학술

Visuo-spatial perception deficit in ophthalmological disorders: Visual field extent matters

PLOS ONE
CC BY
이 매체는 공공·자유 라이선스로 본문을 직접 표시합니다.

Figures
Abstract
Objectives
Persons with Visual Impairment (VI) are more at risk to be without academic qualification. This is classically attributed to limited access to visual information, considered difficult due to reduced visual acuity. However, in some cases, visual acuity is preserved but visual field is reduced. Given the importance of visuo-spatial skills in learning, we assessed the accuracy of perceptual visuo-spatial judgements relative to visual field extent and visual acuity to question their respective contribution to the functional repercussions in VI.
Methods
97 patients were administered the elementary visuo-spatial perception (EVSP) test during their clinical assessment. We put a focus on two diseases of our sample: Retinitis Pigmentosa (N = 19) and Albinism (N = 18), with mainly restriction of visual field extent in the former, and visual acuity loss in the latter. In addition, we investigated the correlation between the visuo-spatial performance and these two distinctive factors of VI in the whole sample.
Results
The results indicated higher prevalence of visuo-spatial perception deficit in the whole sample of VI compared to typically developing individuals. Even if most pathologies affect both peripheral and central vision, which makes it complicated to fully disentangle between these two factors, the focus on the Retinitis Pigmentosa and the Albinism groups suggested that visuo-spatial perception is less impacted by a low visual acuity than by peripheral visual field restriction. Additionally, we found that visuospatial perception performance was significantly correlated with visual field extent and not with visual acuity in the whole sample.
Citation: Drissi H, Jauze M, Perrier E, Takani K, Blanc AC, Laurens A, et al. (2026) Visuo-spatial perception deficit in ophthalmological disorders: Visual field extent matters. PLoS One 21(11): e0363153. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0363153
Editor: Yalong Dang, Sanmenxia Central Hospital, Henan University of Science and Technilogy, CHINA
Received: January 5, 2026; Accepted: November 4, 2026; Published: November 20, 2026
Copyright: © 2026 Drissi et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Data Availability: All relevant data are within the manuscript and its Supporting information files.
Funding: The author(s) received no specific funding for this work.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Introduction
In 2010, the World Health Organization (WHO) estimated that close to 285 million people had a visual impairment (VI) and 19 million of them were children younger than 15 years old [1]. Children’s VI is a major public health issue because there are life-long medical, economic and social impacts for the patients and their families [2]. These children need the assistance of different organizations like the Support Service for the Acquisition of Autonomy and School Integration (SSAASI) to assure an adaptation of their studies [3,4]. A study [5–7] carried out in France reported that the lack of qualifications in 25–64 years old people is more frequent in cases of VI compared to typical population without VI, and 59% of them stated that they gave up their studies due to their VI. The academic choices in VI, e.g., often avoiding scientific sections or other challenging orientations, are commonly attributed to limited access to visual information, considered difficult due to their reduced visual acuity. However, in the most frequent causes of VI where visual acuity is quite preserved, children still present lower academic achievement, which suggests that visual field extent also matters. Indeed, the WHO defines severity levels of VI based on two sensory criteria: visual acuity and visual field extent [8]. The low visual acuity can be explained by ophthalmological pathologies that affect either the central retina inducing macular scotoma and preserving peripheral vision, e.g., Stargardt disease and Best syndrome, or diffusely the entire visual field, e.g., cataract, Achromatopsia and ocular Albinism (Alb). Peripheral visual field loss (tubular vision) can be caused by retinal disorders, e.g., Retinitis Pigmentosa (RP) or optical nerve pathology, e.g., Glaucoma. Most pathologies affect both visual field extent and visual acuity, which makes it complicated to disentangle these two factors and understand their respective contribution to the functional repercussions [9–12].
Knowing the importance of visuo-spatial skills in acquisition of reading and spelling and in mathematical performance, often associated with academic delay [13–16], it seems legitimate to question the prevalence of perceptual visuo-spatial impairment in VI. For instance, the performance at the Elementary Visuo-Spatial Perception (EVSP) screening test, which evaluate the ability to discriminate fine differences in length, size, relative orientations and positions (illustration of items on Fig 1), is correlated with several sub-tests of the Wechsler scale like Coding, Symbol, Block Design and Matrix reasoning [17], and is lower in children with learning disorders [18] suggesting that visuo-spatial perception is linked to cognitive development and learning.
