Marine Mammals; Incidental Take During Specified Activities; Proposed Incidental Harassment Authorization for Southcentral Alaska Stock of Northern Sea Otters at the ARRC Seward Alaska Marine Terminal Freight Dock in Seward, Alaska
[Federal Register Volume 91, Number 224 (Monday, November 23, 2026)]
[Notices]
[Pages 75539-75554]
From the Federal Register Online via the Government Publishing Office [www.gpo.gov]
[FR Doc No: 2026-23734]
[[Page 75539]]
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR
Fish and Wildlife Service
[Docket No. FWS-R7-ES-2026-3037; FXES111607MRG01-267-FF07CAMM00]
Marine Mammals; Incidental Take During Specified Activities;
Proposed Incidental Harassment Authorization for Southcentral Alaska
Stock of Northern Sea Otters at the ARRC Seward Alaska Marine Terminal
Freight Dock in Seward, Alaska
AGENCY: Fish and Wildlife Service, Interior.
ACTION: Notice of receipt of application; proposed incidental
harassment authorization; draft environmental assessment; request for
comments.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
SUMMARY: We, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS), in response to a
request under the Marine Mammal Protection Act of 1972, as amended,
from the Alaska Railroad Corporation, propose to authorize incidental
take by harassment of small numbers of Southcentral Alaska stock
northern sea otters (Enhydra lutris kenyoni) for a period of up to 1
year. The applicant has requested this authorization for take by
harassment that may result from activities associated with pile driving
and marine construction at the Seward Alaska Marine Terminal Freight
Dock in Seward, Alaska. This proposed authorization, if finalized,
would be for incidental take by Level A harassment and Level B
harassment of northern sea otters from the Southcentral Alaska stock.
We invite comments on the proposed incidental harassment authorization
and the accompanying draft environmental assessment from the public,
Tribes, and local, State, and Federal agencies.
DATES: Comments must be received by December 23, 2026.
To ensure your comment is received and considered, you must submit
it using one of the methods identified in the ADDRESSES section of this
document. Comments submitted through any method not authorized in this
document, or sent to an address not listed here, will not be
considered.
ADDRESSES: Document availability: You may view the application package,
the draft environmental assessment, and other supporting material at
https://www.regulations.gov under Docket No. FWS-R7-ES-2026-3037 or you
may request these documents from the person listed under FOR FURTHER
INFORMATION CONTACT.
Comment submission: You may submit comments on the proposed
authorization by one of the following methods:
Electronic submission: Go to the Federal eRulemaking
Portal: https://www.regulations.gov. In the Search box, enter FWS-R7-
ES-2026-3037 which is the docket number for this action. Then, click on
the ``Search'' button. On the resulting page, in the panel on the left
side of the screen under the ``Document Type'' heading, check the
Notice box to locate this document. You may submit a comment by
clicking on ``Comment.'' Comments must be submitted to https://www.regulations.gov before 11:59 p.m. (Eastern Time) on the date
specified in DATES.
U.S. mail: Public Comments Processing, Attn: Docket No.
FWS-R7-ES-2026-3037 U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, MS: PRB (JAO/3W),
5275 Leesburg Pike, Falls Church, VA 22041-3803.
We request that you send comments only by the methods described
above. We will post all comments at https://www.regulations.gov. You
may request that we withhold personal identifying information from
public review; however, we cannot guarantee that we will be able to do
so. See Request for Public Comments for more information.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Stephanie Burgess, by email at
[email protected], by telephone at 907-786-3800, or by U.S. mail
at U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, MS 341, 1011 East Tudor Road,
Anchorage, AK 99503. Individuals in the United States who are deaf,
deafblind, hard of hearing, or have a speech disability may dial 711
(TTY, TDD, or TeleBraille) to access telecommunications relay services.
Individuals outside the United States should use the relay services
offered within their country to make international calls to the point-
of-contact in the United States.
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
Background
Section 101(a)(5)(D) of the Marine Mammal Protection Act of 1972
(MMPA; 16 U.S.C. 1361, et seq.) authorizes the Secretary of the
Interior (Secretary) to allow, upon request, the incidental, but not
intentional, taking by harassment of small numbers of certain marine
mammals in response to requests by U.S. citizens (as defined in title
50 of the Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) in part 18, at 50 CFR
18.27(c)) engaged in a specified activity (other than commercial
fishing) within a specified geographic region during a period of not
more than 1 year. The Secretary has delegated authority for
implementation of the MMPA to the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS,
or we). According to the MMPA, the FWS shall allow this incidental
taking by harassment if we find that the total of such taking for the
1-year period:
1. Will affect only small numbers of individuals of the species or
stock;
2. Will have no more than a negligible impact on the species or
stock; and
3. Will not have an unmitigable adverse impact on the availability
of these species or stock for taking for subsistence use by Alaska
Natives.
If the requisite findings are made, we issue an authorization that
sets forth the following, where applicable:
1. Permissible methods of taking;
2. Means of effecting the least practicable adverse impact on the
species or stock and its habitat and the availability of the species or
stock for subsistence uses; and
3. Requirements for monitoring and reporting of such taking by
harassment, including, in certain circumstances, requirements for the
independent peer review of proposed monitoring plans or other research
proposals.
The term ``take'' means to ``harass, hunt, capture, or kill, or to
attempt to harass, hunt, capture, or kill any marine mammal'' (16
U.S.C. 1362(13)). Harassment for activities other than military
readiness activities or scientific research conducted by or on behalf
of the Federal Government means any act of pursuit, torment, or
annoyance that has the potential to injure a marine mammal or marine
mammal stock in the wild (the MMPA defines this as ``Level A
harassment''), or has the potential to disturb a marine mammal or
marine mammal stock in the wild by causing disruption of behavioral
patterns, including, but not limited to, migration, breathing, nursing,
breeding, feeding, or sheltering (the MMPA defines this as ``Level B
harassment'') (16 U.S.C. 1362(18)).
The terms ``negligible impact'' and ``unmitigable adverse impact''
are defined in 50 CFR 18.27(c) as follows: ``Negligible impact'' is an
impact resulting from the specified activity that cannot be reasonably
expected to, and is not reasonably likely to, adversely affect the
species or stock through effects on annual rates of recruitment or
survival. ``Unmitigable adverse impact'' means an impact resulting from
the specified activity: (1) that is likely to reduce the availability
of the species to a level insufficient for a harvest to meet
subsistence needs by (i) causing the marine mammals to abandon or avoid
hunting areas, (ii) directly displacing subsistence users, or (iii)
placing physical barriers between the marine
[[Page 75540]]
mammals and the subsistence hunters; and (2) that cannot be
sufficiently mitigated by other measures to increase the availability
of marine mammals to allow subsistence needs to be met.
The term ``small numbers'' is also defined in 50 CFR 18.27(c).
However, we do not rely on that definition here as it conflates ``small
numbers'' with ``negligible impacts.'' We recognize ``small numbers''
and ``negligible impacts'' as two separate and distinct considerations
when reviewing requests for incidental harassment authorizations (IHA)
under the MMPA (see Ctr. for Biological Diversity v. Salazar, 695 F.3d
893, 904 (9th Cir. 2012)). Instead, for our small numbers
determination, we estimate the likely number of marine mammals to be
taken and evaluate if that take is small relative to the size of the
species or stock.
The term ``least practicable adverse impact'' is not defined in the
MMPA or its enacting regulations. In processing requests for IHAs, we
ensure the least practicable adverse impact by requiring mitigation
measures that are effective in reducing the impact of specified
activities, but they are not so restrictive as to make specified
activities unduly burdensome or impossible to undertake and complete.
Summary of Request
On April 12, 2024, the FWS received a request prepared by PND
Engineers, Inc. on behalf of the Alaska Railroad Corporation
(hereafter, ARRC or the applicant) for an authorization to take by
harassment northern sea otters (Enhydra lutris kenyoni) (hereafter, sea
otters unless another sea otter subspecies is specified) from the
Southcentral Alaska stock. The applicant expects that take by
harassment may occur during their expansion and improvement of the
existing Seward Alaska Marine Terminal Freight Dock and associated
transportation corridor within the Alaska Railroad Terminal Reserve in
Seward, Alaska. The FWS requested additional information on project
activities, geospatial files of the project impact area, estimated take
numbers, and mitigation measures, and the ARRC provided the requested
information. We received a revised request on June 15, 2026, and we
determined the revised request to be adequate and complete.
Description of Specified Geographic Region and Specified Activities
The specified geographic region is the nearshore waters and
intertidal areas surrounding the existing Seward Alaska Marine Terminal
Freight Dock (hereafter, project location). The project location is at
the head of Resurrection Bay between the Resurrection River delta and
the Seward Small Boat Harbor located in Seward, Alaska (figure 1).
