Understanding factors that influence time to surgery for hip fractures in South Africa: A qualitative study using the Model of Pathways to Treatment
Figures
Abstract
Although early surgery for hip fractures (HF) improves patient outcomes, in South Africa (SA) time to surgery often exceeds recommended durations. We explore factors influencing time to HF surgery in SA to inform interventions promoting earlier access. Data were collected through repeated in-depth interviews with 38 HF patients and their caregivers and 40 healthcare professionals (HCPs) and observations of clinical practice in five hospitals in Gauteng. Findings were informed by the four key “intervals” of the ‘Model of Pathways to Treatment’. Appraisal: Personal beliefs that symptoms were due to other causes or that hospital visits were a “weakness”, prompted initial self-management. Early care-seeking was prompted by pain intensity and further encouraged by family members. Help-seeking: Timely access to transport was impacted by ambulance shortages, long distances, and safety concerns for paramedics, and thus many patients relied on private transportation. High-impact trauma cases were prioritised over low-impact HF. Diagnostic: Patient pathways varied and were complicated by ambulance shortages and scheduling issues. Administrative requirements (referral letters) slowed referral processes, particularly for patients from outside hospital catchment areas. Caregivers found admission paperwork burdensome, while HCPs viewed it as helpful for coordinating care and avoiding later delays. While hospitals prioritised emergency cases (including HF), HCPs felt streamlining administrative processes could improve time to X-ray. Pre-treatment: Patients and caregivers reported long waits for surgery, with delays leading to complications and further setbacks. Surgeries were often postponed for other “emergencies”, with HCPs describing difficulties with managing competing surgical priorities. This study, the first to explore factors that impact time to HF surgery in SA, highlights the agency of patients and caregivers in negotiating access to treatment, and health system processes that help or hinder access. Findings identify key leverage points for interventions targeted at each ‘interval’ in the care pathway to accelerate access to HF surgery.
Citation: Drew S, Cassim B, Chingono RMS, Paruk F, Lukhele M, Zinyemba C, et al. (2026) Understanding factors that influence time to surgery for hip fractures in South Africa: A qualitative study using the Model of Pathways to Treatment. PLOS Glob Public Health 6(11): e0007215. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgph.0007215
Editor: Hani Mowafi, Yale University School of Medicine, UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
Received: December 4, 2025; Accepted: August 10, 2026; Published: November 20, 2026
Copyright: © 2026 Drew et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Data Availability: Data generated and analysed during the study are available in the University of Bristol Research Data Repository, data.bris, at https://doi.org/10.5523/bris.2sruce7ukaka72ms9rdp8o7bky or through the University of Bristol Fractures E3 data access mailbox - fe3-data-access@bristol.ac.uk. Access to the data will be restricted to ensure that data is only made available to bona fide researchers for ethically approved research projects, on the understanding that confidentiality will be maintained and after a Data Access Agreement has been signed by an institutional signatory. The University of Bristol Data Access Committee in consultation with the Study Principal Investigator (Professor Celia Gregson) and in-country Principal Investigator (Professor Rashida Ferrand) will be responsible for deciding if data can be released to external researchers for secondary analyses, in compliance with Zimbabwean governance regulations.
Funding: This work was supported by the National Institute for Health Research (NIHR) (using the UK’s Official Development Assistance (ODA) Funding) and Wellcome Trust (217135/Z/19/Z) under the NIHR-Wellcome Partnership for Global Health Research (217135/Z/19/Z to CLG). CLG is funded by the NIHR (NIHR302394). The views expressed are those of the authors and not necessarily those of Wellcome, the NIHR or the Department of Health and Social Care. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Introduction
Eastern, Western, Central, and Southern Africa is undergoing a demographic transition, characterised by significant population ageing. The United Nations projects a 218% rise in the older population in the Region between 2019 and 2050 [1]. In South Africa (SA), the proportion of individuals aged 60 years and older increased from 7% in 1996 to 9.8% in 2022 [2]. Ageing is accompanied by rising individual and population-level health challenges, including an increase in musculoskeletal conditions such as fragility fractures, including hip fractures [3]. In SA, hip fractures are associated with substantial morbidity and mortality, often resulting in long-term disability, loss of independence, and diminished quality of life [4]. Historically, hip fractures were considered rare among African populations in SA. However, a 2020 study by Dela et al. identified a rise in incidence since the 1960s [5], which has been projected to increase further by 2050 [3]. South Africa operates a two-tiered healthcare system divided into private and public care. The latter is means tested that categorises patients based on their ability to pay, with treatment for pensioners, receiving a government pension or equivalent, fully subsidised. Nevertheless, the economic implications of hip fractures for the public healthcare system are considerable with an estimated average cost of treating a hip fracture within the public healthcare system in SA estimated to be US$6,935 per patient in 2023 [6], significantly exceeding the national per capita health expenditure [6,7].
