met and the binary KPI options will expire unexercised. The
Exchange notes that alternative settlement procedures are not novel for
options, and alternative settlement procedures vary based on option
type.\91\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\91\ For example, for binary index options on indexes issued by
OCC, OCC Rules provide for a determination process used when the
underlying security price or index value is unreported, inaccurate,
unavailable or inappropriate. The OCC determination process utilizes
a panel to fix the value of the underlying interest to be used for
expiration processing. This process differs from the proposed
alternative settlement procedures for binary KPI options because the
binary options issued by OCC depend solely on trading price or index
value (unlike binary KPI options), and OCC Rules allow specific
methods by which an underlying value may be determined for
expiration processing if a trading price or value is not available.
See OCC By-Laws, Article XIV, Section 5.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

The Exchange believes the proposed expirations for binary KPI
options will remove impediments to and perfect the mechanism of a free
and open market and a national market system because they will align
with the reporting periods for which the proposed issuers disclose
earnings results and submit corresponding filings to the Commission.
These expirations will,

[[Page 75403]]

therefore, permit investors to incorporate binary KPI options into
their investment strategies that correspond to issuers' earnings
results. Further, as discussed above, the Exchange believes aligning
expirations with Commission-filed and -regulated sources will reduce
the potential for manipulation of the underlying KPIs, which will
ultimately protect investors and the public interest.
The proposed rule change establishes a strike regime for binary KPI
options similar to that for traditional options. As is the case for
traditional options, the proposed rule change establishes permissible
strike intervals, the amounts of which increase as the value of the
strike increases. Additionally, the Exchange proposes to list initial
and additional series pursuant to a similar framework as traditional
equity options. The differences between the proposed strike regime and
that of standard equity and index options are necessary and appropriate
to reflect the static nature of KPIs (unlike underlying equities and
indexes, the values of which change throughout the trading day) and the
timing of their disclosure. As noted above, the Exchange intends to
list binary KPI options aligned with the cadence of the KPI disclosures
as their expiration cycle (generally quarterly). The Exchange intends
to list for trading binary KPI options with expirations for the then-
current reporting period (e.g., third quarter) as well as the following
period (e.g., fourth quarter) prior to the expiration of the binary KPI
options for the then-current reporting period (e.g., third quarter).
As the Exchange does for standard options, the Exchange lists
strikes (subject to its Rules) based on relevant market information--
including the then-current value of the underlying--and customer
demand. As described above, the Exchange intends to do the same for
binary KPI options by listing strikes relative to the then-current
value of the underlying KPI or publicly available estimates from the
issuer or major market data vendors. The Exchange believes it is
consistent with just and equitable principles of trade to permit the
Exchange to list strikes based on all available information that would
inform expectations about the KPIs (as investors would do), and then
add strikes based on new or updated information, as it will allow the
Exchange to list series with strikes consistent with investor
expectations and demands. This will enable the Exchange to respond to
changes in market conditions for binary KPI options in the same manner
it is able to do today for equity and index options, factoring in the
static value of KPIs. Specifically, the Exchange believes this
flexibility is appropriate for binary KPI options because the value of
a KPI changes only when an issuer discloses that KPI, which generally
happens every three months, unlike other underlyings, the value of
which changes every trading day. While this proposed strike listing
regime for binary KPI options differs from that of other options, the
concept is the same, which is to permit the Exchange to list strikes
reflective of the then-current value of the underlying and in response
to customer demand. It is possible the changed value of an underlying
KPI in a more recent earnings disclosure or new or updated estimates
may be more sudden and pronounced than changes in the value of an
underlying equity or index (which are susceptible to sudden value
changes); however, like the listing rules for equity and index options,
the proposed rules permit the Exchange to list strikes to reflect
changes in the value of the underlying, including substantial changes.
The Exchange believes the proposed scaling of strike prices is
reasonable and will protect investors, as it will permit the Exchange
to list strike values in amounts similar to current strike values for
other options. As noted above, values of certain KPIs may be large
(e.g., in the billions). The proposed scaling will permit the Exchange,
for example, to list a strike of 27 rather than 27,000,000,000, which
the Exchange believes will be simpler for investors to understand (as
it will be made clear that 27 will reflect billions in this example
\92\) and consistent with current strike levels. The proposed scaling
also permits the strike prices for binary KPI options to fit within
current system capabilities regarding strike price values. The Exchange
believes scaling rather than modifying its systems (and potentially
causing investors to modify their systems) will benefit investors by
allowing them to trade binary KPI options in the same manner as they
trade other options today.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\92\ The binary KPI option contract specifications available to
Options Members will set forth the scaling factor for each binary
KPI option.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