BILLING CODE 4333-15-P
[[Page 75541]]
[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TN23NO26.000
BILLING CODE 4333-15-C
The specified activity (hereafter project) will include expanding
the existing Freight Dock by 114 meters (m) (375 feet [ft]) with a
sheet pile bulkhead backed by a rock revetment and installing typical
dock components, such as fenders, mooring bollards, sacrificial anodes,
and bullrail. The project will also include installation of a mooring
dolphin and catwalk, widening the existing uplands, improving upland
facilities, and improving the transportation corridor that connects the
dock to the road and rail networks. The proposed project activities
will improve safety for pedestrians and stevedoring activities, improve
transport efficiency for goods, accommodate larger vessels, and
ultimately enhance the long-term utility of the Freight Dock.
The applicant, the ARRC, plans to remove four existing dolphin
piles that are 61 centimeters (cm) (24 inches [in]) in diameter, and
install and remove 60 61.0-cm (24-in) temporary template piles. They
will also install 425 new sheet pile pairs, 14 new anchor H-piles, 14
new 76.2-cm (30-in) fender piles, and four new 76.2-cm (30-in) dolphin
piles during the in-water components of the dock expansion work.
Uplands work will include removal of one existing onshore 61.0-cm (24-
in) bollard pile, installation and removal of 2,157 temporary
vibrocompaction H-pile probes, and installation of two new 76.2-cm (30-
in) bollard piles and three new 76.2-cm (30-in) high mast light piles.
Pile removal will be conducted using a vibratory hammer and pile
installation will be conducted with a combination of impact and
vibratory hammers. Hereafter (unless otherwise specified), the terms
``pile driving'' and ``pile-driving activities'' are used to refer to
both pile installation and pile
[[Page 75542]]
removal. Project activities are summarized in table 1.
Table 1--ARRC Seward Alaska Marine Terminal Freight Dock Project Activities, Piles Installed or Removed, and Days of Activity
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Maximum number Maximum number
Location Project component Pile size and Activity Total number of piles per of activity
material of piles day days
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
In Water........................... Existing dolphin 61.0-cm (24-in) round Removal--vibratory... 4 4 4
piles. steel. Installation--vibrato 60 6 50
Temporary template 61.0-cm (24-in) steel ry.
piles. pipe.
Temporary template 61.0-cm (24-in) steel Removal--vibratory... 60 6 50
piles. pipe.
New sheet pile pairs. Steel sheet pile..... Installation--vibrato 425 20 75
ry.
New anchor piles..... Steel H-piles........ Installation--vibrato 14 2 15
ry.
New fender piles..... 76.2-cm (30-in) round Installation--vibrato 14 4 6
steel. ry.
New dolphin piles.... 76.2-cm (30-in) round Installation--vibrato 4 2 5
steel. ry.
New dolphin piles.... 76.2-cm (30-in) round Installation--impact. 4 2 5
steel.
Uplands............................ Existing onshore 61.0-cm (24-in) round Removal--vibratory... 1 1 1
bollard pile. steel.
Temporary Steel H-pile probe... Installation--vibrato 2157 20 100
vibrocompaction ry.
probes.
Temporary Steel H-pile probe... Removal--vibratory... 2157 20 100
vibrocompaction
probes.
New bollard piles.... 76.2-cm (30-in) round Installation--vibrato 2 1 2
steel. ry.
New high mast light 76.2-cm (30-in) round Installation--vibrato 3 3 3
piles. steel. ry.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Pile-driving activities will occur up to a maximum of 265 non-
consecutive days during the 1-year period of the IHA, if finalized.
Uplands pile-driving activities will overlap with the in-water work
period, but it is unknown to what extent they will overlap. Materials
and equipment will be transported to Seward via barge, rail, and road.
Project vessels will originate in Seattle, Anchorage, or Unalaska. The
applicant will also use a land- and/or barge-based excavator or crane
to support construction operations. Additional project details may be
reviewed in the application materials available as described under
ADDRESSES or may also be requested as described under FOR FURTHER
INFORMATION CONTACT.
Description of Marine Mammals in the Specified Geographic Region
The sea otter is the only marine mammal species under the FWS's
jurisdiction likely to be found within the specified geographic region.
Information on the range, stocks, and biology of sea otters is included
in supplemental information, which can be found as described above in
ADDRESSES.
Potential Impacts of the Specified Activities on Marine Mammals
Effects of Noise on Sea Otters
We characterize ``noise'' as sound released into the environment
from human activities that exceeds ambient levels or interferes with
normal sound production or reception by sea otters. The terms
``acoustic disturbance'' and ``acoustic harassment'' are disturbances
or harassment events resulting from noise exposure. Potential effects
of noise exposure are likely to depend on the sea otter's distance from
the sound source, the sound level and intensity the sea otter receives,
background noise levels, noise frequency, noise duration, and whether
the noise is pulsed or continuous. The actual noise level perceived by
individual sea otters will also depend on whether the sea otter is
above or below water and atmospheric and environmental conditions.
Temporary disturbance of sea otters or localized displacement reactions
are the most likely effects to occur from noise exposure.
Sea Otter Hearing
Pile driving and marine construction activities produce sound
within sea otters' hearing range. Controlled sound exposure trials on
southern sea otters (Enhydra lutris nereis) indicate that sea otters
can hear frequencies between 125 hertz (Hz) and 38 kilohertz (kHz),
with best sensitivity between 1.2 and 27 kHz (Ghoul and Reichmuth
2014). Sea otters are more adept at aerial hearing, and their hearing
sensitivity is similar to that of terrestrial carnivores (Reichmuth and
Ghoul 2012; Ghoul and Reichmuth 2016; Zellmer et al. 2021). Aerial and
underwater audiograms for a captive adult male southern sea otter in
the presence of ambient noise suggest the sea otter's hearing was less
sensitive to high-frequency (greater than 22 kHz) and low-frequency
(less than 2 kHz) sound than that of terrestrial mustelids but was
similar to that of a California sea lion (Zalophus californianus).
However, the sea otter was still able to hear low-frequency sounds, and
the detection thresholds for sounds between 0.125 and 1 kHz were
between 116 and 101 decibels (dB), respectively. Dominant frequencies
of southern sea otter vocalizations are between 3 and 8 kHz, with some
energy extending above 60 kHz (McShane et al. 1995; Ghoul and Reichmuth
2012).
[[Page 75543]]
Exposure to high levels of sound may cause changes in behavior,
masking of communications, temporary or permanent changes in hearing
sensitivity, discomfort, and injury to marine mammals. Sea otters do
not rely on sound to orient themselves, locate prey, or communicate
under water; therefore, masking of communications by anthropogenic
noise is less of a concern for sea otters than for other marine
mammals. However, sea otters, especially mothers and pups, do use sound
for communication in air (McShane et al. 1995), and sea otters may
monitor underwater sound to avoid predators (Davis et al. 1987).
Exposure Thresholds
Underwater Sounds
Noise exposure criteria for identifying underwater noise levels
capable of causing Level A harassment (injury) to marine mammal
species, including sea otters, have been established using the same
methods as those previously used by the National Marine Fisheries
Service (NMFS) (Southall et al. 2019). These criteria are based on
estimated levels of sound exposure capable of causing a permanent shift
in hearing sensitivity, that is, a permanent threshold shift (PTS)
(NMFS 2018). A PTS occurs when noise exposure causes damage to hair
cells within the inner ear system (Ketten 2012). A sea otter that
experiences PTS would be permanently unable to hear certain sounds at
frequencies similar to those that caused the initial injury. Although
the effects of PTS are, by definition, permanent, PTS does not equate
to total hearing loss.
Sound exposure thresholds incorporate two metrics of exposure: the
peak level of instantaneous exposure likely to cause PTS, and the
cumulative sound exposure level (SELCUM) during a 24-hour
period. They also include weighting adjustments for the sensitivity of
different species to varying frequencies. The PTS-based injury criteria
were developed from theoretical extrapolation of observations of
temporary threshold shifts (TTS) detected in lab settings during sound
exposure trials (Finneran 2015). A TTS is a noise-induced threshold
shift in hearing sensitivity that fully recovers over time (Finneran
2015). Southall et al. (2019) developed TTS thresholds for sea otters,
which are included in the ``other marine carnivores'' category, of 188
dB SELCUM re 1 micropascal ([micro]Pa) for impulsive
underwater sound and 199 dB SELCUM for nonimpulsive
underwater sound. Based on these analyses, Southall et al. (2019)
predict that PTS for sea otters will occur at 232 dB peak sound
pressure level (SPL) or 203 dB SELCUM for impulsive
underwater sound and 219 dB SELCUM for nonimpulsive
underwater sound.
The NMFS has revised their sound exposure criteria to include
thresholds for auditory injury (NMFS 2024). We are evaluating the
auditory injury criteria to determine whether they are appropriate for
FWS trust species, as sea otters in particular are not exposed to in-
water noise for an entire 24-hour period.