A recent study [19] evaluated the effect of artificial gaze-contingent visual masking on the performance of healthy participants at the EVSP screening test, simulating the potential effects of ophthalmological diseases impacting central versus peripheral vision. The accuracy of the visuo-spatial judgments was impaired by macular masking, but not by peripheral retinal masking. As shown previously by Fortenbaugh et al [20], shrinking the field-of-view of healthy participants produces overall more placement errors, angular offsets and mis-estimated distances. The slight disturbance of the oculomotor sampling with peripheral masking slowed the responses to the EVSP screening test but did not impact their accuracy [19]. However, gaze-contingent masking simulates the clinical conditions only in terms of how retinal loss affects the sampling of visual information, but not in terms of how its chronicity can induce neural plasticity over time. Even if the visual cortex is not directly concerned by the ophthalmological diseases causing children’s VI, its functional organization is impacted. Reorganization of primary visual cortex was observed in a study using fMRI with tubular vision affecting its functional connectivity [21] and inducing further plastic changes in the ventral and dorsal cortical visual pathways [22].
This gaze-contingent visual masking study [19] thus allowed us to establish that peripheral vision sparing, unlike central vision sparing, is not necessary to sample the visual information of the EVSP screening test. Low scores observed in clinical condition of visual field reduction (e.g., RP) would therefore be solely attributed to impaired cortical visuo-spatial processing of central vision information. Similarly, reduction of visual acuity (e.g., Alb) may impair cortical visuo-spatial processing without precluding the sampling of visual information as much as in macular scotoma. In order to study the effects of VI on cortical visuo-spatial processing, we analyzed the visuo-spatial perception performance at the EVSP screening test in a population of 97 patients (after exclusion of 8 patients with macular scotoma for which impaired performance at the EVSP screening test could be attributed to inability to sample visual information [19] rather than cortical dysfunction). To distinguish between spatial visual field restriction and visual acuity effects on cortical visuo-spatial processing, we first conducted correlations between these factors and the EVSP scores. Then we specifically focused on two equivalent sub-samples with genetic retinal pathologies mainly affecting visual field extent in the former, versus visual acuity loss in the latter: 19 individuals with Retinitis Pigmentosa (RP) and 18 with Albinism (Alb). RP is an inherited retinal dystrophy induced by the loss of photoreceptors. It is characterized by night blindness preceding a progressive restriction of the peripheral visual field [9]. Alb is an inherited disorder of melanin biosynthesis inducing a reduction in pigmentation of eyes (that can be associated with cutaneous albinism or not). In all types of Alb, reduced pigmentation of the retina is found and foveal hypoplasia inducing reduction of visual acuity from 0.5 to 1.30 logMAR [10]. We thought that the similarities in the aetiology of these conditions when considered alongside the differences in visual symptoms makes the comparison relevant to this study, in addition to the correlation analyses.
Materials and methods
Ethics statement
Population
A total of 105 patients were recruited through the shared database of the care and support for the visually impaired children in the French Rhône-Alpes region (SARADV) which involved orthoptists from eight SSAASI (one for each department) and from the Regional Technical Center for Visual Deficiency (CTRDV). Cerebral lesion was an exclusion criterium. All participants were administered the EVSP screening test [23] during a clinical visit or during a visit in the research laboratory for participation to the present investigation between 2022 and 2024 when they were aged from 5 to 39 (mean age 12.78 years, SD = 7.014, 42% females and 58% males). All presented VI from childhood with various time of appearance of the first symptoms (Data Set available on-line). Table 1 reports the distribution of our population of 105 children classified by VI causes. Patients with macular scotoma (n = 8) were not included in the analyses of the performance at the EVSP screening test since impairment in this clinical condition can be attributed to inability to sample visual information rather than impaired visuo-spatial processing (given that healthy participants with artificial gaze-contingent macular masking also demonstrate impaired accuracy [19]). Moreover, their VI did correspond neither to the criteria of a reduction of visual acuity, nor to the criteria of a peripheral reduction of the visual field extent, but rather to loss of central vision hindering their inability to fixate objects. They therefore do not fit the VI criteria explored in the present study.
VI criteria
All the participants were diagnosed with VI by the clinicians of the network based on deficient visual acuity and/or visual field restriction according to the WHO classification [8] (Table 2).
The Best Corrected Visual Acuity (BCVA) was measured by clinicians with different scales depending on the age of patients and on the equipment available in the various clinical institutions. The near BCVA is clinically established at a comfortable reading distance that better matches the distance at which the EVSP test was performed. However, it was missing for 26 patients (7 Optic Nerve disorder, 6 Albinism, 5 RP, 4 Ocular Globe damage, 2 ametropia, 1 retinal disorder and 1 cataract. In the remaining 71 patients, the near BCVA varied between 1.00 and 0.10 logMAR) thus caution should be shown when interpreting the near BCVA results due to the loss of power due to the missing data. Instead, the far BCVA, established at a standardized distance of 5m, is more systematically measured in clinics. It was available for 92 participants (missing data only for 2 patients with Ocular Globe damage, 2 with Optical Nerve disorder and 1 with Ametropia) ranging from 2.00 to 0.00 logMAR.