The Exchange believes the proposed strike intervals promote just
and equitable principles of trade because it will permit the Exchange
to list commercially meaningful strikes that will permit investors to
tailor their trading strategies with precision. The Exchange
acknowledges the proposed strike intervals are smaller than those in
current Rules for other types of options. However, the Exchange
believes the precision is appropriate and necessary given the nature of
KPIs and the proposed binary options. The purpose of binary KPI options
is to permit investors to take discrete and precise positions on KPIs.
Therefore, the Exchange needs the ability to list strikes with the
precision necessary to permit investors to take these positions. For
example, an issuer's earnings (or loss) per share is generally a
relatively small number (under $10). While strike intervals for other
options are limited to $0.50 intervals, that would not be meaningful in
the context of binary KPI options when investors are looking to take
positions for a specific KPI value, which will be measured in penny
intervals. Therefore, the Exchange believes smaller strike intervals
will benefit investors because they will allow the Exchange to list
binary KPI options that will enable investors to use these options in
the precise nature for which they are intended and provide sufficient
flexibility for the Exchange to list series to respond to changes in
market conditions and customer demand, while other proposed rules will
place bounds around the strikes the Exchange may list.\93\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\93\ See proposed Rule 30.3(f) and (g).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Further, as discussed above, the proposed strike interval framework
is consistent with that of other options, which provides for larger
strike intervals as the value of strike prices increases (as described
above). Given the scaling factor for larger KPI values, while it may
appear the proposed rule change will permit smaller strike intervals
for larger KPI values, this is not the case if the actual value (rather
than the nominal value) of the strike intervals is considered. The
corresponding actual value of the strike interval for a strike price
that was subject to a larger scale value is higher than the actual
value of the strike interval for a strike price that was subject to a
smaller scale value. As a result, the permissible strike intervals for
strike prices representing higher KPI values are larger than the
permissible strike intervals for strike prices representing lower KPI
values. This is consistent with general premise underlying current
strike intervals that larger strike intervals apply to larger strike
values and, therefore, the Exchange believes the proposed rule change
will promote just and equitable principles of trade.
The Exchange believes the proposed rule change clearly describes
the proposed terms of binary KPI options, such as with respect to
expirations (including the Exchange's

[[Page 75404]]

announcement of the specific expiration date after binary KPI options
series for that expiration are listed with a placeholder expiration
date) and exercise prices (including the scaling factor, negative
values, and potential changes to that scaling factor for a binary KPI
option class) for all investors. As discussed above, the Exchange will
make available information regarding the terms of binary KPI options
and changes to such terms to Options Members. Further, Options Members
and retail brokerage firms are highly sophisticated investors and
currently intake information regarding other Exchange-listed options
(including changes) in the same manner that the Exchange plans to
release this information for binary KPI options. As binary KPI options
are intended as a retail-focused product, the Exchange expects that
retail brokerage firms will display binary KPI options on their user
interfaces in ways that similarly make the terms of the options clear
to their retail customers.\94\ Therefore, through information made
available by the Exchange and by retail brokerage firms to their
customers, the Exchange expects retail customers to have access to all
relevant information regarding the terms of binary KPI options they
choose to trade, including specification of the actual expiration dates
and applicable scale values for each KPI.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\94\ For example, the Cboe Proposal notes that retail brokerage
firms intend to display a binary KPI option of an issuer's earnings
per share of -$2.47 to expire on the date on which the issuer
discloses its third quarter 2026 earnings results as a phrase, such
as ``will the issuer's loss per share for the third quarter of 2026
be more than (or less than) $2.47?''. See Cboe Approval Order, supra
note 5, 91 FR at 65871.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

The proposed rule change specifies a multiplier of one for binary
KPI options, which is the same as the Cboe Rules.\95\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\95\ See Cboe Rule 4.82(f).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

The Exchange believes proposed Rule 30.6, which establishes Regular
Trading Hours for binary KPI options, is consistent with the Act,
protects investors, and prevents fraudulent and manipulative practices.
The Exchange believes the proposed structure ensures that trading in
binary KPI options will cease before the earnings disclosure that
determines settlement. The distinction between A.M.- and P.M.-settled
contracts is the same as the settlement terms applicable to binary KPI
options under the Cboe Rules.\96\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\96\ See Cboe Rule 4.82(a).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

The Exchange believes halting trading in binary KPI options in
accordance with current Rules (including Rules 20.3 and 20.4) and not
automatically if trading in the underlying issuer stock halts will
promote just and equitable principles of trade, remove impediments to
and perfect the mechanism of a free and open market and a national
market system, and, in general, protect investors and the public
interest. The Exchange generally halts trading in a security to protect
investors by allowing time for the market to absorb information or
volatility that may impact the value of the security and promote
orderly price discovery, thereby reducing the risk that investors trade
at stale or distorted prices. The Exchange believes halting trading in
binary KPI options in lockstep with trading halts in the issuer's stock
and options overlying that stock given the discrete, disclosure-driven
nature of binary KPI options' value would not serve these investor-
protection purposes. Therefore, the Exchange believes it will benefit
investors to permit them to continue to manage and adjust their
positions in binary KPI options. If the Exchange believes halting
trading in a binary KPI option would be necessary to maintain a fair
and orderly market and protect investors based on then-current factors,
which may include whether the issuer's stock halts and the reasons that
caused the halt, the Exchange will have the authority to do so pursuant
to Rule 20.3.
The Exchange believes proposed Rule 30.6(f), which provides that
the System shall open binary KPI options for trading in accordance with
Rule 21.7, with the stock of the issuer treated as the security
underlying the option for purposes of that Rule, is consistent with the
Act. The proposed rule will allow binary KPI options to open for
trading in an orderly and transparent manner and removes impediments to
a free and open market by applying the Exchange's existing, well-
established opening process for equity options to binary KPI options.
The Exchange believes the proposed rule will protect investors and the
public interest because it will use the opening of trading in the
issuer's stock on its primary listing market as an objective and
readily observable reference point for the commencement of trading in
binary KPI options, and will permit the Exchange to delay the opening
of binary KPI options if the opening of the issuer's stock is delayed
(which may indicate unusual circumstances relating to the issuer) and
the Exchange determines that the interests of a fair and orderly market
are not best served by opening binary KPI options. Under normal market
conditions, the Exchange expects binary KPI options to open for trading
at or shortly after 9:30 a.m., consistent with the fixed-time opening
of binary KPI options on Cboe that the Commission approved.\97\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\97\ See Cboe Rule 5.31(d)(1)(D); Cboe Approval Order, supra
note 5, 91 FR at 65880.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