The NMFS (2018) sound exposure criteria do not identify thresholds
for avoidance of Level B harassment. For pinnipeds (seals and sea
lions), NMFS has adopted a 160-dB threshold for Level B harassment from
exposure to impulsive noise and a 120-dB threshold for nonimpulsive
noise (High Energy Seismic Survey Team 1999; NMFS 2018). These
thresholds were developed from observations of mysticete (baleen)
whales responding to airgun operations (e.g., Malme et al. 1983; Malme
and Miles 1983; Richardson et al. 1986, 1995). Southall et al. (2007,
2019) assessed behavioral response studies and found considerable
variability among pinnipeds. The authors determined that exposures
between approximately 90 to 140 dB generally do not appear to induce
strong behavioral responses from pinnipeds in water. However, they
found behavioral effects, including avoidance, become more likely in
the range between 120 and 160 dB, and most marine mammals showed some,
albeit variable, responses to sound between 140 and 180 dB. Wood et al.
(2012) adapted the approach identified in Southall et al. (2007) to
develop a probabilistic scale for marine mammal taxa at which 10
percent, 50 percent, and 90 percent of individuals exposed are assumed
to produce a behavioral response. For many marine mammals, including
pinnipeds, these response rates were set at 140, 160, and 180 dB SPLs,
respectively.
We have evaluated these thresholds and determined that the Level B
harassment threshold of 120 dB for nonimpulsive noise is not applicable
to sea otters. The 120-dB threshold is based on studies in which gray
whales (Eschrichtius robustus) were exposed to experimental playbacks
of industrial noise (Malme et al. 1983; Malme and Miles 1983). During
these playback studies, southern sea otter responses to industrial
noise were also monitored (Riedman 1983, 1984). While gray whales
exhibited avoidance to industrial noise at the 120-dB threshold, there
was no evidence of disturbance reactions or avoidance in southern sea
otters. Thus, given the differences in hearing and behavior between sea
otters and gray whales, the NMFS 120-dB threshold based on gray whale
behavior is not appropriate for predicting sea otter behavioral
responses.
Based on the lack of sea otter disturbance response or any other
reaction to the playback studies from the 1980s, as well as the absence
of a clear pattern of disturbance or avoidance behaviors attributable
to underwater sound levels up to about 160 dB resulting from low-
frequency broadband noise, we assume 120 dB is not an appropriate
behavioral response threshold for sea otters exposed to nonimpulsive
underwater noise.
Based on the best available scientific information about sea otters
and closely related marine mammals where sea otter data are limited,
the FWS has set 160 dB of received underwater sound as a threshold for
take by Level B harassment of sea otters in this proposed IHA. Exposure
to in-water noise levels between 125 Hz and 38 kHz that are greater
than 160 dB--for both impulsive and nonimpulsive sound sources--will be
considered by the FWS as Level B harassment. Thresholds for Level A
harassment (which entails the potential for injury) for in-water noise
levels between 125 Hz and 38 kHz are 232 dB peak SPL or 203 dB
SELCUM for impulsive sounds and 219 dB SELCUM for
nonimpulsive sounds (table 2 below).
Airborne Sounds
Thresholds for Level A harassment for in-air noise levels are 176
dB peak SPL re 20 [mu]Pa or 161 dB SELCUM for impulsive
sounds and 177 dB SELCUM for nonimpulsive sounds (table 2).
The NMFS (2018) guidance neither addresses thresholds for preventing
injury or disturbance from airborne noise, nor provides thresholds for
avoidance of Level B harassment. The NMFS currently recommends 100 dB
for all pinnipeds, excluding harbor seals, as the Level B harassment
threshold for in-air noise (NMFS 2025). Conveyance of underwater noise
into the air is of little concern since the effects of pressure release
and interference at the water's surface reduce underwater noise
transmission into the air. For activities that create both in-air and
underwater noise, we will estimate take based on parameters for
underwater noise transmission. Considering sound energy travels more
efficiently through water than through air, this estimation will also
account for exposures to sea otters at the surface.
Pile-driving activities are intermittent in nature, and there are
typically breaks in sound production after the removal or installation
of one pile is completed
[[Page 75544]]
and before the installation or removal of another pile commences.
Furthermore, pile-driving activities will only occur during daylight
hours. Additionally, the Level A harassment thresholds for all
activities and the Level B harassment thresholds for all but one
activity (impact installation of 30-in steel piles) are less than 40 m.
The impact installation of 30-in steel piles, with a Level B harassment
threshold of 1,000 m will only occur on five days. Due to the
combination of intermittent sound production, planned schedule for
pile-driving activities, and relatively small harassment thresholds,
the FWS does not anticipate that sea otters will experience continuous
noise, whether underwater or above water, that they cannot get away
from.
Southall et al. (2019) have developed TTS and PTS thresholds for
other marine carnivores, which include sea otters, for airborne
impulsive and non-impulsive sounds (table 2). For project activities
that create only airborne sounds, such as pile driving on land, the
sound levels are significantly below the TTS thresholds developed by
Southall et al. 2019. Since otariid pinnipeds are the closest available
physiological and anatomical proxy for sea otters, we used the NMFS
criteria for pinniped harassment from exposure to airborne sound to
estimate take by Level B harassment from pile driving on shore.
Table 2--Temporary Threshold Shift (TTS) and Permanent Threshold Shift (PTS) Thresholds
[Established by Southall et al. (2019) through modeling and extrapolation for ``Other Marine Carnivores'', which
include sea otters.*]
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
TTS PTS
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
nonimpulsive impulsive nonimpulsive impulsive
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
SELCUM SELCUM Peak SPL SELCUM SELCUM Peak SPL
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Air................................ 157 146 170 177 161 176
Water.............................. 199 188 226 219 203 232
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
* Values are weighted for other marine carnivores' hearing thresholds and given in cumulative sound exposure
level (SELCUM dB re (20 micropascal [[mu]Pa] in air and SELCUM dB re 1 [mu]Pa in water) for impulsive and
nonimpulsive sounds, and unweighted peak sound pressure level (SPL) in air (dB re 20[mu]Pa) and water (dB
1[mu]Pa) (impulsive sounds only).
Evidence From Sea Otter Studies
Individual sea otters near the project location would likely show a
range of responses to noise from pile-driving activities. Some sea
otters would likely dive, show startle responses, change direction of
travel, or prematurely surface. Sea otters reacting to pile-driving
activities may divert time and attention from biologically important
behaviors, such as feeding and nursing pups. Sea otter responses to
disturbance can result in energetic costs. For example, sea otters
spend more time traveling in areas with high levels of disturbance
(Curland 1997). Higher energetic costs require increased amounts of
prey consumption (Barrett 2019). This increased prey consumption may
impact sea otter prey availability and cause sea otters to spend more
time foraging and less time resting (Barrett 2019). Some sea otters may
abandon the project location and return when the disturbance has
ceased. Based on the observed movement patterns of sea otters (Lensink
1962; Kenyon 1969, 1981; Garshelis and Garshelis 1984; Riedman and
Estes 1990), we expect some sea otters would respond to pile-driving
activities by dispersing to nearby areas of suitable habitat; however,
other sea otters, especially territorial adult males, would not leave.
Additional information on the evidence from studies about how sea
otters may be affected by noise can be found in the supplemental
information to this document (available as described above in
ADDRESSES).
Consequences of Permanent Threshold Shift
Sea otters exposed to noise levels above Level A harassment
threshold criteria may experience a permanent shift in the sensitivity
of their hearing. Information on the consequences of a PTS in sea otter
hearing due to noise exposure can be found in the supplemental
information to this document (available as described above in
ADDRESSES).
Consequences of Disturbance
Information on the consequences of disturbance to sea otters can be
found in the supplemental information to this document (available as
described above in ADDRESSES).
Vessel Activities
Vessel activity during the project includes the use of barges to
transport and stage equipment and materials to support construction
operations. Vessels will not be used extensively or over a long
duration during project activities. We do not anticipate that sea
otters would experience changes in behavior indicative of harassment
during vessel operations. Additionally, vessel operators would take
every precaution to avoid harassment of sea otters when operating a
vessel near sea otters and implement mitigation measures described in
the ARRC's request and below in this proposed IHA, which include
maintaining a minimum distance of 100 m (328 ft) from all sea otters.
Additional information on vessel activities can be found in the
supplemental information to this document (available as described above
in ADDRESSES).
Effects on Sea Otter Habitat and Prey
Information on the potential impacts of the specified activities on
sea otter habitat and prey species can be found in the supplemental
information to this document (available as described above in
ADDRESSES). Based on this information, we do not anticipate any
harassment to sea otters due to effects on sea otter habitat or prey
from the specified activities.
Potential Impacts of the Specified Activities on Subsistence Uses
The project activities will occur in areas rarely used for
subsistence harvesting activity. No subsistence harvest of sea otters
was documented in close proximity to Seward from 2013 through 2022, and
only two sea otters were harvested in the area in 2023. In 2024, there
were 10 sea otters harvested in the Seward area, but there are no
reports of sea otter harvest near Seward in 2025.
The planned project will occur within the city limits of Seward,
where firearm use is prohibited. The area potentially affected by the
planned project does not significantly overlap with current subsistence
harvest areas. Construction activities will not preclude access to
hunting areas or interfere in any way with individuals wishing to hunt.