Surgical intervention remains the global standard of care for hip fractures, typically involving metal implants to either fix or replace the broken bone, depending on the fracture type [7]. Within SA, the majority of patients are treated surgically [8] by a multidisciplinary team that includes orthopaedic surgeons, physicians, anaesthetists, nurses and therapists [9]. Globally, timely surgery within 24 – 72 hours post injury has been shown to greatly improve patient outcomes [10]. Although there is no international consensus on recommended time to surgery [9], the Africa Orthopaedic (AO) Alliance has recommended surgical intervention within five days of sustaining a hip fracture [11]. In SA, the median time to hip fracture surgery once patients have been admitted to a public treatment facility is 19 days [4], far exceeding this duration. Research on factors influencing the implementation of HF services and time to surgery in LMICs is limited, but existing studies suggest a complex interplay of patient, health system, and disease-related factors. The INFORMUS study, which examined time from injury to hip fracture surgery across 18 LMICs including SA, found that HFs were not immediately recognised by patients as serious medical events, leading to delayed care-seeking [12]. A review by Elsevier et al. in 2021 on the management of HFs in older people in LMICs highlighted resource constraints, including staffing shortages and essential equipment like X-ray machines that hindered timely surgical intervention [13]. In India and across other parts of Asia, qualitative research suggests that HFs are frequently deprioritised in favour of other emergencies such as obstetric cases [14,15]. Factors that impact time to hip fracture surgery in SA are likely to be similarly multi-faceted. Understanding these factors will enable healthcare professionals and policy makers to develop targeted interventions to improve time to surgery, and ultimately patient outcomes.
A range of theories and frameworks have been used to understand pathways to treatment, including surgical care [16]. These include models focused on treatment-seeking behaviour, which vary in their emphasis on individual and socio-cultural influences [17]. Wyke et al. distinguish between individualist theories that emphasise the role of individual decision-making processes in informing treatment-seeking behaviour, such as the Health Belief Model—which attributes behaviour change to perceived susceptibility, severity, benefits, barriers, and cues to action [18] —and collectivist theories like the Social Ecological Model, which recognise the broader social and environmental contexts shaping behaviour [19]. A smaller subset of frameworks also consider how healthcare system processes, such as appointment scheduling, influence time to treatment. The Three Delays Framework identifies barriers at three critical stages: seeking care, reaching care, and receiving care [20]. Similarly, Scott et al.’s Model of Pathways to Treatment outlines four key processes that shape time to treatment: (i) patient appraisal and self-management, (ii) patient decision to consult, (iii) healthcare professional appraisal, investigations and referral, and (iv) planning and scheduling of treatment [21].
In this study we chose to use the Model of Pathways to Treatment due to its recognition of the complex and interrelated factors that influence illness behaviour and time to treatment, including health system processes [21]. This is pertinent in the delivery of hip fracture care in SA where extended periods of time have been observed between admission and surgical intervention [4] that are likely to be attributable to organisational factors.
This study explored factors influencing time to surgery for hip fracture care in SA, focusing on the experiences of patients and caregivers. To deepen understanding of the health system processes that influence time to treatment, insights from healthcare professionals were also included. Findings were informed by the Model of Pathways to Treatment [21]. These findings were used to develop a set of recommendations to accelerate time to surgery. This study complements previously published work exploring the implementation of hip fracture services from the perspective of healthcare professionals [22].
Methods
Ethics statement
Study setting
South Africa, designated as an upper-middle-income country, had an estimated population of 62 million in 2022 [24]. Despite this classification, the nation is characterised by socio-economic inequality, as reflected in a Gini coefficient of 0.63—one of the highest in the world [25].
In 2022, SA recorded an average unemployment rate of 33.5% [26]. In the same year, total health expenditure amounted to 8.77% of gross domestic product (GDP) [27], exceeding the World Health Organization’s recommended threshold of 5% for mitigating financial hardship associated with healthcare costs [28]. However, substantial disparities persist in per capita health spending, with the private sector receiving disproportionately greater investment relative to the public sector [29]. The country faces a quadruple burden of disease, encompassing: (1) communicable diseases, notably HIV/AIDS and tuberculosis; (2) elevated maternal and child mortality; (3) rising non-communicable diseases, including cardiovascular conditions, diabetes, cancer, mental health disorders, and chronic respiratory illnesses; and (4) high rates of injury and trauma [30]. These concurrent health challenges place considerable demands on service delivery and resource allocation. Health outcomes are inequitable, with poorer populations experiencing higher morbidity and mortality rates compared to more affluent groups [31,32].
Healthcare in SA is delivered through a dual system comprising a publicly funded sector, which provides means-tested services to approximately 84% of the population, and a private sector accessed primarily by those with medical scheme coverage (i.e., insurance) [33,34]. While the public system offers financial protection against catastrophic health costs, it is marked by persistent inequities in access and quality of care [34]. Structural challenges such as shortages of healthcare professionals and resources exist [35]. Public healthcare is delivered within a tiered referral system, where patients often begin in primary care clinics and community health centres, advancing through district, regional, tertiary and central hospitals [35]. The population is organised into ‘catchment areas’—geographic areas assigned to specific healthcare facilities. Each facility, whether a primary healthcare facility or hospital, is responsible for delivering services to the population residing within its designated catchment. Individuals living in a catchment area are expected to seek care at the corresponding facility.
Patients with hip fractures may initially present to any public healthcare facility for basic, immediate management before being referred-on for further care. Definitive orthopaedic surgical care is typically provided at regional and higher-level hospitals within the public sector’s structured referral system. Fig 1 shows the pathway of hip fracture care for patients within the public healthcare system.
The study was undertaken in Gauteng Province, chosen as the most populous of the nine provinces in SA. Gauteng had a population of just under 16 million inhabitants in 2024, which represented 25.1% of the country’s population [36]. The study included five public hospitals providing orthopaedic services (three facilities located in urban centres and two in rural areas). Among them, two were tertiary (central) hospitals and three were secondary (regional) hospitals. This selection aimed to capture variations in hospital type, patient volumes, and geographic catchment areas [37].