The Exchange believes proposed Rule 30.3(e), which addresses bid
and offer conventions for binary KPI options with multipliers other
than 100, will provide clarity and consistency in market quotations
relative to the notional size of the option and promote investor
understanding of the cost and value of binary KPI option contracts.
Therefore, the Exchange believes the proposed rule change is consistent
with just and equitable principles of trade because it creates a
pricing structure that reflects the notional value of an option based
on its multiplier.\98\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\98\ The Exchange notes that this proposal is substantially the
same as Cboe Rule 5.3(c)(3), which applies to all binary options
listed on Cboe.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

The Exchange believes proposed Rule 30.8, which provides that,
notwithstanding Rule 21.5, the Exchange shall establish the minimum
increment for bids and offers on orders for binary KPI options on a
class-by-class basis, which may not be less than $0.01, is consistent
with just and equitable principles of trade and will protect investors.
Proposed Rule 30.8 is substantially the same as Cboe Rule 5.4(c)(1),
which the Commission approved with respect to binary KPI options.\99\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\99\ See Cboe Approval Order, supra note 5, 91 FR at 65880.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

The Exchange believes excluding binary KPI options from the obvious
error provisions in Rule 20.6 is consistent with the Act and promotes
just and equitable principles of trade because the standard obvious
error framework, which evaluates whether an execution price deviates
from a ``theoretical value'' by a prescribed amount, is incompatible
with the structure of binary KPI options. Binary KPI options have no
continuously observable theoretical value (unlike equity and index
options) prior to the date of the earnings-related disclosure. Rather,
their exercise settlement amount is fixed at either a pre-specified
dollar amount or zero, depending entirely on whether the reported KPI
satisfies the exercise condition, which itself is based on a single,
publicly verifiable metric, disclosed in issuers' earnings-related
filings submitted to the Commission. An obvious error framework
premised on theoretical value calculations is unsuitable for a product
with a binary, fixed payout, and application of such a framework to a
binary product could produce unjust or arbitrary results for investors.
Moreover, because settlement of binary KPI options is determined by

[[Page 75405]]

metrics an issuer discloses in its earnings-related filings submitted
to the Commission (i.e., figures produced pursuant to established
accounting standards, subject to independent audit, and certified under
the Sarbanes-Oxley Act), the settlement process is itself governed by a
comprehensive external regulatory framework. The Exchange believes that
establishing any alternative dispute mechanism in this context would be
not only unnecessary, but potentially disruptive to market integrity,
as it may introduce an element of post-hoc discretion into a settlement
process that is expressly designed to be objective, verifiable, and
rule bound. Finally, the Exchange notes that pursuant to proposed Rule
21.17(h), the Exchange may apply a maximum execution price protection
for binary KPI options on a class basis, pursuant to which the System
will prevent executions from occurring at prices above the Exchange-
designated maximum execution price for that class. This protection
provides investors with an additional safeguard against executions at
potential erroneous prices, further limiting the need for a separate
obvious error provision applicable to binary KPI options, which the
Exchange believes protects investors and the public interest. The
Exchange accordingly believes that not applying Rule 20.6 to binary KPI
options is a reasonable and justified product-specific accommodation
that promotes orderly trading and clear, consistent treatment of
transactions in these contracts.
The Exchange believes proposed Rule 21.17(h) is consistent with the
Act and will protect investors and the public interest. Binary KPI
options have a maximum value equal to their exercise settlement amount.
Preventing executions at prices above the Exchange-designated maximum
execution price for a binary KPI option class therefore protects
investors from execution prices that are potentially erroneous. While
Cboe Rule 5.34(d) provides that the System adjusts execution prices
above the maximum execution price down to the maximum execution price,
proposed Rule 21.17(h) provides that the System prevents executions at
prices above the maximum execution price. The Exchange believes this
difference does not raise any novel issues, as both approaches achieve
the same purpose of ensuring that binary options do not execute at
prices above the designated maximum execution price, and preventing
such executions (rather than adjusting their prices) avoids executing
an order at a price other than the price at which the parties' orders
would otherwise have executed. Proposed Rule 21.17(h) is otherwise
substantially the same as Cboe Rule 5.34(d), which the Commission
approved, and, consistent with that rule, the Exchange will designate
the maximum execution price for each binary KPI option class and will
notify Options Members of the designated maximum execution price.\100\
Accordingly, the Exchange believes the proposed maximum execution price
protection does not raise any novel issues.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\100\ Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