Despite no conflict with subsistence use
[[Page 75545]]
being anticipated, the FWS will conduct outreach with potentially
affected communities to see whether there are any questions, concerns,
or potential conflicts regarding subsistence use in those areas. If any
conflicts are identified in the future, the ARRC will develop a plan of
cooperation (POC) specifying the steps necessary to minimize any
effects the project may have on subsistence harvest.
Estimated Take
Definitions of Incidental Take Under the MMPA
Under the MMPA, ``take'' means ``to harass, hunt, capture, or kill,
or attempt to harass, hunt, capture, or kill any marine mammal'' (16
U.S.C. 1362(13)). Below we provide definitions of three types of take
of sea otters. This discussion is provided for context and background
and does not necessarily reflect what is anticipated to result from the
specified activities.
Lethal Take
In the most serious interactions, human actions can result in the
mortality of sea otters, which we define here as lethal take.
Level A Harassment
The MMPA defines Level A harassment for nonmilitary readiness
activities as ``any act of pursuit, torment, or annoyance which . . .
has the potential to injure a marine mammal or marine mammal stock in
the wild'' (16 U.S.C. 1362(18)(A)(i), (C)). We interpret this
definition to include human activity that may result in PTS in a sea
otter's hearing sensitivity or injury to sea otters.
Level B Harassment
The MMPA defines Level B harassment for nonmilitary readiness
activities as ``any act of pursuit, torment, or annoyance which . . .
has the potential to disturb a marine mammal or marine mammal stock in
the wild by causing disruption of behavioral patterns, including, but
not limited to, migration, breathing, nursing, feeding, or sheltering''
(16 U.S.C. 1362(18)(A)(ii), (D)). We interpret this definition to
include human-caused reactions that disrupt biologically significant
behaviors or activities for the affected animal. Such reactions
include, but are not limited to, the following:
Swimming away at a fast pace on belly (i.e., porpoising);
Repeatedly raising the head vertically above the water to
get a better view (spyhopping) while apparently agitated or while
swimming away;
In the case of a pup, repeatedly spyhopping while hiding
behind and holding onto its mother's head;
Abandoning prey or feeding area;
Ceasing to nurse and/or rest (applies to dependent pups);
Ceasing to rest (applies to independent animals);
Ceasing to use movement corridors;
Ceasing mating behaviors;
Shifting/jostling/agitation in a raft (i.e., group of 10
or more sea otters) so that the raft disperses;
Sudden diving of an entire raft;
Flushing animals off a haulout; or
TTS in a sea otter's hearing sensitivity.
This list does not encompass all possible behaviors that indicate
Level B harassment; other behavioral responses may be indicative of
take by Level B harassment. In some circumstances, eliciting behavioral
responses that equate to take by Level B harassment repeatedly may
result in Level A harassment. Relatively minor changes in behavior such
as the animal raising its head or temporarily changing its direction of
travel are not likely to disrupt biologically important behavioral
patterns, and the FWS does not view such minor changes in behavior as
indicative of a take by Level B harassment.
Calculating Take
The FWS does not anticipate the Level A harassment or Level B
harassment of sea otters as a result of barge operations or gravel fill
placement. Barges will be operated in areas with year-round boat
traffic at conservatively slow speeds, significantly reducing the
probability of sea otter harassment. Barge movements and gravel fill
placement are not anticipated to generate appreciable underwater noise
(Dickerson et al. 2001) and all fill placement will be entirely within
closed sheet pile cells. Finally, otters are not anticipated to be
physically injured by barge movements or fill placement due to the use
of protected species observers (PSO) and shutdown zones.
We also assumed that up to two sea otters per day (to account for a
potential mother and pup pair) would experience take by Level B
harassment on days when only uplands pile-driving activities are
occurring due to exposure to in-air noise, given that sea otters are
commonly sighted amongst the ARRC docks and close to human activity in
that area (PND 2026). The ARRC estimates there will be 64 days of
uplands pile-driving activities that do not occur on the same day as
in-water pile-driving activities, resulting in up to 128 takes by Level
B harassment due to in-air sound exposure.
Sea Otter Density
We assumed all sea otters exposed to underwater sound levels that
meet the acoustic exposure criteria defined above in Exposure
Thresholds would experience take by Level A harassment or Level B
harassment. We refer to the area in which sound levels meet or exceed
the acoustic exposure criteria defined for either Level A harassment or
Level B harassment as the ensonification area. Spatially explicit
ensonification areas were established around the planned construction
location to estimate the number of sea otters that may be exposed to
these sound levels. We determined the number of otters present in the
ensonification zones using a density of 2.31 sea otters per square
kilometer (km\2\) derived from surveys conducted in Prince William
Sound, Alaska (Weitzman and Esslinger 2015).
Sound Levels for the Specified Activities
The project activities consist of vibratory pile extraction and
pile installation via vibratory pile driving and impact pile driving.
Each method generates a different type of noise. Vibratory pile
extraction and installation produce nonimpulsive or continuous noise,
whereas impact pile installation produces impulsive noise (NMFS 2020).
The level of sound anticipated from each project activity was
established using data from several sources in addition to guidance
from NMFS. We used the empirical data from those proxy projects and
sound levels provided by NMFS with the NMFS Technical Guidance and User
Spreadsheet (NMFS 2018, 2020) to determine the distance at which sound
levels would attenuate to Level A harassment thresholds (table 2
above). To estimate the distance at which sound levels would attenuate
to Level B harassment thresholds, we used the data from the proxy
projects and the sound levels provided by NMFS to determine the
distance at which sound levels would attenuate to 160 dB. We used the
NMFS-recommended transmission loss coefficient of 15 for coastal pile-
driving activities in a practical spreading loss model (NMFS 2020) to
estimate distances at which sounds would attenuate to Level A
harassment and Level B harassment thresholds. The weighting factor
adjustment included in the NMFS user spreadsheet accounts for sounds
experienced in less sensitive portions of an animal's hearing range.
[[Page 75546]]
We used the weighting factor adjustment for otariid pinnipeds as they
are the closest available physiological and anatomical proxy for sea
otters. We acknowledge that NMFS has revised their user spreadsheet to
include thresholds for auditory injury (NMFS 2024). As discussed in
Exposure Thresholds above, we are evaluating the auditory injury
criteria to determine whether they are appropriate for FWS trust
species, and we will continue to use the previous version of the user
spreadsheet (NMFS 2018, 2020) to estimate harassment of sea otters from
in-water noise exposure during our evaluation.
Sound levels for all in-water sources are unweighted and given in
dB re 1 [mu]Pa. For nonimpulsive sound sources, sound levels are shown
in the form of mean maximum root mean square (RMS) SPL. For impulsive
sound sources, sound levels are shown in the forms of peak SPL (peak)
and sound exposure level for a single strike (SELss). Sound levels for
in-water project activities are listed in table 3 below. The estimated
in-air sound level for all uplands pile-driving activities is 103 dB
(90 FR 21754, May 21, 2025).
Table 3--ARRC Seward Alaska Marine Terminal Freight Dock Project Sound Types, Levels, and Timing for In-Water Pile-Driving Activities
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Timing per pile
(nonimpulsive
Pile size and Sound levels (dB sound sources) or
Project component material Activity Type of sound re 1 uPa) Source strikes per pile
(impulsive sound
sources)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Existing dolphin piles.......... 61.0-cm (24-in) Removal-vibratory. Nonimpulsive...... 163 dB RMS........ Illingworth & 90 minutes.
round steel. Rodkin 2012;
Illingworth &
Rodkin 2013;
Miner 2020;
Caltrans 2020.
Temporary template piles........ 61.0-cm (24-in) Installation- Nonimpulsive...... 163 dB RMS........ Illingworth & 60 minutes.
steel pipe. vibratory. Rodkin 2012;
Illingworth &
Rodkin 2013;
Miner 2020;
Caltrans 2020.
Temporary template piles........ 61.0-cm (24-in) Removal-vibratory. Nonimpulsive...... 163 dB RMS........ Illingworth & 60 minutes.
steel pipe. Rodkin 2012;
Illingworth &
Rodkin 2013;
Miner 2020;
Caltrans 2020.
New sheet pile pairs............ Steel sheet pile.. Installation- Nonimpulsive...... 160.7 dB RMS...... PND 2016; Caltrans 30 minutes.
vibratory. 2015.
New anchor piles................ Steel H-piles..... Installation- Nonimpulsive...... 150 dB RMS........ Caltrans 2015; 60 minutes.
vibratory. Caltrans 2020.
New fender piles................ 76.2-cm (30-in) Installation- Nonimpulsive...... 167 dB RMS........ Illingworth & 60 minutes.
round steel. vibratory. Rodkin 2012;
Caltrans 2020.
New dolphin piles............... 76.2-cm (30-in) Installation- Nonimpulsive...... 167 dB RMS........ Illingworth & 60 minutes.
round steel. vibratory. Rodkin 2012;
Caltrans 2020.