Study design
This qualitative study was conducted as part of a wider mixed-methods research programme investigating the epidemiology, economic impact, and treatment of fractures and musculoskeletal health using ethnography in The Gambia, SA, and Zimbabwe. The protocol for this work has been published [38]. Data were collected in two stages. Firstly, case studies comprising repeated in-depth interviews with patients who had experienced a hip fracture and their family members and other informal caregivers were undertaken to understand factors that support or hinder access to surgery. Secondly, in-depth interviews were conducted with healthcare professionals involved in the organisation and delivery of hip fracture care who provided additional insights into health system processes that influenced time to surgery. Interviews were complemented by observations of clinical practice that provided further detail about the context in which care was delivered [39].
Participant recruitment
Health professionals who were involved in the delivery and organisation of hip fracture care at all five healthcare facilities were purposively sampled from across the care pathway [37]. Members of the study team approached healthcare professionals about participation during visits to clinical services and emailed or telephoned known contacts. Snowball sampling was also used [41], such that healthcare professionals recommended other professionals who they knew were involved in service delivery. In total, 40 healthcare professionals agreed to participate in the study. Sample size was determined by the achievement of information power which was assessed throughout data collection to ensure adequacy for addressing the study aims [42].
Data collection
Repeated in-depth interviews with patients and their caregivers were conducted from 4th April 2022–7th December 2022 as single, dyads or group interviews with more than two participants. Topic guides informed data collection and explored pathways through care, including factors that impacted on access to care (Supplementary material). Depending on a patients’ journey through care, one to three follow-up interviews (ranging from 20 - 90 minutes) were conducted four to eight weeks after the initial interview to understand experiences at different stages of the care pathway. Information relating to time intervals was derived from participants’ accounts during interviews rather than from clinical records. Participants described sequences of events and their experiences of movement through the care pathway. All interviews were carried out in isiZulu, Sesotho or English by two researchers (AM and KK). Interviews were conducted in healthcare facilities, the homes of patients and caregivers or remotely by telephone. Interviews were audio recorded; however, if a participant expressed discomfort in being audio recorded then written notes were taken instead. Of a total of 95 interviews, 61 were single interviews and 34 were dyads or group interviews.
In-depth interviews with healthcare professionals and observations of clinical practice were conducted from 3rd July 2023–23rd April 2025. These explored factors that impacted on the implementation of hip fracture services, including emergency and orthopaedic care. Data collection was informed by patient and caregiver experiences. Topic guides were used as above (Supplementary material). Interviews lasted between 20–90 minutes and were conducted in isiZulu, Sesotho or English (depending on participants’ preferences) in healthcare facilities or remotely using Microsoft Teams by three researchers (AM, KK and SD). Observations explored activities taking place, interactions between healthcare professionals and patients and factors that impact on the implementation of services. Observation checklists were used with fieldnotes written to record observations (Supplementary material). Informal interviews were carried out during observation sessions for researchers to make sense of what they were observing. Approximately 34.5 hours of observations with healthcare professionals were conducted.
The’Model of Pathways to Treatment
The Model of Pathways to Treatment is a framework that describes the multiple stages through which patients transition before they are able to start treatment. It identifies key ‘events’ in the pathway such as recognition of bodily changes, first consultation with a healthcare professional, diagnosis and the initiation of treatment. ‘Intervals’ describe the time between these key events that are influenced by patient-related factors, health provider and system-level factors and disease-specific factors [21]. The relationship between the components of the framework is shown in Fig 2.
Data analysis
Analysis was iterative and informed further data collection [31]. The team held collaborative meetings to incorporate insights from patients and caregivers into data collection tools for healthcare professionals. All interviews, whether audio-recorded or noted, were translated into English verbatim and anonymised to protect participants’ identities. Observations were written up into full fieldnotes.
Data from patients and caregivers and healthcare professionals were analysed as discreet datasets. First, data from patients and caregivers were analysed using Gale et al.’s seven stage approach to framework analysis [43]. Transcripts were reviewed to support familiarisation, after which a sub-set of transcripts were inductively coded to identify factors that impacted time to surgery. Codes were grouped into categories to develop an initial analytical framework. The analytical framework was then applied to subsequent transcripts using NVivo qualitative analysis software. The framework was iteratively refined where new themes were identified. Data were then charted onto a matrix which involved summarising the data by category for each interview. This aided comparison across cases and supported interpretation of findings. Analysis focused on how participants described their progression through different stages of the pathway and on the factors that influenced this, rather than on calculating the duration of specific intervals. Next, interviews with healthcare professionals and observations of clinical practice were analysed using a ‘rapid analysis’ approach [44]. In this, transcripts and observations were manually reviewed, with data coded inductively to identify barriers and facilitators to treatment using structured summary templates. Triangulation was carried out by comparing findings across the datasets [45]. Similarities and differences were identified to develop a more comprehensive understanding of factors that impacted on time to surgical care. Following separate analyses, themes from both datasets were then synthesised and transposed onto the four ‘intervals’ in the Model of Pathways to Treatment [21]. This process enabled integration of patient experiences with healthcare professional perspectives and observations of clinical practice.
The research team comprised South African, Zimbabwean and UK-based researchers. To ensure cultural and contextual sensitivity, all data collection tools were co-developed and translated by the in-country team. Interviews were conducted in participants’ preferred language by researchers fluent in isiZulu, Sesotho, and English. Regular team debriefs were held to discuss how researchers’ professional and personal backgrounds might influence data interpretation and to ensure findings were grounded in the local context.