Almost all patients (n = 92, missing data for the patients also missing their visual acuity measures: 2 patients with Ocular Globe damage, 3 with Optical Nerve disorder) also received a binocular and/or monocular visual field perimetry (with various equipment, Goldmann perimeter the most frequently) as part of their medical assessment when they were admitted in the clinical institution. We categorized the visual field extent of our population into 5 classes: normal visual field (coded 5), reduced but ≥20°, between 15 and 19°, between 10 and 14°, < 10° (coded 1).
The EVSP screening test
As described below in detail for each of its sub-test and illustrated on Fig 1, the EVSP screening test [23] evaluates visuo-spatial perceptual judgement ability without requiring complex language, manual dexterity or visual object knowledge. It counts 6 subtests (T1, T2, T3, T4, T5, T6) with abstract geometrical shapes presented on A4 sheets of paper. It is easy and fast to conduct, needing a maximum of 15 minutes.
For T1, objects consisted of horizontal lines of various extents (from 0.7 to 4.5 cm) combined with a vertical bar of 1 cm placed either at the left extremity of the horizontal line (forming a L shape) or at 1.5 cm from the left extremity of the horizontal line (forming an asymmetrical T shape upside down, as illustrated on Fig 1). The closest distance between the two objects aligned horizontally was 0.9 cm. Participants had to judge whether the two objects have same length or not.
For T2, objects consisted of two discs of same or different diameter (from 0.75 to 2.25 cm). The closest distance between the two objects aligned horizontally was 1.8 cm. Participants had to judge whether the two discs have the same size or not.
For T3, objects consisted of two crosses, the right cross was composed of two perpendicular bars of 4 cm, one horizontal and one vertical, while the left cross could display a near-horizontal or a near-vertical bar leading to angles that can be 90° + /- 7°. The closest distance between the two objects, not aligned horizontally, was 2 cm. Participants had to judge whether the two objects have similar angles or not.
The midline judgement subtest (T4) consisted of a single pre-bisected horizontal line of 12 cm with spatial offsets from the true midline ranging from 0 to 6 mm. Participants were asked to judge whether the bisection mark was at midline or not.
For T5, objects consisted of two square frames of 6 cm with a black dot of 3 mm diameter inside each frame with a positional difference ranging from 3 to 6 mm. The closest distance between the two frames, not aligned horizontally, was 7.5 cm. Participants had to judge whether the dot is at the same relative position to the frame in the two objects.
Subtest T6 consisted of the same right object as T5, but the left one contains several randomly arranged colored dots. Participants had to select the dot corresponding to the position of the black dot in the right frame, and either report its color or point to it.
Scoring of the EVSP test performance independent of age.
Raw accuracy scores in the EVSP test scores improve during childhood and adolescence and remain stable in adulthood [23], which is why they ought to be compared with the normative range established by developmental age category. The most recent norms for each subtest and for the total score (which corresponds to the sum of the subtests’ scores) can be found in Drissi et al. [24]. The raw score obtained by each patient was categorized into 4 scoring classes by comparison to the age-normative values, such that we included in our further analyses standardized values independent of the patient’s chronological age at testing. A raw score below the inferior Outlier Limit (OL = Q1 - 1.5 x interquartile range), corresponding to a score below the one observed at the 5th lower centile of the normative population, was categorized in class 1. A raw score between the inferior Outlier Limit (OL) and the inferior limit of the interquartile range (Q1) was categorized in class 2. A raw score between Q1 and the median (M) was categorized in class 3. A raw score at the median or above was categorized in class 4.
Prevalence of visuo-spatial perception disorder by group.
At any age, performance scored below the lower interquartile (<Q1) at the EVSP screening test is clinically considered fragile (corresponding to the lowest 25% scores of the age-matched neurotypical population) and performance scored below the lower Outlier Limit (<OL) is considered pathological (corresponding to the lowest 5% scores of the age-matched neurotypical population). To establish whether the prevalence of fragile visuo-spatial perception was frequent in a given group, we determined the number of patients who scored lower than the Q1, changed it into an observed percentage in the group, and performed a one-sided statistical comparison to 25% using the Fisher exact test. For the evaluation of the prevalence of visuo-spatial perception deficit, the number of patients scoring below OL was determined, then changed into an observed percentage in the group that was compared statistically to 5% using a one-sided Fisher exact test. Fisher exact tests were performed on the website biostatgv.sentiweb.fr.