New dolphin piles............... 76.2-cm (30-in) Installation- Impulsive......... 190 dB RMS; 177 dB Caltrans 2015..... 1,800 strikes.
round steel. impact. SELss; 210 dB
peak.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ensonification Areas
Distances to where sound levels fall below Level A harassment and
Level B harassment thresholds were calculated for each in-water project
activity to determine the ensonification area for that activity (table
4). The applicant has proposed implementing acoustic shutdown zones
that will encompass the majority of both Level A harassment thresholds
and Level B harassment thresholds (table 4) in order to minimize take
of sea otters. The ARRC would also implement a 10-m (33-ft) physical
interaction shutdown zone, regardless of predicted sound levels, to
minimize the potential for physical impacts to sea otters.
Table 4--ARRC Seward Alaska Marine Terminal Freight Dock Project Distances to Below Level A Harassment and Level
B Harassment Zones and Proposed Acoustic Shutdown Zones for In-Water Pile-Driving Activities
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Distance to Distance to Distance to
Pile size and below Level A below Level B below acoustic
Project component material Activity harassment harassment shutdown zones
threshold (m) threshold (m) (m)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Existing dolphin piles....... 61.0-cm (24-in) Removal- 1.3 15.85 20
round steel. vibratory.
[[Page 75547]]
Temporary template piles..... 61.0-cm (24-in) Installation- 1.3 15.85 20
steel pipe. vibratory.
Temporary template piles..... 61.0-cm (24-in) Removal- 1.3 15.85 20
steel pipe. vibratory.
New sheet pile pairs......... Steel sheet pile Installation- 1.3 11.13 20
vibratory.
New anchor piles............. Steel H-piles... Installation- 0.1 2.15 10
vibratory.
New fender piles............. 76.2-cm (30-in) Installation- 1.8 29.29 30
round steel. vibratory.
New dolphin piles............ 76.2-cm (30-in) Installation- 1.2 29.29 30
round steel. vibratory.
New dolphin piles............ 76.2-cm (30-in) Installation- 36.4 1000 310
round steel. impact.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
We calculated the area ensonified to >232 dB peak SPL or >203 dB
SELCUM re 1[mu]Pa for impulsive underwater sound and >219 dB
SELCUM re 1[mu]Pa for nonimpulsive underwater sound to
determine the area in which sea otters may experience Level A
harassment for each of the ARRC's in-water pile-driving activities. Our
ensonification area calculations showed that the project activity sound
levels would not reach the 232 dB peak SPL threshold for causing
instantaneous PTS in sea otter hearing sensitivity. We multiplied the
ensonification area for Level A harassment by the density of sea otters
for the project location (see Sea Otter Density) and the number of
project activity days to determine the number of Level A harassment
events for each project activity.
To estimate the number of Level B harassment events during the
ARRC's in-water pile-driving activities, we subtracted the area of the
Level A harassment zone from the area ensonified to >160 dB re 1[mu]Pa
to determine the area in which sea otters may experience Level B
harassment for each project activity. Our ensonification area
calculations showed that the project activity sound levels would not
reach the 226 dB peak SPL threshold for causing instantaneous TTS in
sea otter hearing sensitivity outside the 10-m (33-ft) physical
interaction shutdown zone. We multiplied the ensonified area for Level
B harassment outside the ensonified area of Level A harassment by the
density of sea otters for the project location (see Sea Otter Density)
and the number of project activity days to determine the number of
Level B harassment events for each project activity.
To calculate the areas in water that will be ensonified by pile-
driving activities, we used the area of a circle ([pi]r\2\) where the
radius (r) is the distance to below the Level A harassment threshold or
the Level B harassment threshold. The number of Level A harassment and
Level B harassment events estimated during in-water project activities
can be found in tables 5 and 6 below, respectively.
Table 5--ARRC Seward Alaska Marine Terminal Freight Dock Project In-Water Level A Harassment Events Estimated
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Estimated
Estimated sea otters Total
Maximum Sea otter Level A sea otters affected by estimated
Project component Pile size and Activity number of density area affected by Level A Level A
material activity (sea otters/ (km\2\) Level A sound per harassment
days km\2\) sound per day events
day (rounded)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Existing dolphin piles.......... 61.0-cm (24-in) Removal-vibratory.. 4 2.31 0.000 0.000 0 0
round steel.
Temporary template piles........ 61.0-cm (24-in) Installation- 50 0.000 0.000 0 0
steel pipe. vibratory.
Temporary template piles........ 61.0-cm (24-in) Removal-vibratory.. 50 0.000 0.000 0 0
steel pipe.
New sheet pile pairs............ Steel sheet pile... Installation- 75 0.000 0.000 0 0
vibratory.
New anchor piles................ Steel H-piles...... Installation- 15 0.000 0.000 0 0
vibratory.
New fender piles................ 76.2-cm (30-in) Installation- 6 0.000 0.000 0 0
round steel. vibratory.
New dolphin piles............... 76.2-cm (30-in) Installation- 5 0.000 0.000 0 0
round steel. vibratory.
New dolphin piles............... 76.2-cm (30-in) Installation-impact 5 0.004 0.010 \a\ 2 10
round steel.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
\a\ Where the estimated total number of harassment events expected was equal to or greater than 0.001, we rounded to 2 instead to accommodate potential
mother and pup pairs of sea otters for project activities.
[[Page 75548]]
Table 6--ARRC Seward Alaska Marine Terminal Freight Dock Project In-Water Level B Harassment Events Estimated
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Estimated
Level B Estimated sea otters Total
Maximum Sea otter Level B area minus sea otters affected by estimated
Project component Pile size and material Activity number of density area Level A affected by Level B Level B
activity (sea otters/ (km\2\) area Level B sound per harassment
days km\2\) (km\2\) sound per day events
day (rounded)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Existing dolphin piles................... 61.0-cm (24-in) round steel. Removal-vibratory........... 4 2.31 0.001 0.001 0.002 \a\ 2 8
Temporary template piles................. 61.0-cm (24-in) steel pipe.. Installation-vibratory...... 50 0.001 0.001 0.002 \a\ 2 100
Temporary template piles................. 61.0-cm (24-in) steel pipe.. Removal-vibratory........... 50 0.001 0.001 0.002 \a\ 2 100
New sheet pile pairs..................... Steel sheet pile............ Installation-vibratory...... 75 0.000 0.000 0.000 0 0
New anchor piles......................... Steel H-piles............... Installation-vibratory...... 15 0.000 0.000 0.000 0 0
New fender piles......................... 76.2-cm (30-in) round steel. Installation-vibratory...... 6 0.003 0.003 0.006 \a\ 2 12
New dolphin piles........................ 76.2-cm (30-in) round steel. Installation-vibratory...... 5 0.003 0.003 0.006 \a\ 2 10
New dolphin piles........................ 76.2-cm (30-in) round steel. Installation-impact......... 5 3.140 3.136 7.244 8 40
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
\a\ Where the estimated total number of harassment events expected was equal to or greater than 0.001, we rounded to 2 instead to accommodate potential mother and pup pairs of sea otters for
project activities.
Critical Assumptions
We estimate that 398 takes by Level B harassment and 10 takes by
Level A harassment of up to 347 sea otters may occur due to the ARRC's
planned pile driving and marine construction activities. In order to
conduct this analysis and estimate the potential amount of take by
harassment, several critical assumptions were made.
Sound level information from pile-driving activities in a number of
locations was used to generate sound level estimates for the specified
activities (see sources in table 3 above). Environmental conditions in
these locations, including water depth, substrate, and ambient sound
levels may be similar to those in the project location, but are not
identical. Further, ensonification area estimates were based on sound
attenuation models using a practical spreading loss model. These
factors may lead to actual sound values differing slightly from those
estimated here.
We assumed that the different types of pile-driving activities will
occur sequentially and that the total number of activity days will
equal the sum of the number of days required to complete each type of
pile-driving activity. While it is possible that on some days more than
one type of activity will take place, which would reduce the number of
days of exposure, we cannot know this information in advance. As such,
the estimated number of activity days is the maximum possible for the
planned work.
The in-water pile-driving activities described here will also
create in-air noise. Because sea otters spend over half of their day
with their heads above water (Esslinger et al. 2014), they will be
exposed to the in-air noise produced by construction equipment.
However, we have calculated Level A harassment and Level B harassment
with the assumption that a sea otter may be harassed only one time per
24-hour period, and in-water noise levels would be more disturbing and
extend farther than in-air noise from the same activities. Thus, while
sea otters may be disturbed by noise both in-air and in-water, we have
relied on the more conservative in-water estimates for in-water pile-
driving activities.
Level B harassment is equated herein with behavioral responses that
indicate harassment or disturbance. There is likely a portion of
animals that respond in ways that indicate some level of disturbance
but do not experience biologically significant consequences. Our
estimates do not account for variable responses by sea otter age and
sex.
The behavioral response estimates presented here do not account for
the individual movements of animals in response to the specified
activities. Our assessment assumes animals remain stationary (that is,
the density does not change) for a 24-hour period, and animals do not
move out of ensonification areas in response to noise. Not enough
information is available about the movement of sea otters in response
to specific disturbances to refine this assumption. Individual sea
otters could potentially be exposed repeatedly to noise above ambient
sound levels, but we do not anticipate that temporary behavioral
disturbances due to sound exposure would be additive, nor do we
anticipate that multiple exposures to Level B harassment sound levels
would rise to the level of take by Level A harassment.