Findings
Patient and caregiver characteristics
A total of 38 patients and 34 caregivers were recruited for the study. Hip fracture patient characteristics are summarised in Table 1, while the number of patients recruited from each study site is presented in Table 2. Caregiver characteristics are presented in Table 3.
Healthcare professional characteristics
A total of 40 healthcare professionals were recruited for the study. Their professional roles are summarised in Table 4, while the number of participants recruited from each study site is presented in Table 5. To maintain confidentiality, all study sites are anonymised.
- (i) Appraisal: Patient appraisal and self-management
Decisions to seek medical care following a hip fracture were shaped by a combination of factors. Some patients explained that they did not initially recognise the severity of their injury, attributing symptoms to less serious causes such as a strained muscle. They often opted for self-management of pain using over-the-counter medication and decided to “wait and see” if the pain would stop. They explained that this had delayed them visiting a healthcare facility:
“[We called the doctor] the next day… I didn’t know it was so bad. I thought maybe I had bruised myself. So that’s why I said to my son ‘let’s wait until the next day and we will see’.” Patient, male, 70 years old
Many patients explained the intensity of pain and inability to move were key factors prompting them to seek medical care, as they perceived the hospital as the only place able to provide effective treatment.
Several patients, particularly men, reported being reluctant to attend hospital as they associated it with being “sick” which they saw as a weakness. Others were concerned about long waits before receiving treatment. In contrast, those with medical aid said it had encouraged them to visit a hospital as they assumed it would enable them to access efficient care. Social networks also played a critical role in shaping decisions: for instance some patients described how relatives helped alleviate their fears about visiting hospitals. Logistical challenges presented further challenges. Several patients described being alone at the time of the fall, lacking mobile phone credit to call for help, and having to wait for family members to return from work to assist. In some cases, they explained that neighbours had provided essential support, such as contacting relatives or helping them into the house. One participant described being unconscious and immobile after falling outside, with neighbours playing a vital role in initiating help-seeking by contacting their family members.
- (ii) Help-seeking: Patient decision to consult healthcare professional and arrange an appointment
Once a decision to seek health care was made, patients and their caregivers explained that accessing ambulance services to transfer them to healthcare facilities was often challenging. Although transport-related barriers were reported by many patients and caregivers, they were described more frequently by participants from rural areas. Those who lived in rural areas with long distances to healthcare facilities thought that this had contributed to a longer wait for assistance. In some cases, they recounted incidences where ambulances failed to arrive.
Healthcare professionals noted that ambulance availability was frequently constrained due to the limited number of vehicles, resulting in prolonged wait times for patients in need of emergency assistance. They explained that some roads were hard to access and navigate. Paramedics clarified that the prioritisation system used by emergency services tended to favour cases involving high-impact incidents, such as road traffic accidents, meaning that patients with low-impact hip fractures were not considered a priority for rapid response. In addition to logistical constraints, paramedics explained that they faced significant safety concerns, prompting the need for police escorts in certain areas that slowed down response times:
“Challenges that we face as paramedics is being attacked because during the night they fight and the next thing is they turn back on us, they rob us. There were two kidnappings.” Paramedic, Site 4.
In response to limited ambulance availability, many patients and caregivers explained that they chose to seek private transport. Some described borrowing money or seeking assistance from those who could afford to pay, while others used private or neighbour’s vehicles. Patients with long-standing relationships with taxi drivers, especially among older patients who regularly visited hospitals, explained that this had enabled them to defer payments until government social grants were received. This trust between patients and drivers helped to ensure timely access to care when immediate funds were unavailable:
“There is nothing free. It was a 100 [Rand] back-and-forth. [The taxi driver] charged me the same amount… but I paid at the end of the month with my grant.” Patient, female, 76 years old
- (iii) Diagnostic: Healthcare professional appraisal, investigations and referral
Patients described considerable variation in their pathways to surgery, often undergoing multiple transfers between clinics, district hospitals, and private facilities. Patients and caregivers explained that they had weighed the advantages and disadvantages of waiting for an ambulance versus arranging private transport to travel between facilities. Some chose to wait, believing that ambulance staff would be better equipped to manage their hip fracture and help minimise pain during the journey:
“We decided to get someone to help us with transport to the hospital, but I quickly opted for an ambulance because I know that those people [the taxi drivers] won’t have mercy on me. If I cry, they will just be doing their work… So my son was pleading with me [to take an ambulance].” Patient, female, 53 years old
Patients reported that being seen by healthcare professionals at clinics and district hospitals had taken a long time. Patients reported that the district hospitals they had visited were unable to diagnose or treat hip fractures due to the unavailability of key resources such as x-ray machines, orthopaedic surgical facilities, and orthopaedic surgeons.
“Yes, we get to the doctor [at the district hospital], and I am thinking, okay, sharp, and I am still thinking it is something small, and even there, I am using the clinic’s wheelchair, ye see, and I am going to my brother… He calls the other doctor; this doctor says do you see that this person broke here and there... the second doctor says ayi, this person got fractured in the wrong place. Then they referred me here [to the tertiary hospital] because they do not treat surgery”. Patient, male, 41 years old
Healthcare professionals attributed the issue to challenges with staffing and resources at the district level:
“We experience a lot of delays in being consulted and getting the patients here [to the tertiary facility]. So sometimes the patients gets delayed there [at the district or regional hospital]. They try to do them in a smaller hospital and then on the day of surgery, the patient gets cancelled. They need to do the science [and work out if a] patient needs an ICU bed. Then we see the patient a week, two weeks, even three weeks later. And by that time we know that the morbidity and the mortality complications rises.” Orthopaedic surgeon, Site 3
Patients and caregivers who visited “medical aid facilities” (private facilities covered by medical insurance or that require a cash payment for patients who are not insured) reported mixed experiences. While they explained that these services had x-ray facilities available, smaller queues and efficient referral processes, the cost of treatment was viewed as being high. As a result, they had decided to transfer to a public facility for further care.