Percentages of prevalence were calculated and statistically tested when possible (n > 5) for the total score in the different groups of visual impairment defined by the WHO levels [8]. Then, percentages of prevalence were calculated and statistically tested for the total score and separately for each sub-test, in the total sample and in the two groups that we specifically isolated. The first group was composed of 19 patients with a diagnosis of Retinitis Pigmentosa. They were aged between 6 and 22 (median = 14 years, interquartile range = [9−15]) and visual field extent varied from 40° to less than 5°. Their far BCVA ranged between 1.00 and 0.00 logMAR and their near BCVA between 1.00 and 0.10 logMAR. The second group was composed of 18 patients with diagnosis of Albinism. They were aged between 6 and 39 (median = 7.5 years, interquartile range = [6−15]). Their far BCVA ranged between 1.10 and 0.50 logMAR and their near BCVA between 1.00 and 0.10 logMAR. All had a normal visual field except one who presented a visual field reduced but ≥20°. As we used standard scoring, independent of age, for the EVSP screening test, matching the two groups on age was not necessary. Nevertheless, direct statistical comparison of the two groups in term of age did not reach significance (Mann-Whitney test p = 0.07, Z = −1.81).
Under the request of a reviewer, the direct statistic comparison of the two groups’ performance at the EVSP screening test was also undertaken using non-parametric Mann-Whitney test comparison of their total scores.
Correlation between EVSP performance and VI criteria.
To determine whether there is a link between the VI criteria (visual acuity or visual field extent) and the EVSP total score class, we performed Spearman Rank correlation test separately for the Visual Field Extent, the near and the far Visual Acuity, as well as multiple regressions with Statistica 13.2 Software (StatSoft, Inc). Note that for the regression analyses, we used the equivalent French unity measure of visual acuity in decimals (data set on-line). Due to the missing data, the simple Spearman correlations were run on n = 71 individuals for the near BCVA and are thus less powerfull than those run on n = 92 individuals for the far BCVA and the Visual Field extent. The multiple regression involving far and near BCVA together with Visual field extent could only be run on the 71 individuals on which the three measures were available.
Results and discussion
Results
In the sample, 26% had an heredo-degenerescence disorder (18% suffered from Retinitis Pigmentosa and 8% from Stargardt disease), and 17% suffered from Albinism (Table 1). These percentages are comparable to the results of a survey conducted in 2012 on a larger population (N = 1047) consulting the French SSAASI: retinal heredo-degenerescence disorders (Retinitis Pigmentosa, Stargardt disease, Usher syndrome…) represented 25% of the sample, and the second most frequent cause was Alb with a frequency of 12% [11]. However, while the survey concluded that genetic and perinatal factors were the most frequent causes of visual impairment, in our sample the most frequent cause was optical nerve disorder with various etiologies (dominant optic atrophy, congenital glaucoma, optic neuropathy, optic nerve hypoplasia) whose functional manifestations on the visual field are more heterogeneous and less characteristic than in Retinitis Pigmentosa. Retinitis Pigmentosa and Albinism were the two second most frequent diseases of our sample and they are well characterized as two inherited retinal disorders with distinctive functional manifestations: mostly restriction of visual field extent in the former, and visual acuity loss in the latter. We therefore put a focus on these two groups to question the respective contribution of these two criteria of VI on visuo-spatial perceptual skills that may be involved in the lower academic achievement observed in VI.
Prevalence of visuospatial perception disorder.
Prevalence was established on the total score of EVSP test and also on each subtest in the total sample (Fig 2A) and separately for the Retinitis Pigmentosa (Fig 2B) and Albinism (Fig 2C) groups (see also Table 3).
In the total sample with visual impairment (N = 97), we found a high and significant prevalence of visuo-spatial perception disorder: 36% (p < 0.001) displayed a pathological total score below OL and 73% (p < 0.001) displayed a fragile total score below Q1. The prevalence of disorder was also high and significant for each subtest with a minimum of 27% of people scoring <OL (p < 0.01) and of 46% scoring <Q1 (p < 0.05 for T2 and for the 5 other subtests all p values<0.01).
In the group of 18 individuals suffering from Albinism, the prevalence of fragility just reached significance but not the prevalence of deficit: 23% scored as outliers (p = 0.24) and 56% scored below Q1 (p = 0.043). The prevalence of outlier scores was nevertheless significant for three subtests: Length comparison (T1:28%; p = 0.008), Midline judgment (T4:28%; p = 0.008) and Relative Position comparison (T5:47%; p < 0.001).