We used the sea otter density for the Seward area from surveys and
analyses conducted by Weitzman and Esslinger et al. (2015). Methods and
assumptions for these surveys can be found in the original publication.
A limited number of individual sea otters occupy the project
location depending on multiple factors, such as habitat suitability,
prey availability, environmental stressors, predation, subsistence
harvest levels, and human activity (Tinker et al. 2019; Eisaguirre et
al. 2021). Although sea otters are non-migratory, they typically move
amongst focal areas within their home ranges to rest and forage
(Garshelis and Garshelis 1984; Laidre et al. 2009). The project area is
located at the north, and furthest inland, end of Resurrection Bay,
which has a length of just under 30 kilometers (~18.6 miles) and an
area of roughly 150 km\2\ (~58 square miles). The width and length of
Resurrection Bay make it unlikely that there would be 100% daily
turnover of individual animals in the project area. Similarly, if sea
otters from adjacent coastline were to enter Resurrection Bay to seek
calmer waters during rough weather, we would not expect those animals
to travel far enough inshore to reach the areas ensonified by the
ARRC's pile-driving activities. It is possible that, given the large
variability in individual sea otter home range sizes and the potential
for daily movement in and out of foraging or resting areas, different
individual sea
[[Page 75549]]
otters could be found within the ensonification area each day of the
project. Thus, we assumed that the estimated harassment events may
impact different sea otters up to the maximum number of individual sea
otters estimated to be exposed to the ARRC's project activities.
To find the maximum number of individual sea otters that might be
exposed to the ARRC's project activities, we multiplied the area of
Resurrection Bay by the expected density of sea otters. This resulted
in ~347 animals (150 km\2\ * 2.31 sea otters per km\2\ = 346.5). Thus,
the FWS assumes that the 408 estimated harassment events may impact up
to 347 different sea otters.
For our take estimate analysis, we subtracted the Level A
harassment ensonification area from the Level B harassment
ensonification area for each project activity to estimate the total
number of Level B harassment events. This approach avoids
overestimating the number of Level B harassment events. We rounded the
total numbers of Level A harassment and Level B harassment events up to
the nearest whole number considering that harassment events are not
fractional units. Where the estimated total number of harassment events
was between 0.001 and 1, we rounded up to 2 harassment events per day
of activity to account for the potential of mother and pup pairs of sea
otters encountering project activities.
Sum of Harassment From All Sources
The applicant plans to conduct pile driving and marine construction
activities in Seward Alaska for up to a 1-year period. Over the course
of the project, we estimate up to ten instances of take by Level A
harassment of sea otters from the Southcentral Alaska stock due to PTS
associated with cumulative in-water noise exposure during project
activities. Project activity sound levels would not reach the 232 dB
peak SPL threshold for causing instantaneous PTS in sea otter hearing
sensitivity based on our ensonification area calculations. Using soft-
start procedures, zone clearance prior to activity startup, and
shutdown zones is likely to decrease both the number of sea otters
exposed to noise above Level A harassment thresholds and the exposure
time of any sea otters entering the Level A harassment zone. This
reduces the likelihood of hearing sensitivity losses that might impact
the health, reproduction, or survival of affected sea otters. Despite
the implementation of mitigation measures, it is anticipated that some
sea otters may experience Level A harassment via exposure to in-water
noise above threshold criteria during pile-driving activities.
Over the course of the project, we estimate up to 398 instances of
take by Level B harassment of sea otters from the Southcentral Alaska
stock due to behavioral responses associated with noise exposure during
project activities. Although multiple instances of Level B harassment
of individual sea otters are possible, these events are unlikely to
have significant consequences for the health, reproduction, or survival
of affected sea otters, and are not anticipated to aggregate to Level A
harassment. The potential effects of multiple Level B harassment noise
exposures may include short-term behavioral reactions, displacement of
sea otters near active operations, and, in rare cases, potential
temporary shifts in hearing thresholds. We anticipate that the
likelihood of sea otters experiencing a TTS is low during the project.
Project activity sound levels would not reach the peak SPL threshold
for causing instantaneous TTS in sea otter hearing sensitivity outside
of the 10-m (33-ft) physical interaction shutdown zone based on our
ensonification area calculations. Therefore, sea otters would
experience TTS as a result of cumulative noise exposure, which is
unlikely due to sea otter behavioral patterns. Considering the sound
levels of the specified activities, the limited amount of time over
non-consecutive days in which the specified activities will occur, and
the localized area to be impacted by the specified activities, we do
not anticipate that the effects of multiple Level B harassment noise
exposures would rise to the level of TTS, an injury, or Level A
harassment.
Determinations and Findings
Sea otters exposed to noise from the specified activities are
likely to respond with temporary behavioral modification or
displacement. The specified activities could temporarily interrupt the
feeding, resting, and movement of sea otters. The activities will occur
during a limited amount of time and in a localized area, and the
impacts associated with the project are likewise temporary and
localized. The anticipated effects are short-term behavioral reactions,
displacement of sea otters near active operations, and potential shifts
in hearing thresholds.
Sea otters that encounter the specified activities may exert more
energy than they would otherwise due to temporary cessation of feeding,
increased vigilance (for example, repeatedly spyhopping), increased
foraging to compensate for disturbance, and retreating from the project
location. We expect that affected sea otters would tolerate this
exertion without measurable effects on health or reproduction. Most of
the anticipated takes would be due to short-term Level B harassment in
the form of startling reactions, interruption of feeding, resting, and
movement, or temporary displacement. We anticipate that the likelihood
of sea otters experiencing a TTS due to noise exposure is low during
the project based on the project activity sound levels and sea otter
behavioral patterns. While mitigation measures incorporated into the
ARRC's request would reduce occurrences of Level A harassment to the
extent practicable, a small number of takes by Level A harassment would
be authorized for the specified activities, which have Level A
harassment zone radii ranging up to 36.4 m (119.4 ft).
Small Numbers
For our small numbers determination, we consider whether the
estimated number of sea otters to be subjected to incidental take is
small relative to the population size of the species or stock. More
specifically, the FWS compares the number of sea otters anticipated to
be taken in the year contemplated by the proposed IHA with the
population estimate applicable for the year. Here, predicted numbers of
sea otters to be taken were determined based on the estimated density
of sea otters in the project location and ensonification areas
developed using empirical evidence from similar geographic areas. We
estimate that the ARRC's specified activities in the specified
geographic region would take no more than 347 Southcentral Alaska stock
sea otters by Level A harassment and Level B harassment during the 1-
year period of this proposed IHA (see Sum of Harassment from All
Sources). Take of 347 animals is 1.61 percent of the best available
estimate of the current Southcentral Alaska stock size of 21,617
animals (Esslinger et al. 2021) ((347 / 21,617) x 100 [ap] 1.61), and
represents a ``small number'' of sea otters of that stock.
Further, the specified activity area is small relative to the range
of the Southcentral Alaska stock of sea otters. The Southcentral Alaska
stock of sea otters ranges well beyond the nearshore waters surrounding
the existing Seward Alaska Marine Terminal Freight Dock at the head of
Resurrection Bay in Seward, meaning this specified geographic region
represents only a small subset of the potential area in which this
population may occur.
Therefore, we propose a finding that the ARRC's specified
activities would take only small numbers of sea otters
[[Page 75550]]
because: (1) Only a small proportion of sea otters would overlap with
the areas where the specified activities will occur; and (2) the
estimated number of Southcentral Alaska stock sea otters to be taken
would be limited to a total of 347 sea otters over the duration of the
proposed IHA, which represents a small proportion (1.61 percent) of the
stock of sea otters.
Negligible Impact
We propose a finding that any incidental take by harassment
resulting from the specified activities cannot be reasonably expected
to, and is not reasonably likely to, adversely affect sea otters
through effects on annual rates of recruitment or survival and would,
therefore, have no more than a negligible impact on the Southcentral
Alaska stock of sea otters. In making this finding, we considered the
best available scientific evidence including the biological and
behavioral characteristics of the species, the most recent information
on species distribution and abundance within the specified geographic
region, the current and expected future status of the stock (including
existing and foreseeable human and natural stressors), the potential
disturbance sources caused by the specified activities, and the
potential sea otter responses to this disturbance. In addition, we
reviewed applicant-provided materials, our own files and datasets,
published reference materials, and input from species experts. We
propose this finding based on the following: (1) we anticipate that the
impacts on sea otters potentially resulting from the specified
activities are limited to short-term behavioral reactions, displacement
near active operations and, in rare cases, hearing threshold shifts;
(2) the potential impacts from the specified activities would not have
long-term consequences to a sea otter's survival and reproduction; (3)
the total number of sea otters affected and the impact severity are not
expected to affect annual rates of recruitment or survival or result in
adverse effects on the stock; and (4) we propose mitigation measures
that are designed to minimize interactions with and impacts to sea
otters.