Patients and caregivers noted that referral to regional and tertiary facilities for surgery was often challenging. While some patients reported that ambulances were available for transfers on the required days, others noted that limited ambulance availability and the scheduling of ambulances on certain days caused delays. Some patients and caregivers described being admitted to district hospitals while awaiting ambulance transfers.
Patients also described facing administrative barriers to transfers that slowed down the referral process, such as the requirement to obtain referral letters before being transferred to regional or tertiary hospitals. Patients presenting directly to tertiary facilities bypassed some referral-related difficulties. In some cases, patients who arrived at regional or tertiary facilities without the necessary documentation were turned away and sent back to clinics. One patient recounted:
“When we got to [the central hospital], they gave me a hard time... They said, ‘hai, you need to start at the clinic.’ I had to call my child and ask them to fetch me at [the clinic] and only after they gave us a referral letter were we then able to come back again to [the central hospital] … so we went back to the hospital with it.” Patient, female, 56 years old
Healthcare professionals said this reflected challenges in communication across facility levels. They thought that staff at clinics and district hospitals were often unfamiliar with referral protocols. As a result staff at referral hospitals were not consulted prior to the transfer. In addition, some patients explained that they had wanted to be treated at hospitals close to their relatives so they could receive support, rather than at hospitals within their designated catchment areas. As such, some patients relocated closer to the hospital before seeking treatment.
Patients often described waiting a considerable amount of time before being attended to by healthcare professionals after arriving at the final treating facility. During observations it was noted that patient files were initiated on arrival and used by healthcare professionals throughout the hospital journey. Caregivers were observed playing a vital role in this process by providing essential information although some found this onerous:
“When I arrived, they opened a file for me... they made me write a lot of things, which was tedious.” - Patient, female, 58 years old
In contrast to patients, healthcare professionals emphasised the importance of patient files to communicate information within the healthcare team:
Each patient has got a file and everybody who sees that patient from whatever field must document inside of that file, what their findings are and what they have done for that patient within the scope of their own duties. So that patient’s file is really an invaluable resource as to all that goes on with the patient. Medical Officer Internal Medicine, Site 1
Healthcare professionals also thought that registering all patients at the hospital when they presented helped to expedite access to treatment as it meant that information did not have to collected later. Some patients explained that having their information already recorded in the hospital system, including previous medical history and contact details, made the admission process more efficient. A small number of patients who tried to use private healthcare funds mentioned that they had encountered bureaucratic barriers, which ultimately led them to seek care in public institutions. One participant recounted:
“[The private hospital] started by saying they wanted my certified ID copy. I responded, ‘I don’t have it’ and then said, ‘How can I get something certified whilst in pain? I’ll bring it after.’ They said, ‘in that case, we can’t help you without it.’ That’s when I told [my colleague] to leave me at [the public tertiary hospital]. They couldn’t admit me at [the private hospital] without the claim number.” Patient, female, 67 years old.
In some cases, patients reported that healthcare professionals at tertiary facilities had requested a second x-ray to confirm the diagnosis of a hip fracture, although they were unclear why. Patients and caregivers shared that admission to wards was sometimes postponed due to queues at x-ray machines or if the x-ray equipment was not working. During observations it was noted that the corridors leading to the x-ray room were narrow, contributing to a sense of overcrowding. To minimise waiting times, a radiographer at a tertiary hospital explained that they tried to prioritise emergency cases such as hip fractures. The radiographer suggested that time to x-rays could be improved by adding more machines and updating equipment. They also suggested streamlining administrative processes, as patients and caregivers needed to collect files and documentation from the administrative department, pay a registration fee and then proceed to the x-ray room which took time.
Patients described differences between levels of care. District-level facilities were commonly described as having fewer diagnostic resources available to manage hip fractures, leading to onward referral. In contrast at regional and tertiary level facilities, patients described challenges related to high patient volumes and administrative processes.
- (iv) Pre-treatment: Planning and scheduling of treatment
Following admission, many patients described how they experienced long waits for surgery, often exceeding one month, which caused frustration. Most reported cancellations or changes to their surgery dates which was a source of uncertainty and distress. Patients explained that they found repeatedly being ‘nil by mouth’ difficult and uncomfortable, a concern that was echoed by healthcare professionals who worried that it could lead to dehydration and malnutrition. As one patient explained:
Three weeks [I’ve been waiting for an operation], so it’s been a month and a few days since I’ve been hurt. They then come back and say ‘ya, you will go in’ and then they tell me not to eat food. You are not allowed to eat food before you have an operation. Then I stay the whole day without eating. Around eleven or ten o’clock at night, they’d say ‘ahhh, you aren’t going anymore… go back’ but… on Tuesday, it was Tuesday, on Wednesday they did the same thing and said I should eat on Thursday”. Patient, male, 65 years old
Patients and caregivers explained that waiting for surgery had led to complications such as pressure ulcers which then required treatment, causing further setbacks. Similarly, healthcare professionals expressed concern about the effects of long waits for surgery, noting that delays often led to medical complications and impacted patients psychologically.