In the group of 19 individuals suffering from Retinitis Pigmentosa, the prevalence of deficit was significant with 37% displaying an outlier score at the EVSP screening test (p = 0.001) and 89% scoring below Q1 (p = 0.010). The prevalence of deficit was significant for each subtest (T1: 21% (p = 0.027), 42% for T2 (p < 0.001), 31% for T3 and T5 (p = 0.003), 47% for T4 (p < 0.001) and 68% for T6 (p < 0.001).
When directly compared, the performance at the EVSP screening test was not significantly different at the group-level between RP and Alb. Mann-Whitney test displayed only a trend (p = 0.077; Z = 1.65).
Relationship between EVSP performance and VI criteria.
Table 2 describes our population according to WHO classification criteria, i.e., levels of severity depending on visual acuity, visual field restriction or their combination. It reports the total number of patients of our sample in each category and the number of them displaying a pathological score (<OL) or a fragile score (<Q1) at the EVSP screening test. When the total number of patients in a category was above 5, we also computed the percentage of EVSP disorder and tested the statistical significance of this computed prevalence in bold.
For equivalent severity level of visual impairment, EVSP disorder appeared more frequent when visual impairment was dominated by the visual field reduction (right part of the Table 2) than when it was dominated by visual acuity reduction (left part of the Table 2). For example, for a mild level of visual impairment, the prevalence of visuo-spatial perception disorder was not significant for the left column gathering 11 individuals with visual acuity between 0.50 and 0.30 logMAR and normal visual field, whereas it was significant for the right column gathering 7 individuals with similar visual acuity but presenting a small reduction of the visual field remaining superior to 20° of extent. For a moderate VI level, the addition of visual field reduction to a visual acuity between 1.00 and 0.50 logMAR also increased the prevalence of visuo-spatial disorder (36% of deficit prevalence and half of the population scoring below Q1 when the visual field was normal, while the deficit prevalence reached 54% and 86% scored below Q1 with reduction of the visual field). In the category of severe VI, despite equivalent or even better visual acuity, a stronger reduction of the visual field (below 20°) on the right part of the table (n = 9) was associated with high significant prevalence of visuo-spatial perceptual deficit.
The read out of these raw data from Table 2 is difficult and the multiplication of the small groups decreases the statistical power of the Fischer tests. Correlation analyses performed in the whole sample provides further and stronger evidence for the deleterious effect of the spatial restriction of the visual field on visuo-spatial perception relative to the visual acuity reduction. As shown on Fig 3A-C illustrating the simple regressions, the total score class at the EVSP screening test correlated significantly to the visual field extent classification (n = 92, Spearman R = 0.23; p < 0.05), whereas it did not significantly correlate neither with far BCVA (n = 92; Spearman R = 0.06; p > 0.05) nor with near BCVA (n = 71; Spearman R = 0.22; p > 0.05). The multiple regression including far and near BCVA and Visual field extent (R = 0.37; n = 71) showed significant p value for Visual field (p = 0.018, t(67)=2.43) but neither for far BCVA (p = 0.518, t(67)=0.650) nor for near BCVA (p = 0.313, t(67)=1.016). Note that the explanatory effect of the visual field extent also remains the only significant when the regression analysis is performed with only the near visual acuity and the visual field extent (R = 0.31, near visual acuity p = 0.20, visual field extent p = 0.02), or only the far visual acuity and the visual field extent (R = 0.28, far visual acuity p = 0.417, visual field extent p = 0.010)
Discussion
Most studies in the literature have investigated spatial cognition in blindness [25–28]. The present study investigates whether it would be relevant to consider that spatial cognition may be at-risk as well in the mildest form in visual impairment (VI). Even if residual vision improves spatial skills compared to complete blindness [29], its reliability to support learning through vision could be questioned, separately for visual acuity and visual field reductions which are the two distinctive criteria used to classify VI by the World Health Organization (WHO). Tubular vision for example, as in Retinitis Pigmentosa, may be sufficient to identify visual objects when captured by central vision, a process relying on the ventral cortical visual stream, but insufficient to accurately apprehend their positions, metrics, and spatial relationships.
The Elementary Visuo-Spatial Perception (EVSP) screening test evaluates this cortical “Where” function of the dorsal occipito-parietal visual stream [23] by assessing the ability to discriminate, through vision, differences in the spatial relationship between the objects in the environment, or in their spatial metrics. It is called “elementary” as it is supposed to evaluate perceptual spatial process that may contribute to the development of other cognitive functions, to which its performance is correlated [16]. Indeed, visual perception is dynamic and implies spatial working memory processes [30]. It involves the high-level integration across space, in multiple reference frames, of the different visual “snapshots” collected overtly or covertly, i.e., from macular and peripheral vision, to build an accurate perceptual representation [19].