We anticipate that the impacts on sea otters potentially resulting
from the specified activities are limited to short-term behavioral
reactions, displacement near active operations, and, in rare cases,
hearing threshold shifts. Most sea otters would respond to disturbance
by moving away from the source, which may cause temporary interruption
of foraging, resting, or other natural behaviors. Affected sea otters
are expected to resume normal behaviors soon after exposure with no
lasting consequences to their survival or reproduction. Level A
harassment from cumulative in-water noise exposure has the potential to
result in the injury (hearing threshold shift) of up to ten sea otters
during the IHA period. We anticipate a low likelihood of sea otters
experiencing hearing threshold shifts due to cumulative in-water noise
exposure, however, based on the project activity sound levels and sea
otter behavioral patterns. Sea otters spend over half of their time
above the surface during the summer months (Esslinger et al. 2014), and
likely no more than 70 percent of their time foraging during winter
months (Gelatt et al. 2002); thus, their ears would not be exposed to
underwater noise for a prolonged time period, thereby reducing their
likelihood of experiencing hearing threshold shifts. Based on this
information, we anticipate that the vast majority of harassment events
will be limited to short-term behavioral reactions and displacement
near active operations. These behavioral responses could have temporary
biological impacts for affected sea otters but are not anticipated to
result in measurable changes in survival or reproduction. Should
individual sea otters remain in the immediate project location and be
repeatedly harassed, the most biologically consequential repeated
behavioral responses would be cessation of nursing or changes to
foraging, grooming, or resting. However, the project location is
surrounded by suitable sea otter habitat, providing ample opportunity
for undisturbed nursing, foraging, grooming, or resting in nearby
coves. While individual sea otters could potentially be exposed
repeatedly to noise above ambient sound levels, the FWS does not
anticipate that multiple exposures to Level B harassment sound levels
would rise to the level of take by Level A harassment.
We anticipate that the potential impacts from the specified
activities would not have long-term consequences to a sea otter's
survival and reproduction. The most severe impact on sea otters
potentially resulting from the specified activities is multiple Level A
harassment noise exposures. The potential effects of multiple Level A
harassment noise exposures may include a greater reduction in a sea
otter's hearing sensitivity, but this reduction in hearing sensitivity
does not equate to total hearing loss. The reduction in sea otter
hearing sensitivity caused by PTS would align with the energy produced
by pile-driving activities (for example, low-frequency less than 2
kHz), which would not impair the majority of a sea otter's hearing
range. Sea otters do not rely on sound to orient themselves, locate
prey, or communicate underwater. Therefore, we do not anticipate PTS
from multiple Level A harassment noise exposures would impact sea
otters' ability to move, forage, or communicate. Sea otters, especially
mothers and pups, do use sound for communication in air (McShane et al.
1995), and sea otters may monitor underwater sound to avoid predators
(Davis et al. 1987). However, we anticipate that a sea otter would
retain the majority of its hearing range if it experiences PTS from
multiple Level A harassment noise exposures and that impacts from PTS
would not have long-term consequences to a sea otter's survival and
reproduction.
The total number of sea otters affected and the impact severity are
not sufficient to change the current population dynamics at the stock
scale. Although the specified activities may result in a maximum of 408
incidental takes of up to 347 sea otters from the Southcentral Alaska
stock, we do not expect this level of harassment to affect annual rates
of recruitment or survival or result in adverse effects on the stock.
Our proposed finding of negligible impact applies to incidental
take associated with the specified activities as mitigated by the
avoidance and minimization measures identified in the ARRC's mitigation
and monitoring plan. These mitigation measures are designed to minimize
interactions with and impacts on sea otters. These mitigation measures
and the monitoring and reporting procedures are required for the
validity of our finding and are a necessary component of the proposed
IHA. For these reasons, we propose a finding that the specified project
would have a negligible impact on the Southcentral Alaska stock of sea
otters.
Least Practicable Adverse Impact
We propose a finding that the mitigation measures required by this
proposed IHA would effect the least practicable adverse impact on the
Southcentral Alaska stock of sea otters from any incidental take likely
to occur in association with the specified activities. In making this
finding, we considered the biological characteristics of sea otters,
the nature of the specified activities, the potential effects of the
activities on sea otters, the documented impacts of similar activities
on sea otters, and alternative mitigation measures.
[[Page 75551]]
In evaluating what mitigation measures are appropriate to ensure
the least practicable adverse impact on species or stocks and their
habitat, as well as subsistence uses, we considered the manner and
degree to which the successful implementation of the measures is
expected to achieve this goal. We considered the nature of the
potential adverse impact being mitigated (likelihood, scope, range),
the likelihood that the measures would be effective if implemented, and
the likelihood of effective implementation. We also considered the
practicability of the measures for applicant implementation (for
example, the cost and impact on operations).
To reduce the potential for disturbance associated with the
activities, the ARRC would implement mitigation measures, including the
following:
Using the smallest diameter piles practicable while
minimizing the overall number of piles;
Using a project design that does not include dredging or
blasting;
Minimizing the use of the impact hammer to the extent
possible by using a vibratory hammer to advance piles as deeply as
possible;
Development of a marine mammal monitoring and mitigation
plan;
Visual mitigation monitoring by designated PSOs;
Halting or delaying activity during environmental
conditions that may hinder sea otter detection, such as darkness,
adverse weather conditions, high sea states, and other times of limited
visibility;
Maintaining the maximum distance practicable between a
vessel and raft of sea otters;
Operating vessels in such a way as to avoid approaching
sea otters or impeding sea otter movements when traveling near the
shoreline in shallow water ( Establishment of shutdown and monitoring zones;
Site clearance before activity startup;
Soft-start procedures; and
Shutdown procedures.
Several additional potential mitigation measures were considered
but determined to be not practicable and/or not effective. These
measures are listed below:
Require use of bubble curtains and other noise-dampening
methods--The applicant indicated that implementation of bubble curtains
and other noise-dampening methods such as cofferdams, pile-surrounding
casings, sound mitigation screens, and nets around piles would not be
effective to reduce sound around filled sheet-pile docks that cannot be
enclosed like a standalone pile.
Require use of alternate detection methods--The FWS
determined that the required use of alternate detection methods such as
infrared sensors; thermal imaging; or surveys conducted by aircraft,
unmanned aircraft system, or vessel was not practicable considering
that these alternate detection methods would be less effective than
PSOs in reducing impacts on sea otters due to the limited number of
project activities and small spatial extent of ensonification areas.
The applicant would employ PSOs to monitor the project location for sea
otters to reduce impacts on sea otters.
Impact on Subsistence Use
The anticipated harassment will not preclude access to harvest
areas or interfere with the availability of sea otters for harvest by
Alaska Native Peoples. Additionally, the existing ARRC Seward Alaska
Marine Terminal Freight Dock is located within the City of Seward,
Alaska, where firearm use is prohibited. We therefore propose a finding
that the ARRC's anticipated harassment would not have an unmitigable
adverse impact on the availability of any stock of sea otters for
taking for subsistence uses by Alaska Native Peoples during the
specified timeframe. In making this proposed finding, we considered the
timing and location of the planned activities and the timing and
location of subsistence harvest activities in the project location.
The planned specified activities will occur in areas rarely used
for subsistence harvesting activity. Despite no conflict with
subsistence use being anticipated, the FWS will conduct outreach with
potentially affected communities to see whether there are any
questions, concerns, or potential conflicts regarding subsistence use
in those areas. If any conflicts are identified in the future, the ARRC
will develop a POC specifying the steps necessary to minimize any
effects the project may have on subsistence harvest. The POC would
ensure that the ARRC would not have an unmitigable adverse impact on
the availability of the species or stock for subsistence uses. This POC
would provide the procedures addressing how the ARRC would work with
the affected Alaska Native communities and what actions would be taken
to avoid interference with subsistence hunting of sea otters, as
warranted.
The FWS has not received any reports and is not aware of
information that indicates that sea otters are being or would be
deterred from hunting areas or impacted in any way that diminishes
their availability for subsistence use by the expected level of pile
driving and marine construction activity. If there is evidence that
these pile driving and marine construction activities are affecting the
availability of sea otters for subsistence uses, we would reevaluate
our findings regarding permissible limits of take and the measures
required to ensure continued subsistence hunting opportunities.
Monitoring and Reporting
The purpose of monitoring requirements is to assess the effects of
specified activities on sea otters; to ensure that take is consistent
with that anticipated in the small numbers, negligible impact, and
subsistence use analyses; and to detect any unanticipated effects on
the species or stock. Monitoring plans document when and how sea otters
are observed, the number of sea otters, and their behaviors during the
observation. This information allows the FWS to measure encounter
rates, examine trends in sea otter activity and distribution in the
project location, and estimate the number of sea otters potentially
affected by the specified activities. The ARRC is required to report
all observations of sea otters. To the extent possible, PSOs would
record group size, age, sex, behavior, duration of observation, and
closest approach to the project activity.