Patients and caregivers explained that cancellations had occurred due to equipment needing repairs or because certain resources such as implants were unavailable, which had to ordered before surgery. Surgeries were also postponed for what patients and caregivers described as “emergencies” such as road traffic accidents. Healthcare professionals highlighted the challenges of managing competing surgical priorities, such as road traffic accidents and paediatric cases, which were sometimes prioritised over hip fracture patients:
“[What causes the delays to surgery] is the amount of acute surgery that we are having, the amount of people we have waiting to be operated on. Our head of department is the one that does the list... The acute and babies are the ones that are prioritised”. Orthopaedic matron, Site 5
Healthcare professionals in some hospitals explained that hip fracture surgery was only performed on allocated days, which affected overall surgical capacity. Patients and caregivers said that they were uncertain about how theatre lists were organised and expressed frustration at not knowing when surgery would take place. Some caregivers noted that they had questioned healthcare professionals about cancellations and the ordering of surgery to try to expedite time to operation.
Discussion
This study explored factors influencing time to hip fracture surgery in SA to inform interventions that could improve timely access. Factors that impacted time to surgery were identified at all ‘intervals’ in the Model of Pathways to Treatment and included patient-related factors, healthcare provider and system-level issues and factors related to the injury itself [21]. Appraisal: While personal beliefs that their symptoms were due to other causes or that hospital visits were a “weakness”, especially by men, prompted initial self-management, for many pain intensity prompted early care-seeking. Family members encouraged care-seeking, alleviating fears about hospitalisation. Help-seeking: Patients and HCPs described challenges in accessing emergency transport due to ambulance shortages, long distances, and safety concerns for paramedics. Furthermore, high-impact trauma cases were prioritised over low-impact HF. Many patients relied on private transport, often facilitated by social networks. Diagnostic: Patient pathways varied and number of transfers between facilities was complicated by ambulance shortages and scheduling issues. Patients reported that district hospitals were unable to diagnose or treat hip fractures due to resource and staffing shortages, such as x-ray machines, orthopaedic surgical facilities and orthopaedic surgeons. Referral processes were sometimes slowed by administrative requirements such as referral letters, especially when patients sought care outside their hospital catchment areas. At the treating hospital, caregivers found admission paperwork burdensome, while HCPs viewed it as helpful for coordinating care and avoiding later delays. HCPs thought time to X-ray could be improved by streamlining administrative processes, although hospitals prioritised emergency cases, including HF. Pre-treatment: After admission, patients and caregivers reported long waits for surgery and explained this led to medical complications and further setbacks. Surgery was often postponed due to what patients described as “emergencies” like road traffic accidents, and HCPs explained the difficulty of managing competing surgical priorities.
This is the first study to explore in detail the factors influencing time to surgical treatment for hip fractures in SA. The study builds on existing research by helping to elucidate the reasons behind the time to HF surgery previously reported. This includes findings from Cassim et al. that identified the median time to hip fracture surgery once patients have been admitted to a public treatment facility is 19 days [4] and the INFORMUS study which quantified time to hip fracture surgery across 18 LMICs including SA, at three points along the care pathway [12]. Understanding these reasons provides valuable information that can be used to adapt models of care to accelerate access to surgical care, potentially improving patient outcomes [10,46].
Patient appraisal was shaped by beliefs surrounding low-impact fractures, echoing findings from previous research in LMICs that highlight how cultural perceptions of surgical conditions influence treatment-seeking behaviour [47]. Similar to our study, Armstrong et al. reported delays in treatment-seeking for hip fractures due to patients believing the injury would heal without intervention [12]. This aligns with research conducted in India, where patients often underestimated the severity of hip fractures and were unaware that surgical care was necessary [48]. Men’s reluctance to seek medical care as a sign of “weakness”, reflects previous research by Tshuma et al. that has shown how socio-cultural norms in SA influence treatment-seeking amongst men [49]. Attitudes toward healthcare facilities in SA also play a role. In Hasumi et al.’s secondary analysis of SA’s General Household Survey, it was reported that over 70% of patients visiting public healthcare facilities reported encountering “issues” at their last visit —most commonly long waiting times [50] — a factor considered by participants in our study. Findings underscore the critical role of social networks in shaping injury appraisal, supporting previous research on access to surgical care for hip fractures [15,48] and other musculoskeletal injuries [51]. However, social influence has been shown to vary by context. For instance, in India the main family breadwinner often made healthcare decisions, potentially delaying access to care [48]. In contrast, our study found that family members generally encouraged prompt treatment-seeking.
The decision to seek healthcare was hindered by logistical constraints linked to patient and caregivers socio-economic circumstances, particularly distance to services and transport costs—barriers widely reported in other studies exploring health seeking behaviour in LMICs [47]. Shortages of ambulances due to competing demands have been observed in other studies [52], alongside challenges in road infrastructure that can hinder emergency response [52]. Prioritisation systems for emergency medical service vehicles, as described by healthcare professionals, may reflect findings from India that suggest that within resource-constrained healthcare systems, low-impact fractures are often deprioritised compared to other cases [14]. Due to limited ambulances, reliance on multiple methods of transport to reach healthcare facilities, such as hired cars and taxis, in other LMICs has been shown to be common [52,53].