The Exchange believes the proposed amendments related to position
limits for binary KPI options are consistent with the Act because they
establish a rational position limit framework for binary KPI options
that will protect against manipulation while facilitating legitimate
trading activity in a novel product. The Exchange believes that setting
the position limit for binary KPI options at a fixed level of 25,000
standard options contracts, with 100 binary KPI option contracts
equaling one standard option contract, is appropriate. The Exchange
believes the proposed position limit, which is the smallest possible
position limit that can apply to equity options, is appropriate and
consistent with the Act.\101\ The proposed position limit is also the
same as the position limit for binary KPI options in the Cboe Rules,
which the Commission found reasonably designed to protect investors and
the public interest and to prevent fraud and manipulation.\102\
Specifically, the proposed position limit of 25,000 standard contracts
is equivalent to the position limit in Rule 18.7(d)(1) that applies to
an equity option for which the underlying security does not meet the
requirements for a higher option contract limit (including newly listed
equity options). The position limit for options on the stocks of the
issuers of the proposed KPIs is ten times higher (i.e., 250,000
contracts) pursuant to Rule 18.7(d)(5). Given the large market
capitalization and liquidity of these stocks, the Exchange believes the
proposed position limit for binary KPI options for the issuers of those
stocks is conservative and reasonable for the binary KPI options.
Further, the proposed position limit for binary KPI options is
equivalent to a position limit the Commission previously approved for
binary options on stocks.\103\ Therefore, the Exchange believes the
proposed position limit will promote just and equitable principles of
trade, as it is sufficient to mitigate potential manipulation and
prevent disruption in the markets for the issuers' stocks and options
on the stocks while accommodating investors trading activity for
legitimate economic purposes.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\101\ See Rule 18.7(d)(1).
\102\ See Cboe Approval Order, supra note 5, 91 FR at 65880.
\103\ See NYSE American, LLC Section 17, Rule 904ByRDs.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

As proposed, binary KPI options with a multiplier of one will count
toward applicable limits on a proportional basis relative to standard
equity options on the issuer's stock, which carry a multiplier of 100.
This treatment is consistent with the position limits applied to other
reduced-value options, such as micro-options listed on Cboe (which also
have a contract multiplier of one).\104\ Because the proposed binary
KPI options have a multiplier of one, while standard option contracts
have a multiplier of 100, the notional value of a binary KPI option is
significantly less than the notional value of standard option
contracts. For example, 25,000 contracts with a value of $1.00 with a
multiplier of 100 would equate to $2,500,000 notional value, while
25,000 binary KPI option contracts with a value of $1.00 (which is the
fixed maximum value of a binary KPI option contract) with a multiplier
of one would equate to $25,000 notional value. Counting 100 binary KPI
option contracts as one standard option contract for purposes of
calculating compliance with position limits effectively calibrates
these limits so that investors may hold positions in binary KPI options
for an economically equivalent number of contracts as they may hold in
standard equity options. Therefore, the Exchange believes this proposed
treatment is consistent with just and equitable principles of trade, as
it counts option positions in a manner equivalent with their value.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\104\ See Cboe Rule 8.31(f) (which provides for purposes of
determining compliance with the position limits under Cboe Rule
8.31, 100 micro-option contracts with an index multiplier of one
equal one standard option contract with an index multiplier of 100).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

The Exchange further believes the proposal regarding position
limits is reasonable because it reflects the distinct structure of
binary KPI options and their relationship to the underlying issuer.
Binary KPI options have a fixed maximum notional value and settle on an
all-or-nothing basis based on a KPI of the issuer rather than the price
of the issuer's stock as is the case for a standard equity option. The
economic risk of a position is binary, in that the

[[Page 75406]]

contract either settles in-the-money at $1.00 or out-of-the-money at
$0.00. Additionally, with respect to binary KPI options, the maximum
notional exposure per contract is fixed in advance; it cannot exceed
$1.00. Moreover, the exercise of binary KPI option positions would not
influence the outcome of the underlying KPI. As a result, the potential
for any single market participant to exert undue influence over binary
KPI option settlement is limited.
Further, the Exchange's proposal to not aggregate positions in
binary KPI options on the same KPI with different expiration dates and
positions in binary KPI options for the same issuer with different
underlying KPIs similarly reflects the distinct structure of binary KPI
options. Each binary KPI option expiration corresponds to a separate
event tied to a specific issuer reporting period. Thus, the Exchange
believes aggregating positions across different expiration dates would
not accurately reflect the risk profile of these positions and would
impose an unnecessary burden on market participants seeking exposure to
company KPI events across different reporting periods. In determining
that position limits should not be aggregated across all binary KPI
options referencing a single issuer, Cboe analyzed the degree to which
KPIs of a given issuer are correlated with one another.\105\
Specifically, Cboe performed a correlation analysis for each company
set forth in Cboe Rule 4.81(a) (which are the same companies set forth
in proposed Rule 30.2(a)), measuring the historical co-movement of each
company's KPIs across the 16 most recent earnings releases (Q3 2022
through Q2 2026). Of the 223 KPI correlation pairs examined, 30
(approximately 13%) exhibit correlations above 0.90.\106\ As Cboe
noted, many of these highly correlated pairs involve closely related
measures, such as aggregate and segment revenue, where strong co-
movement is expected and does not reflect an independent source of
concentrated risk. Across the full sample, correlations indicate that
the large majority of KPI pairs move substantially independently of one
another across earnings periods. Thus, the Exchange believes, as did
Cboe, that issuer-level aggregate position limits are not warranted.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\105\ See Cboe Approval Order, supra note 5, 91 FR at 65873.
\106\ Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Similarly, the Exchange believes it is reasonable to not aggregate
binary KPI options with non-binary options contracts overlying the
stock of the issuer. Because binary KPI options and equity options
overlying the same issuer have different risk profiles (i.e., binary
KPI options settle based on the value of a KPI of the issuer rather
than its stock price, on which equity options settle), the Exchange
believes it would be inappropriate and misleading to require
aggregation of these positions for purposes of position limits. As
noted above, binary KPI options are based solely on whether a single,
specified-issuer KPI meets a discrete threshold at a defined future
date, and their value reflects the market's probability assessment of
that singular outcome. Standard equity options, on the other hand,
reflect a broad array of factors bearing on the price of the underlying
security, including macroeconomic conditions and sector dynamics, of
which any individual KPI is only one component. Because the two
products are not priced off a common reference and do not represent
economically equivalent or fungible exposures, aggregating positions
across them would not meaningfully advance the prevention of
manipulative practices with respect to the underlying security.
There is further precedent for the proposed nonaggregation
framework. Specifically, Cboe Rule 4.8(g) provides that positions in
Single Stock Dividend Options (``SSDOs'') will not be aggregated with
positions in ordinary options overlying the stock of the issuer
underlying the SSDOs. The rationale underlying that rule is directly
analogous to the rationale supporting nonaggregation of binary KPI
options with standard listed equity options on the same issuer. In its
SSDO filing,\107\ Cboe noted that SSDOs are based solely on expected
dividends for an issuer and will reflect the forward value of that
expectation. Because the pricing of ordinary options and SSDOs differs
dramatically due to fundamentally different inputs, Cboe concluded
there was no need to aggregate positions across the two product types
to prevent manipulative practices involving the underlying. The
Commission found this approach appropriate and consistent with the Act
in its approval of the proposal.\108\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\107\ See Securities Exchange Act Release No. 64654 (June 13,
2011), 76 FR 35503 (June 17, 2011) (SR-CBOE-2011-039).
\108\ See Securities Exchange Act Release No. 64991 (July 29,
2011), 76 FR 47280 (August 4, 2011) (SR-CBOE-2011-039).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