Areas of the dorsal visual stream display accurate representations of the visual space, without a magnified representation of macular vision relative to peripheral vision [31–33]. Based on this active compensation of the cortical magnification distortion, the dorsal visual stream plays an important role to refine spatial perception [34]. The dorsal visual stream is supplied by macular and peripheral vision whereas the ventral visual stream is mostly supplied by inputs from the macula [35,36]. A disease affecting peripheral retina could therefore be potentially deleterious for the dorsal visual stream with higher functional repercussion on visuo-spatial processing than low visual acuity.
Accordingly, the main result of the present study was that the total score of the EVSP screening test significantly correlated to the visual field extent in our sample (N = 92). Table 2 also showed that for a similar visual acuity loss (labelled either mild or moderate by the WHO), the addition of a slight restriction of visual field was associated with higher prevalence of impairment at the EVSP screening test. Moreover, in the Retinitis Pigmentosa group of the present study, more than half displayed pathological scores at the EVSP screening test and 89% of them displayed fragile scores. The disorder concerned all subtests. These converging results stand in contrast with the finding of a recent study in which normally sighted participants performed the EVSP screening test with a gaze-contingent tubular vision without a significant drop of accuracy compared to full vision [19]. We think that this is because artificial masking mimics only the difficulty to sample visual information but not the long-life effects of such visual restriction in terms of cortical development and plasticity. This is confirmed by the neuroimaging literature involving patients with Retinitis Pigmentosa. In young adults suffering from this inherited disease, Ferreira et al [37] have evidenced a cortical reorganization at the level of the primary visual area (V1) which depended on the size of the residual visual field. Retinitis Pigmentosa caused an erratic expansion of the (preserved) central visual field representation in V1 toward the deafferented regions dedicated to peripheral field representation. The deficits of perceptual visuo-spatial skills measured in central vision in Retinitis Pigmentosa [38] may reflect this maladaptive plasticity in V1, on which relies the reading out of spatial configurations and metrics by the visual dorsal stream. Dorsal stream vulnerability has previously been highlighted in neurodevelopmental disorders [17] or amblyopia [39]. What we add here is the important role of peripheral vision sparing in the development of accurate dorsal visual stream function.
From the neuroimaging literature, we have speculated that the visuo-spatial perception deficit observed in the present study for the group of Retinitis Pigmentosa may result from the distortion of central vision linked to the plasticity in V1 triggered by the loss of input from peripheral retina. Such remapping of spatial retinotopy should theoretically not occur in diseases causing a general decrease of visual acuity, since the whole visual field cortical representation is still fed by visual inputs. Accordingly, the prevalence of visuo-spatial perception deficit did not reach significance in the Albinism group of this study (N = 18) with performance equivalent to typically developing population for the subtests of size (T2) and angle (T3) comparison and of position selection (T6). This result was reinforced by the lack of significant correlation in the whole sample between the EVSP screening test total score and the visual acuity measure available in the clinical folders, whether it was provided as far (N = 92) or near (N = 71) visual acuity. These secondary results of the present study have two important consequences: 1) this shows that the EVSP screening test can still be used for clinical examination even if visual acuity is low, 2) even if it seems counterintuitive, development of good visuospatial perception does not crucially dependent on the ability to see objects clearly.
Conclusion
Many adaptations are developed for VI, classically with the idea to compensate for low visual acuity. This includes multimodal stimulations or visual adaptation like the design of new fonts to ameliorate readability. Luciole (luciole-vision.com) modifies spatial typographical characteristics such as thickness and length of the strokes, and the space between letters. Acting on spatial dimensions appeared beneficial to improve academic accessibility [40]. This study involved people aged between 6 and 35 without distinguishing the criteria of VI. It would be interesting to retrospectively explore whether the benefit was higher for individuals with reduced visual field.
Lunghi et al. [41] suggested that the plasticity of the adult brain in Retinitis Pigmentosa can let them benefit from prospective strategies aiming at restoring or substituting peripheral retinal input. Multimodal stimulations can improve spatial cognition in blindness [42,43] and in VI [44]. The results of the present study would lead to preconize them also and above all for individuals with preserved visual acuity but restricted visual field. Indeed, their residual central vision may not reveal reliable enough to subtend good visuo-spatial perception of learning supports.
Supporting information
S1 Table. Raw clinicale and functional vision dataset of all included subjects (N=105).
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0363153.s001
(PDF)
References
- 1.