Patients and caregivers identified several factors within the healthcare system that they thought hindered healthcare professional appraisal, investigations and referral. One major barrier to trauma care that has been identified in Southern Africa and other LMICs reflected here is the limited availability of diagnostic and surgical services at District Hospitals, with care often concentrated in higher-level tertiary centres [54]. The INFORMUS study found that transfer from lower-level facilities to tertiary centres was one of the largest factors that contributed to time to admission [12]. Previous research in SA has underscored the need to streamline referral pathways between healthcare facilities [55–57]. Challenges related to x-ray capacity and the difficulty of repairing broken x-ray machines are common barriers to surgical care in many LMICs [16]. In our study, the prioritisation of emergency cases including hip fractures helped to alleviate this difficulty for patients.
The planning and scheduling of surgical care were influenced by resource and staffing issues that impacted access to surgical care. This aligns with findings from other LMICs, where shortages of physicians, surgeons, and hospital beds have been reported in the management of hip fractures [13]. In SA, a 2018 study noted that 95% of orthopaedic surgeons worked in the private sector, resulting in a significant disparity in availability—8.3 per 100,000 in the private sector compared to 0.36 in the public sector [58]. Within LMICs, limited surgical care at the district level shifts the burden of care to better-resourced tertiary hospitals [16]. In our study, healthcare professionals at tertiary centres described a discrepancy between surgical capacity and the high volume of emergency cases, forcing prioritisation decisions. Similar issues have been reported in other countries; Armstrong et al. reported that in Asia hip fracture surgeries were frequently deprioritised compared to other emergencies, including obstetric cases [15]. In India, clinicians noted that orthopaedic surgeons had differing priorities when treating emergency cases [48]. In SA, surgical prioritisation is shaped by the high volume of road traffic accidents that contribute significantly to demand [59].
The Model of Pathways to Treatment was originally developed in a high-income country where it has been widely applied [60,61], with more limited use in LMICs. While it has been used in LMICs to explore treatment journeys in areas such as cancer [62] and tuberculosis [63], its relevance to emergency surgery —where rapid time to treatment is critical— has not yet been established. In contrast, the ‘Three Delays Framework’ has been more widely used to explore access to emergency surgical care [16,51,64]. Application includes a study in 2021 by Whitaker et al. that systematically reviewed and mapped existing literature on access to trauma care in LMICs onto the framework [51].
In framing processes that impact on time to treatment as ‘intervals’ rather than ‘delays’, the Model of Pathways to Treatment allowed us to move beyond identifying barriers and recognise factors that enabled access to care—a limitation of the ‘Three Delays Framework’ previously highlighted [65]. However, we felt the categorisation of data into four distinct intervals obscured issues that existed across the pathway.
Across the care pathway, similar factors influenced time to surgery across multiple intervals, suggesting that surgical timing was shaped by system-wide factors operating throughout the care pathway. Findings highlight the importance of health system capacity and surgical system readiness, both of which have been recognised as key determinants of access to surgical care in previous global health research [16,66]. Similar to previous studies, timely access to surgery depended on the availability and effective functioning of multiple health system components [67]. Consistent with previous health systems research, findings identified that access to hip fracture surgery was influenced not only by the availability of resources but also by how those resources were prioritised and distributed within the health system [68]. Prioritisation decisions within healthcare systems are made both explicitly, for instance through priority-setting frameworks [69] and implicitly, whereby healthcare professionals make decisions based on their own assessment of need [70]. Findings illustrated how these institutional prioritisation decisions shape patient experiences and pathways through care.
Findings highlighted the important role of family members, neighbours, caregivers and wider social networks in facilitating access to care. Informal support networks influenced decisions to seek treatment, helped mobilise transport and financial resources and assisted patients in navigating healthcare processes. These findings are consistent with wider health systems literature on social capital, which recognises that access to care is shaped not only by the availability of formal services but also by the tangible and intangible resources available to patients as a result of their social networks [71].
Recommendations
Based on our findings, we have developed key short-, medium-, and long-term recommendations for improving access to hip fracture care in SA, presented in Table 6. We categorise our recommendations by timeframe. Short-term recommendations can be introduced with minimal changes to current systems. Medium-term recommendations involve coordinated efforts among healthcare providers, facility administrators, and policymakers to revise specific aspects of care delivery. Long-term recommendations involve system-wide changes and sustained collaboration between stakeholders over time. Recommendations were developed through a review of findings at each ‘interval’ in the Model of Pathways to Treatment. The research team identified factors that supported or hindered access to care, transforming facilitators and practical suggestions into actionable recommendations and developing practical solutions to address challenges. Several of the recommendations relate to more than one interval, as shown in the table. This reflects the cross-cutting system constraints identified in the study. For example, the development of national guidelines for hip fracture care in South Africa would improve timely access to treatment across the intervals of help-seeking, diagnosis, and pre-treatment. Recommendations were prioritised according to the frequency with which barriers and facilitators were identified across interviews and observations and their perceived feasibility within the South African health system. The team included experts in gerontology (BC, CLG, FP, AA) and orthopaedics (ML, MC), as well as healthcare professionals involved in the delivery of HF care in South Africa (BC, CLG, FP, ML). Recommendations were refined through discussion within the multidisciplinary research team to ensure alignment with study findings and relevance to the South African healthcare context.