The same logic applies to the proposed binary KPI options. Like
SSDOs, binary KPI options derive their value from a single, specified
variable (whether a particular issuer KPI meets a discrete contractual
threshold at a defined date), and their pricing reflects the market's
probability assessment of that singular outcome. In contrast, as noted
above, standard equity options on the same issuer reflect a full
spectrum of factors which may affect the underlying security's price.
The pricing of binary KPI options and standard equity options on the
same issuer will therefore differ substantially, for the same
structural reasons that the Commission found dispositive in the SSDO
context. The Exchange accordingly believes that nonaggregation of
binary KPI options with standard equity options is appropriate and
consistent with the Act.
The Exchange notes that binary option contracts (Binary Return
Derivatives (``ByRDs'')) approved for trading at NYSE American and NYSE
Arca, Inc. are similarly not aggregated with positions in other options
on the same underlying security for purposes of determining compliance
with the position limits.\109\ This is true despite those binary
options directly overlying the same stock as non-binary options. When
approving such rule (including a position limit of 25,000 contracts for
ByRDs), the Commission stated ``that the proposed position limits . . .
for [ByRDs] are reasonable and consistent with the Act. The proposed
position limit of 25,000 contracts in any [ByRD] class appears to
reasonably balance the promotion of a free and open market for these
securities with minimization of incentives for market manipulation. The
proposed margin rules appear reasonably designed to deter a member or
its customer from assuming an imprudent position in [ByRDs].'' \110\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\109\ See NYSE American Rule 904ByRDs (b) and NYSE Arca Rule
5.86-O(b).
\110\ See Securities Exchange Act Release No. 56251 (August 14,
2007), 72 FR 46523, 46525 (SR-Amex-2004-27).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Finally, the Exchange believes the proposed amendment to the hedge
exemption provision is consistent with the Act because it facilitates
legitimate hedging activity in binary KPI options. Because a liquidity
provider simultaneously holding a short put and short call position in
binary KPI options has taken opposing sides of the potential binary
outcome (i.e., the short call is at risk if the KPI is met, and the
short put is at risk if the KPI is not met), the Exchange believes such
a position represents a defined, bounded risk profile that does not
present the same potential for manipulation or market disruption that
position limits are designed to prevent. The Exchange believes it is
reasonable to make the proposed hedge exemption available

[[Page 75407]]

only to binary KPI positions held by Market Makers. As described above,
binary KPI options are not subject to any hedge exemption from standard
position limits, including any equity hedge exemption granted by
another options exchange upon which an Options Member may otherwise
rely pursuant to Rule 18.8, which is consistent with the Cboe
Rules.\111\ The Exchange believes that offsetting binary KPI option
creates a similar hedge to one to which the equity exemption is
available. The Exchange believes the proposed hedge exemption (in
addition to any other exemptions available under the Rules) will allow
Market Makers to provide depth and liquidity in the marketplace for
binary KPI options. The Exchange therefore believes the hedge exemption
as proposed will encourage market-making activity and liquidity
provision in binary KPI options while protecting investors and the
public.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\111\ See Cboe Rule 8.36(e); Cboe Approval Order, supra note 5,
91 FR at 65881.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