WHO. Blindness and visual impairment [Internet]. 2010. Available from: https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/blindness-and-visual-impairment
- 2. Kong L, Fry M, Al-Samarraie M, Gilbert C, Steinkuller PG. An update on progress and the changing epidemiology of causes of childhood blindness worldwide. J Am Assoc Pediatr Ophthalmol Strabismus. 2012;16(6):501–7. pmid:23237744
- 3. Fellenius K. Reading environment at home and at school of Swedish students with visual impairments. J Vis Impair Blind. 1999;93(4):211–24.
- 4. Woods RJ, Davis K, Scharff L. Effects of typeface and font size on legibility for children. Am J Psychol Res. 2005:86–102.
- 5.
Pigeon C, Baltenneck N, Galiano AR, Uzan G. Étude Homère. Étude nationale sur la déficience visuelle. Université Lyon 2; 2023.
- 6. Pigeon C, Galiano AR, Afonso-Jaco A, Valente D, Uzan G, Prestini M, et al. A participatory research to design a survey providing a portrait of the life of people with visual impairments. Disabil Soc. 2023;40(2):300–16.
- 7. Pigeon C, Valente D, Baltenneck N, Uzan G, Galiano AR. Recherche participative sur la déficience visuelle: Analyse des modalités de participation de l’étude Homère. Revue Interdisciplinaire Sur Le Handicap Visuel. 2024.
- 8.
World Health Organization (WHO). International Classification of Diseases, Eleventh Revision (ICD-11) [Internet]. 2019. Available from: https://icd.who.int/browse11
- 9. Hamel C. Retinitis pigmentosa. Orphanet J Rare Dis. 2006;1:40. pmid:17032466
- 10. Grønskov K, Ek J, Brondum-Nielsen K. Oculocutaneous albinism. Orphanet J Rare Dis. 2007;2:43. pmid:17980020
- 11.
Robert PY. déficience visuelle.pdf [rapport de la société française d’ophtalmologie]. Société Française d’ophtalmologie; 2015. pp. 154–62.
- 12. Burton M, Ramke J, Marques A. The Lancet Global Health Commission on Global Eye Health: vision beyond 2020. Lancet Glob Health. 2021;9:e489–551.
- 13. Saj A, Barisnikov K. Influence of spatial perception abilities on reading in school-age children. Cogent Psychol. 2015;2(1):1049736.
- 14. Fischer MH, Shaki S. Spatial associations in numerical cognition--from single digits to arithmetic. Q J Exp Psychol (Hove). 2014;67(8):1461–83. pmid:25051273
- 15. Gilligan KA, Hodgkiss A, Thomas MSC, Farran EK. The developmental relations between spatial cognition and mathematics in primary school children. Dev Sci. 2018;13:e12786.
- 16. Gras D, Ploix Maes E, Doulazmi M, Huron C, Galléa C, Boespflug Tanguy O. Developmental coordination disorder subtypes in children: An unsupervised clustering. Dev Med Child Neurol. 2023.
- 17. Pisella L, Martel M, Roy AC, Vuillerot C, Gonzalez-Monge S. Validation of a simple screening test for elementary visuo-spatial perception deficit. Ann Phys Rehabil Med. 2020;63(4):302–8. pmid:31009800
- 18. Pisella L, Vialatte A, Martel M, Prost-Lefebvre M, Caton M-C, Stalder M, et al. Elementary visuospatial perception deficit in children with neurodevelopmental disorders. Dev Med Child Neurol. 2021;63(4):457–64. pmid:33314050
- 19. Drissi H, Jurkiewicz T, Vialatte A, Khan AZ, Pisella L. Impact of macular scotoma and tubular vision on oculomotor behavior and performance in visuospatial comparison tasks. J Vis. 2024;24(9):2. pmid:39226068
- 20. Fortenbaugh FC, Hicks JC, Hao L, Turano KA. Losing sight of the bigger picture: Peripheral field loss compresses representations of space. Vision Res. 2007;47(19):2506–20. pmid:17692884
- 21. Sabbah N, Sanda N, Authié CN, Mohand-Saïd S, Sahel J-A, Habas C, et al. Reorganization of early visual cortex functional connectivity following selective peripheral and central visual loss. Sci Rep. 2017;7:43223. pmid:28233790
- 22. Sanda N, Cerliani L, Authié CN, Sabbah N, Sahel J-A, Habas C, et al. Visual brain plasticity induced by central and peripheral visual field loss. Brain Struct Funct. 2018;223(7):3473–85. pmid:29936553
- 23. Pisella L, André V, Gavault E, Le Flem A, Luc-Pupat E, Glissoux C, et al. A test revealing the slow acquisition and the dorsal stream substrate of visuo-spatial perception. Neuropsychologia. 2013;51(1):106–13. pmid:23174400
- 24. Drissi H, Mosquera J, Plaisant F, Vuillerot C, Gonzalez-Monge S, Pisella L. Visuospatial perception in prematurely born children without cerebral palsy or retinopathy but with scholar complaints. Dev Neuropsychol. 2024;49(5):207–24. pmid:38904205
- 25.
