Iran deal is 'a major setback for the United States', ex-adviser to State Department says
AI Summary
President Trump unveiled a preliminary accord with Iran aimed at ending the Middle Eastern conflict, framed as preventing Iranian nuclear weapons development and averting economic collapse from prolonged warfare. The agreement operates as a foundational framework with several nuclear-related issues left for future negotiation, distinguishing it from the more technically detailed accord negotiated under the Obama administration. International response at the G7 summit included backing from allied nations, while domestic critics questioned whether the arrangement provides sufficient safeguards against Iranian military expansion or represents an imbalanced exchange of commitments.
Progressive: Progressive-leaning outlets stress inadequate nuclear safeguards and argue the deal strengthens Iran by providing military resources while failing to match the technical depth of the prior administration's agreement.
Moderate: Centrist outlets emphasize the preliminary nature of the framework, note remaining open questions on nuclear matters, and present both G7 support and polling evidence of public skepticism about Iran's compliance.
Conservative: Conservative-leaning outlets diverge: some characterize it as diplomatically weak with excessive American concessions, while others defend it as a practical alternative to prolonged conflict and economic hardship.
In an interview with FRANCE 24, Vali Nasr, professor of Middle East studies at Johns Hopkins University and former adviser to the State Department, explained that "the war is ending in Iran's favour" and that "the outcome is definitely not favourable to Israel".
"It's very difficult not to see this as a major setback for the United States and a major gain for Iran", he said, adding that "the Islamic Republic, domestically and regionally, is coming out of this war more confident, more self-assured and stronger" than before. ...
이 뉴스, 독자들은 어떻게 느꼈나요?
첫 반응을 남겨보세요로그인하면 감정 반응에 참여할 수 있어요.
공식 발표 ↔ 진영별 보도
Netanyahu says Israel must protect relationship with US
FOR THE RECORDS: US-Iran deal (FULL TEXT)
What the US-Iran deal means for West Asian security and Pakistan
US-Iran Peace Deal: M-East stability crucial to global economy — Olawepo-Hashim
Accord entre l'Iran et les États-Unis : le silence de Benyamin Nétanyahou, qui tente de sauver les acquis d'Israël
Israël "parie sur un échec de l'accord" : à Tel-Aviv, les négociations entre Washington et Téhéran sont vécues comme un désaveu
Gbenga Hashim welcomes US-Iran peace agreement
Netanyahu under pressure in Israel after US-Iran agreement
Iran deal is 'a major setback for the United States', ex-adviser to State Department says
Trump: I'll likely support Netanyahu in next election, but I need to see who is running
To prevail in the Middle East, Netanyahu must go
Israel desafia acordo de paz entre Irã e EUA e publica mapa mostrando território ocupado no Líbano
For Israel, US-Iran deal a 'disaster' incompatible with its security interests
US-Iran agreement leaves Israelis 'in profound state of shock'
How do Iranians and Israelis view the US-Iran deal?
Após acordo, Israel volta a atacar sul do Líbano, diz imprensa local
Can the US-Iran deal survive a defiant Israel and Hormuz uncertainties?
'Catastrophic capitulation': Why US and Israel are the biggest losers in Iran deal
Acordo EUA e Irã: o que pode dar errado e as perguntas ainda em aberto, segundo especialistas
Netanyahu, Israel’s arch-survivor, set to face voter fury over Iran deal
Israel seizes property tied to Gaza drone smuggling in first-of-its-kind enforcement action
Netanyahu set to face voter fury over Iran deal
Israel after Oct. 7: a strategic assessment nearly three years on - analysis
Leia a íntegra do acordo entre EUA e Irã
After Iran deal, Israel's Netanyahu calls for preserving 'vital relationship' with US
Israel, stunned by Trump’s Iran deal, sees it as a ‘catastrophic capitulation’
Trump privately frets Bibi Netanyahu's zeal to 'bomb everyone' could turn him into another disgraced president
Timeline: How US-Israel war on Iran unfolded
How Israel seized 1,000 sq km in two years, its biggest territorial expansion in decades
'Won't be nuked, think of it, Bibi': Trump reveals how he convinced Netanyahu for Iran deal