As proposed, monitoring activities would be summarized and reported
in formal reports. The ARRC must submit monthly reports for all months
during which noise-generating work takes place as well as a final
monitoring report that must be submitted no later than 90 days after
the expiration of the IHA. We would require approval of the monitoring
results for continued operation under the IHA.
We propose a finding that these monitoring and reporting
requirements to evaluate the potential impacts of planned activities
would ensure that the effects of the activities remain consistent with
the rest of the findings.
References Cited
A list of the references cited in this notice may be found at
https://www.regulations.gov under Docket No. FWS-R7-ES-2026-3037.
Required Determinations
National Environmental Policy Act
We have prepared a draft environmental assessment in accordance
with the National
[[Page 75552]]
Environmental Policy Act (NEPA; 42 U.S.C. 4321 et seq.). We have
preliminarily concluded that the proposed action of issuing a final IHA
would not significantly affect the quality of the human environment
and, thus, preparation of an environmental impact statement for this
IHA, if finalized, is not required by section 102(2) of NEPA. We are
accepting comments on the draft environmental assessment as specified
above in DATES and ADDRESSES.
Endangered Species Act
Under the Endangered Species Act (ESA; 16 U.S.C. 1536(a)(2)), all
Federal agencies are required to ensure the actions they authorize are
not likely to jeopardize the continued existence of any threatened or
endangered species or result in destruction or adverse modification of
critical habitat. The specified activities would occur entirely within
the range of the Southcentral Alaska stock of northern sea otters,
which is not listed as threatened or endangered under the ESA. The
authorization of incidental take of northern sea otters and the
measures included in the proposed IHA would have no effect on other
listed species or their designated critical habitat. Consultation under
the ESA is not required because the proposed action would have no
effect on listed species.
Government-to-Government Consultation
It is our responsibility to communicate and work directly on a
Government-to-Government basis with federally recognized Alaska Native
Tribes and organizations in developing programs for healthy ecosystems.
We seek their full and meaningful participation in evaluating and
addressing conservation concerns for protected species. It is our goal
to remain sensitive to Alaska Native culture, and to make information
available to Alaska Natives. Our efforts are guided by Executive Order
13175--Consultation and Coordination With Indian Tribal Governments,
512 DM 5--Procedures for Consultation with Indian Tribes, 512 DM 6--
Department of the Interior Policy on Consultation with Alaska Native
Claims Settlement Act Corporations, 510 FW 1, The Service's Native
American Policy, and 510 FW 2, The Service's Alaska Native Relations
Policy.
The FWS has evaluated possible effects of the specified activities
on federally recognized Alaska Native Tribes and Alaska Native Claims
Settlement Act Corporations. We have evaluated the potential effects of
the proposed action and determined that it would not have substantial
direct effects on any federally-recognized Tribes or Alaska Native
Claims Settlement Corporations. However, we invite continued
discussion, either about the project and its impacts or about our
coordination and information exchange, throughout the IHA/POC process.
Paperwork Reduction Act
This authorization does not contain any new collection of
information that requires approval by the Office of Management and
Budget (OMB) under the Paperwork Reduction Act of 1995 (44 U.S.C. 3501
et seq.). The OMB has previously approved the information collection
requirements associated with IHAs and assigned OMB Control Number 1018-
0194 (expired 08/31/2026, and in accordance with 5 CFR 1320.10, an
agency may continue to conduct or sponsor this collection of
information while the submission is pending at OMB).
Proposed Authorization
We propose to authorize the incidental take by Level A harassment
and Level B harassment of sea otters from the Southcentral Alaska
stock. Authorized take would be limited to disruption of behavioral
patterns, displacement of sea otters near active operations, or hearing
threshold shifts that may be caused by pile driving and marine
construction activities conducted by the ARRC in Seward, Alaska, for a
period of up to 1 year.
A. General Conditions for This IHA
(1) Activities must be conducted in the manner described in the
revised request dated June 15, 2026, from the ARRC for an IHA and in
accordance with all applicable conditions and mitigation measures. The
taking of sea otters whenever the required conditions, mitigation,
monitoring, and reporting measures are not fully implemented as
required by the IHA is prohibited. Failure to follow the measures
specified both in the revised request and within this proposed
authorization may result in the modification, suspension, or revocation
of the IHA.
(2) If project activities cause a form of take other than Level A
harassment or Level B harassment, or take of one or more sea otters
through methods not described in the IHA, the ARRC must take the
following actions:
(i) Cease its activities immediately (or reduce activities to the
minimum level necessary to maintain safety);
(ii) Report the details of the incident to the FWS within 24 hours;
and
(iii) Suspend further activities until the FWS has reviewed the
circumstances and determined whether additional mitigation measures are
necessary to avoid further unauthorized taking.
(3) All operation managers, vehicle operators, and machine
operators must receive a copy of this IHA and maintain access to it for
reference at all times during project work. These personnel must
understand, be fully aware of, and be capable of implementing the
conditions of the IHA at all times during project work.
(4) This IHA will apply to activities associated with the specified
project as described in this document and in the ARRC's revised
request. Changes to the specified project without prior authorization
may invalidate the IHA.
(5) The ARRC's revised request is approved and fully incorporated
into this IHA unless exceptions are specifically noted herein. The
request includes:
(i) The ARRC's revised request for an IHA, dated June 15, 2026; and
(ii) The ARRC's revised Protected Species Monitoring and Mitigation
Plan, dated May 14, 2026.
(6) Operators will allow FWS personnel or the FWS's designated
representative to visit project worksites to monitor for impacts on sea
otters and subsistence uses of sea otters at any time throughout
project activities so long as it is safe to do so. ``Operators'' are
all personnel operating under the ARRC's authority, including all
contractors and subcontractors.
B. Avoidance and Minimization
(7) Construction activities must be conducted using equipment that
generates the lowest practicable levels of in-water noise within the
range of frequencies audible to sea otters.
(8) During all pile-driving activities, regardless of predicted
sound levels, a physical interaction shutdown zone of at least 10 m (33
ft) must be enforced. If a sea otter enters or appears likely to enter
the shutdown zone, pile-driving activities must be shut down until
either the sea otter has been visually observed outside the shutdown
zone or at least 15 minutes have elapsed since the last observation
time without redetection of the sea otter.
(9) For impact pile-driving activities, a soft-start procedure must
be implemented at the start of each day's impact pile-driving
activities and at any time following cessation of impact pile driving
for more than 30 minutes without monitoring by PSOs. The soft-start
procedure requires an initial set of three strikes from the impact
driver at
[[Page 75553]]
reduced energy if possible, followed by a 30-second waiting period.
This procedure must be conducted a total of three times before full-
powered strikes if practicable.
(10) Pile-driving activities must be conducted in daylight. If
environmental conditions prevent visual detection of sea otters
approaching the shutdown zone, pile-driving activities must be stopped
until visibility is regained.
C. Mitigation Measures for Vessel Operations
Vessel operators must take every precaution to avoid harassment of
sea otters during vessel operations. The applicant must carry out the
following measures:
(12) Vessels must maintain a minimum distance of 500 m (0.3 mi)
from rafts of 10 or more sea otters unless otherwise needed for safety.
If a vessel must transit within 500 m (0.3 mi) from rafts of sea
otters, the vessel must travel at a reduced speed and maintain the
maximum distance practicable between the vessel and raft of sea otters.
Vessels must reduce speed and maintain a minimum distance of 100 m (328
ft) from all sea otters unless otherwise needed for safety.
(13) Vessels must not be operated in such a way as to separate
members of a group of sea otters (two or more sea otters) from other
members of the group, encircle sea otters, or impede movement of sea
otters. Vessels must use established navigation channels or commonly
recognized vessel traffic corridors and avoid approaching sea otters or
impeding sea otter movements when traveling near the shoreline in
shallow water ([email protected].
(30) The ARRC must notify the FWS upon project completion or end of
the work season.
Request for Public Comments
If you wish to comment on this proposed authorization, the
associated draft environmental assessment, or related documents, you
may submit your comments by either of the methods described above in
ADDRESSES. Please identify the document(s) to which your comments
pertain, make your comments as specific as possible, confine them to
issues pertinent to the proposed authorization, and explain the reason
for any changes you recommend. Where possible, your comments should
reference the specific section or paragraph that you are addressing.
The FWS will consider all comments that are received before the close
of the comment period (see DATES above). The FWS does not anticipate
extending the public comment period beyond the 30 days required under
section 101(a)(5)(D)(iii) of the MMPA.
Comments, including names and street addresses of respondents, will
become part of the administrative record for this proposal. Before
including your address, telephone number, email address, or other
personal identifying information in your comment, be advised that your
entire comment, including your personal identifying information, may be
made publicly available at any time. While you can ask us in your
comments to withhold from public review your personal identifying
information, we cannot guarantee that we will be able to do so.
Peter Fasbender,
Assistant Regional Director for Fisheries and Ecological Services,
Alaska Region, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service.
[FR Doc. 2026-23734 Filed 11-20-26; 8:45 am]
BILLING CODE 4333-15-P
공식 발표 ↔ 매체 보도
보도 없음
보도 없음
보도 없음