Hatwell Y. Psychologie cognitive de la cécité précoce. France: DUNOD; 2003. pp. 213.
- 26. Pasqualotto A, Proulx MJ. The role of visual experience for the neural basis of spatial cognition. Neurosci Biobehav Rev. 2012;36(4):1179–87. pmid:22330729
- 27. Thinus-Blanc C, Gaunet F. Representation of space in blind persons: Vision as a spatial sense? Psychol Bull. 1997;121:23.
- 28. Gori M, Amadeo MB, Campus C. Spatial metric in blindness: Behavioural and cortical processing. Neurosci Biobehav Rev. 2020;109:54–62. pmid:31899299
- 29. Papadopoulos K, Koustriava E, Kartasidou L. The impact of residual vision in spatial skills of individuals with visual impairments. J Spec Educ. 2011;45(2):118–27.
- 30. Pisella L. Visual perception is dependent on visuospatial working memory and thus on the posterior parietal cortex. Ann Phys Rehabil Med. 2017;60(3):141–7. pmid:26926263
- 31. Galletti C, Fattori P, Gamberini M, Kutz DF. The cortical visual area V6: Brain location and visual topography. Eur J Neurosci. 1999;11(11):3922–36. pmid:10583481
- 32. Fattori P, Pitzalis S, Galletti C. The cortical visual area V6 in macaque and human brains. J Physiol Paris. 2009;103(1–2):88–97. pmid:19523515
- 33. Pitzalis S, Fattori P, Galletti C. The human cortical areas V6 and V6A. Vis Neurosci. 2015;32:E007. pmid:26241369
- 34. Jurkiewicz T, Salemme R, Froment C, Pisella L. Role of the dorsal posterior parietal cortex in the accurate perception of object magnitude in peripheral vision. Iperception. 2021;12(6). pmid:34900214
- 35. Iwata M. Visual association pathways in human brain. Tohoku J Exp Med. 1990;161 Suppl:61–78. pmid:2082505
- 36. Stephen JM, Aine CJ, Christner RF, Ranken D, Huang M, Best E. Central versus peripheral visual field stimulation results in timing differences in dorsal stream sources as measured with MEG. Vision Res. 2002;42(28):3059–74. pmid:12480075
- 37. Ferreira S, Pereira AC, Quendera B, Reis A, Silva ED, Castelo-Branco M. Primary visual cortical remapping in patients with inherited peripheral retinal degeneration. Neuroimage Clin. 2016;13:428–38. pmid:28116235
- 38. Wittich W, Faubert J, Watanabe DH, Kapusta MA, Overbury O. Spatial judgments in patients with retinitis pigmentosa. Vision Res. 2011;51(1):165–73. pmid:21073889
- 39. Atkinson J. The Davida Teller Award Lecture, 2016: Visual brain development: A review of “Dorsal stream vulnerability”—motion, mathematics, amblyopia, actions, and attention. J Vis. 2017;17(3):26.
- 40. Galiano AR, Augereau-Depoix V, Baltenneck N, Latour L, Drissi H. Luciole, a new font for people with low vision. Acta Psychol (Amst). 2023;236:103926. pmid:37137180
- 41. Lunghi C, Galli-Resta L, Binda P, Cicchini GM, Placidi G, Falsini B. Visual cortical plasticity in retinitis pigmentosa. Investig Ophthalmol Vis Sci. 2019;60(7):2753.
- 42. Finocchietti S, Cappagli G, Gori M. Encoding audio motion: Spatial impairment in early blind individuals. Front Psychol. 2015;6:1357. pmid:26441733
- 43. Leo F, Ferrari E, Baccelliere C, Zarate J, Shea H, Cocchi E, et al. Enhancing general spatial skills of young visually impaired people with a programmable distance discrimination training: A case control study. J Neuroeng Rehabil. 2019;16(1):108. pmid:31462262
- 44. Cappagli G, Finocchietti S, Cocchi E, Giammari G, Zumiani R, Cuppone AV, et al. Audio motor training improves mobility and spatial cognition in visually impaired children. Sci Rep. 2019;9(1):3303. pmid:30824830

관련 뉴스