The Exchange also believes proposed Rule 30.7(f) is consistent with
the Act. By establishing tailored reporting requirements for binary KPI
options, the Exchange will be able to monitor Options Member positions
effectively and detect any accumulation of positions that may approach
or exceed applicable limits to the benefit of investors. The Exchange
believes it is consistent with just and equitable principles of trade
for 100 binary KPI option contracts to equal one standard option
contract for purposes of determining whether the report in Rule
18.10(a) is required given the relatively small size of binary KPI
option contracts compared to standard option contracts. As discussed
above, proposed binary KPI options have a multiplier of one, while
standard option contracts have a multiplier of 100. Therefore, the
notional value of a binary KPI option is significantly less than the
notional value of standard option contracts. For example, 200 contracts
with a value of $1.00 with a multiplier of 100 would equate to $20,000
notional value, while 200 binary KPI option contracts with a value of
$1.00 (which is the fixed maximum value of a binary KPI option
contract) with a multiplier of one would equate to $200 notional value.
Counting 100 binary KPI option contracts as one standard option
contract for purposes of this report effectively calibrates the
reporting requirement so that investors are required to submit the
report for an economically equivalent number of contracts, which
promotes just and equitable principles of trade. The Exchange believes
the proposal will provide the Exchange and regulators with visibility
into large position concentrations in binary KPI options, preserving
the ability to identify unusual activity and respond to any unforeseen
concerns, while calibrating the threshold to a metric that is
meaningful for this contract given its smaller multiplier relative to
that of standard equity options. Further, consistent with the Cboe
Rules,\112\ proposed Rule 30.7(f) provides that positions in binary KPI
options are not aggregated with non-binary option contracts overlying
the stock of the issuer in computing reportable positions, which is
consistent with the non-aggregation of such positions for purposes of
position limits discussed above. The Exchange believes this reporting
framework, coupled with the proposed position limits amendments,
provides a fully adequate regulatory framework for these instruments.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\112\ See Cboe Rule 8.43(f).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

The Exchange believes proposed Rule 30.9 is consistent with the Act
and will protect investors and the public interest because it will
ensure that the same margin requirements apply to all binary KPI
options listed on the Exchange, regardless of whether an Options Member
has elected to be bound by the margin rules of Cboe or the NYSE
pursuant to Rule 28.3, and that such requirements are the same as those
that apply to binary KPI options listed on Cboe. As a result, binary
KPI options listed on the Exchange will be fully funded, which the
Commission noted is an important safeguard designed to help protect
investors and to prevent fraud and manipulation.\113\ The proposed rule
is also consistent with the existing framework in Rule 28.3, pursuant
to which the margin rules of Cboe or the NYSE apply to Options Members
as though such rules were part of the Rules.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\113\ See Cboe Approval Order, supra note 5, 91 FR at 65881.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Further, as noted above, the Exchange believes it has an adequate
surveillance program in place to surveil for any potentially heightened
insider trading or manipulation risks that may be presented by the
proposed binary KPI options. The Exchange notes that the settlement
value of a binary KPI option is sourced from the issuer's earnings-
related filing submitted to the Commission. The values of these KPIs
are produced through the accounting and reporting processes of the
issuer, subject to independent audit prior to submission to the
Commission. Because settlement is decoupled from the market price of
the underlying security, no amount of trading activity in that security
could alter the revenue, earnings, or other metric that determines
whether the exercise criterion of a binary KPI option is satisfied. Any
manipulation of the reported KPI would constitute securities fraud and
expose the issuer to liability under federal securities law, separate
and apart from any exchange-related violation.
Moreover, the specifically proposed binary KPI options present a
more defined surveillance profile than other event contracts available
in the market today. Because settlement is tied to a well-defined set
of issuer-KPI metrics contained in earnings-related filings submitted
to the Commission, the relevant surveillance framework operates as a
focused subset of the insider trading surveillances the Exchange
already applies to standard equity options. The legal prohibition on
trading in the issuer's securities, including options, while in
possession of material non-public information about an unreported KPI
is not novel, but rather the same prohibition the Exchange enforces
today for standard equity options overlying the issuer's stock.
The Exchange believes the proposed binary KPI options will serve as
a vehicle to hedge idiosyncratic, event-specific risk embedded in the
specific issuer KPIs. Standard equity options are calibrated to the
price of the underlying security and capture a full spectrum of factors
or risks which may affect the issuer's value, such as macroeconomic
conditions or sector dynamics. Because equity option pricing
incorporates this full spectrum, a participant seeking to hedge
exposure to a single, discrete KPI outcome cannot do so using standard
equity options as precisely as the participant could with binary KPI
options. Settlement of a binary KPI option is determined solely by
whether a specified-issuer KPI meets a defined threshold, so the
contract effectively isolates certain individual risks an investor may
seek to manage. For example, consider an investor holding a long-term
position in a particular issuer stock, who believes the issuer's
quarterly revenue will fall short of expectations (for reasons
unrelated to the issuer's long-term prospects). The investor may
utilize the binary KPI option to hedge more precisely against the near-
term risk without disruption to the underlying equity position. This
targeted hedging utility represents a distinct and additive function
relative to existing listed products, which the Exchange believes will
serve the interests of investors and provide an

[[Page 75408]]

efficient mechanism for managing event-specific, KPI-driven risk.
The Exchange believes the proposed rule change will facilitate
transactions in securities, remove impediments to and perfect the
mechanism of a free and open market and a national market system, and,
in general, protect investors and the public interest, because it will
provide investors with a securities exchange-listed investment choice
for these instruments, offering price transparency and the regulatory
protections of a national securities exchange. The Exchange believes
the proposed rule change will permit investors to manage their risk
exposures and carry out their investment objectives on a securities
exchange with more flexibility and broader applicability. The Exchange
also believes the proposed rule change will promote competition, as it
will meet demands of investors that currently may trade products
structured in substantively the same manner as the proposed binary KPI
options in other markets (as further discussed below). Binary KPI
options would provide investors with a straightforward means of
expressing a directional view on key financial and operating metrics.
The Exchange further believes the proposed rule change is consistent
with the protection of investors and the public interest, as binary KPI
options would be subject to the Exchange's existing rules governing the
listing and trading of options. The Exchange believes expanding the
universe of binary options will benefit investors, particularly retail
investors and other investors who prefer simplicity, as a complementary
offering to current exchange-traded options.
The proposed rule change will permit the Exchange to list binary
KPI options on a national securities exchange as alternatives to
products that are structured in substantially the same manner as binary
options currently available in the OTC market and on other platforms.
The Exchange understands investors have traded binary options similar
to the proposed binary options in OTC markets for many years but may
prefer to trade such options in a listed environment to receive the
benefits of trading listed options. These benefits include: (1)
enhanced efficiency in initiating and closing out positions; (2)
increased market transparency; and (3) heightened contra-party
creditworthiness. The Exchange believes the proposed rule change may
encourage liquidity to shift from the OTC market onto the Exchange,
which the Exchange believes would increase market transparency as well
as enhance the process of price discovery conducted on the Exchange
through increased order flow. The proposed rule change is intended to
provide a market for binary KPI options as a standardized product
without the credit risk of an individual issuer. By providing a listed
and standardized market for more classes of binary options, the
Exchange seeks to attract investors who desire the simplicity of a
binary option with the certainty and safeguards of a regulated and
standardized marketplace. Additionally, unlike an OTC binary option,
contra-party credit risk for Exchange-listed binary KPI options is
significantly reduced through the issuance and guarantee of the
contracts by a registered clearing agency. Further, as an exchange-
traded option, binary options will have the advantage of liquidity
provided by Market Makers, which the Exchange believes may lead to
tighter spreads than those in the OTC market. The Exchange also
believes that standardization will enable more interested parties to
become market participants.
In addition to the OTC market, various market platforms that are
not registered as national securities exchanges currently offer
products structured in substantively the same manner as the binary KPI
options the Exchange proposes to list. These platforms offer binary
option products overlying issuer KPIs, which may be settled at varying
points of the day (not just at the open and close of the trading day).
However, as these venues are not national securities exchanges, they do
not offer investors the benefits of centralized liquidity, market
transparency, or securities regulations intended to protect investors.
The Exchange believes listing competitive products on a national
securities exchange would create a centralized and standardized
marketplace for these products, which promotes price discovery and
transparency, within an established and appropriate regulatory
framework designed to afford investors in securities with important
protections. In other words, the Exchange believes its proposal offers
a more transparent platform than the OTC market or other market
platforms offer. It would contribute to leveling the playing field with
these alternative markets and provide investors with safeguards
associated with Commission and SRO oversight of the trading activity in
the proposed exchange-listed binary KPI options.
Ultimately, the Exchange believes the proposed rule change will
provide investors with greater trading tools and opportunities and
flexibility, resulting in investors having additional means to carry
out their investment objectives and manage their risk exposures through
products listed and traded on a national securities exchange. The
Exchange believes the proposed rule change will offer market
participants a simplified, transparent, and limited risk investment
choice that may be more aligned with their specific timing needs,
investment and hedging strategies, and risk tolerances. The Exchange
believes it benefits the investing public to continue to enhance its
listed product offerings to respond to continuously changing needs of
investors and to a continuously changing competitive environment.
A robust and competitive market requires exchanges to respond to
investors' evolving needs by regularly improving their offerings. When
Congress charged the Commission with supervising the development of a
``national market system'' for securities, Congress stated its intent
that the ``national market system evolve through the interplay of
competitive forces as unnecessary regulatory restrictions are
removed.'' \114\ Consistent with this purpose, Congress and the
Commission have repeatedly stated their preference for competition,
rather than regulatory intervention to determine products and services
in the securities markets.\115\ This consistent and considered judgment
of Congress and the Commission is correct, particularly in light of
evidence of robust competition in the options trading industry. The
fact that an exchange proposed something new is a reason to be
receptive, not skeptical--innovation is the lifeblood of a vibrant
competitive market--and that is particularly so given the continued
internationalization of the securities markets, as exchanges and other

[[Page 75409]]

platforms continue to implement new products and services to compete
not only in the United States but throughout the world. Options
exchanges continuously adopt new and different products and trading
services in response to industry demands to attract order flow and to
increase their trading volume. This competition has led to a growth in
investment choices, which ultimately benefits the marketplace and the
public. The Exchange believes the proposed rule change will help
further competition by providing market participants with yet another
investment option for options listed on a national securities exchange.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\114\ See H.R. Rep. No. 94-229, at 92 (1975) (Conf. Rep.).
\115\ See S. Rep. No. 94-75, 94th Cong., 1st Sess. 8 (1975)
(``The objective [in enacting the 1975 amendments to the Exchange
Act] would be to enhance competition and to allow economic forces,
interacting within a fair regulatory field, to arrive at appropriate
variations in practices and services.''); Order Approving Proposed
Rule Change Relating to NYSE Arca Data, Securities Exchange Act
Release No. 59039 (December 2, 2008), 73 FR 74770 (December 9, 2008)
(``The Exchange Act and its legislative history strongly support the
Commission's reliance on competition, whenever possible, in meeting
its regulatory responsibilities for overseeing the [self-regulatory
organizations] and the national market system. Indeed, competition
among multiple markets and market participants trading the same
products is the hallmark of the national market system.''); and
Regulation NMS, 70 FR at 37499 (observing that NMS regulation ``has
been remarkably successful in promoting market competition in [the]
forms that are most important to investors and listed companies'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

B. Self-Regulatory Organization's Statement on Burden on Competition

The Exchange does not believe that the proposed rule change will
impose any burden on competition that is not necessary or appropriate
in furtherance of the purposes of the Act. The Exchange does not
believe that the proposed rule change will impose any burden on
intramarket competition that is not necessary or appropriate in
furtherance of the purposes of the Act, because binary KPI options will
be available to all market participants who wish to trade such options
on the same terms and in the same manner (including with respect to the
payout terms and amount). All market participants will be subject to
the same rules applicable to binary KPI options, as described in this
proposed rule change. Except as set forth in the proposed rule change,
binary KPI options will trade in the same manner as other options on
the Exchange.
The Exchange does not believe the proposed rule change will impose
any burden on intermarket competition that is not necessary or
appropriate in furtherance of the purposes of the Act, because other
options exchanges may propose similar products. Rather, the Exchange
believes the proposed rule change will promote intermarket competition,
as it will permit the Exchange to list and trade binary KPI options
with the same terms as the binary KPI options that the Commission
recently approved for listing and trading on Cboe,\116\ thereby
providing market participants with an additional venue on which to
trade these products.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\116\ See Cboe Approval Order, supra note 5, 91 FR at 65876.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

The Exchange notes that it operates in a highly competitive market
in which market participants can readily direct order flow to competing
venues that offer similar products, including Cboe, which may list
binary KPI options with the same terms as those proposed herein. The
Exchange believes the proposed rule change will promote competition by
providing market participants with an additional venue on which to
trade binary KPI options.

C. Self-Regulatory Organization's Statement on Comments on the Proposed
Rule Change Received From Members, Participants, or Others

The Exchange neither solicited nor received written comments on the
proposed rule change.

III. Date of Effectiveness of the Proposed Rule Change and Timing for
Commission Action

The Exchange has filed the proposed rule change pursuant to Section
19(b)(3)(A)(iii) of the Act \117\ and Rule 19b-4(f)(6) thereunder.\118\
Because the proposed rule change does not: (i) significantly affect the
protection of investors or the public interest; (ii) impose any
significant burden on competition; and (iii) become operative prior to
30 days from the date on which it was filed, or such shorter time as
the Commission may designate, if consistent with the protection of
investors and the public interest, the proposed rule change has become
effective pursuant to Section 19(b)(3)(A) of the Act and Rule 19b-
4(f)(6) thereunder.\119\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\117\ 15 U.S.C. 78s(b)(3)(A)(iii).
\118\ 17 CFR 240.19b-4(f)(6).
\119\ 17 CFR 240.19b-4(f)(6). In addition, Rule 19b-4(f)(6)(iii)
requires a self-regulatory organization to give the Commission
written notice of its intent to file the proposed rule change, along
with a brief description and text of the proposed rule change, at
least five business days prior to the date of filing of the proposed
rule change, or such shorter time as designated by the Commission.
The Exchange has satisfied this requirement.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

At any time within 60 days of the filing of such proposed rule
change, the Commission summarily may temporarily suspend such rule
change if it appears to the Commission that such action is necessary or
appropriate in the public interest, for the protection of investors, or
otherwise in furtherance of the purposes of the Act. If the Commission
takes such action, the Commission shall institute proceedings under
Section 19(b)(2)(B) \120\ of the Act to determine whether the proposed
rule change should be approved or disapproved.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\120\ 15 U.S.C. 78s(b)(2)(B).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

IV. Solicitation of Comments

Interested persons are invited to submit written data, views and
arguments concerning the foregoing, including whether the proposed rule
change is consistent with the Act. Comments may be submitted by any of
the following methods:

Electronic Comments

Use the Commission's internet comment form (http://www.sec.gov/rules/sro.shtml); or
Send an email to [email protected]. Please include
File Number SR-MEMX-2026-35 on the subject line.

Paper Comments

Send paper comments in triplicate to Secretary, Securities
and Exchange Commission, 100 F Street NE, Washington, DC 20549-1090.

All submissions should refer to File Number SR-MEMX-2026-35. This file
number should be included on the subject line if email is used. To help
the Commission process and review your comments more efficiently,
please use only one method. The Commission will post all comments on
the Commission's internet website (http://www.sec.gov/rules/sro.shtml).
Copies of the filing will be available for inspection and copying at
the principal office of the Exchange. Do not include personal
identifiable information in submissions; you should submit only
information that you wish to make available publicly. We may redact in
part or withhold entirely from publication submitted material that is
obscene or subject to copyright protection. All submissions should
refer to File Number SR-MEMX-2026-35 and should be submitted on or
before December 11, 2026.

For the Commission, by the Division of Trading and Markets,
pursuant to delegated authority.\121\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\121\ 17 CFR 200.30-3(a)(12).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Vanessa A. Countryman,
Secretary.
[FR Doc. 2026-23650 Filed 11-19-26; 8:45 am]
BILLING CODE 8011-01-P

공식 발표 ↔ 매체 보도

진보 성향0

보도 없음

중도 성향0

보도 없음

보수 성향0

보도 없음