Strengths and limitations
A key strength of this study lies in the inclusion of the perspectives of both patients and caregivers, as well as healthcare professionals across five diverse facilities to explore access to surgical treatment. Interviewing patients and caregivers at multiple timepoints enabled us to understand factors that influenced access to treatment from the point of symptom appraisal to the scheduling of treatment. Complementing in-depth interviews with observations enriched the dataset, providing a more detailed understanding of the clinical context in which care was delivered [39]. The use of criterion sampling to identify healthcare professionals from across the care pathway [37] – from paramedics to surgeons, enabled us to understand factors that helped or hindered access to surgery along the pathway. However, the transferability of findings may be limited by the study’s geographic focus on Gauteng Province, which may not reflect the full diversity of South Africa’s healthcare system [72]. Furthermore, the study did not include patients accessing private hip fracture care who may have had further insights into care provision and its financial consequences. This decision was made as only a small proportion of patients in SA have access to private services [33,34] and was aligned with the study’s aim to generate insights for improving public healthcare provision. Therefore, our findings are specifically relevant to improving care within the public system, which serves the majority of the population. A potential limitation is that data collection with patients and caregivers (April 2022–December 2022) and healthcare professional (July 2023–April 2025) were conducted over different time periods. This staged approach was intentional and enabled findings from patients and caregivers to inform subsequent data collection with healthcare professionals. The different periods of time for phases of data collection raises the possibility that system-level changes may have influenced findings. However, clinical co-authors involved in the organisation and delivery of hip fracture care confirmed that no major changes to service organisation or care pathways occurred during this period. We therefore consider it unlikely that the timing of data collection influenced the pathways to treatment described in this study. This study did not seek to quantify pathway intervals. Rather, it complements previous quantitative studies that have measured time to treatment by exploring patients’ experiences of those delays and the mechanisms underlying them. This is consistent with the use of the Model of Pathways to Treatment in other studies [60,61,63]. The research team brought diverse disciplinary and contextual expertise to data collection and analysis, encompassing sociology, gerontology, orthopaedics and SA-based researchers. This ensured findings were both relevant and grounded in the local context.
Future research
As data collection with healthcare professionals focused on staff in regional and tertiary centres, future research should explore the experiences of staff in district hospitals. This may include characterising how care is delivered and referrals are managed, to build a more complete, ‘system-wide’ understanding of hip fracture care in SA. Further work is also needed to quantify the time spent at each ‘interval’ in the care pathway to help understand where time to surgical care is most affected in order to guide the development of interventions. Further rigorous work is required to assess the feasibility and acceptability of these recommendations within SA. However, in our opinion these research needs should not delay progress on the recommendations listed in Table 5, which should be addressed as key healthcare priorities.
Conclusions
This qualitative study is the first to provide a detailed exploration of factors influencing time to surgery for hip fractures in SA, focusing on the experiences of patients and caregivers. Using the Model of Pathways to Treatment helped to highlight the agency of patients and caregivers in negotiating access to care, while also acknowledging the impact of health system processes.
However, categorising data into ‘intervals’—defined as the time between key events in the pathway, shaped by patient, provider, and disease-specific factors—risked obscuring cross-cutting issues such as the persistent issue of health system capacity. Findings provide an evidence-base to inform the development of targeted interventions across the treatment pathway to improve timely access to care.
Supporting information
S1 Appendix. Interview topic guide patients and caregivers.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgph.0007215.s001
(DOCX)
S2 Appendix. Interview topic guide healthcare professionals.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgph.0007215.s002
(DOCX)
Acknowledgments
We are grateful to all of the study participants who gave their time to the study and to S. A Mwelase, K.B Khutsoane who collected data for the study. We are also grateful to Fundile Habana for supporting us with data collection.
References
- 1.
World Population Ageing 2019. New York: Department of Economic and Social Affairs United Nations; 2020.
- 2.
Is South Africa growing older? The unseen shift in our population. 2025.
- 3. Hawley S, Dela S, Burton A, Paruk F, Cassim B, Gregson CL. Incidence and number of fragility fractures of the hip in South Africa: Estimated projections from 2020 to 2050. Osteoporos Int. 2022;33(12):2575–83. pmid:35962821
- 4. Paruk F, et al. Hip fractures in South Africa: Mortality outcomes over 12 months post-fracture. Arch Osteoporos. 2020;15(1):76.
- 5. Dela SS, Paruk F, Brown SL, Lukhele M, Kalla AA, Jordaan JD, et al. Ethnic and gender-specific incidence rates for hip fractures in South Africa: A multi-centre study. Bone. 2020;133:115253. pmid:31987987
- 6. Mafirakureva N, Paruk F, Cassim B, Lukhele M, Gregson CL, Noble SM. The healthcare system costs of hip fracture care in South Africa. Osteoporos Int. 2023;34(4):803–13. pmid:36705682
- 7.
World development indicators 2018, in Current health expenditure per capita, PPP (current international $). South Africa: World Bank; 2018.
- 8. Dela SS, Paruk F, Conradie M, Jordaan JD, Kalla AA, Lukhele M, et al. Access to care for low trauma hip fractures in South Africa. Arch Osteoporos. 2022;17(1):15. pmid:35024971
- 9. Cassim B, Lipschitz S, Paruk F, Tipping B. Recommendations for the acute and long-term medical management of low-trauma hip fractures. J Endocrinol Metab Diabetes South Afr. 2013;18(1):21–32.
- 10. Simunovic N, Devereaux PJ, Sprague S, Guyatt GH, Schemitsch E, Debeer J, et al. Effect of early surgery after hip fracture on mortality and complications: Systematic review and meta-analysis. CMAJ. 2010;182(15):1609–16. pmid:20837683
- 11.
Management of closed proximal femoral fractures in adults. Africa Orthopaedic Alliance; 2025.
- 12. Armstrong E, Rogers K, Li CS, Jagnoor J, Moroz P, Oguzie GC, et al. Time from injury to hip-fracture surgery in low-income and middle-income regions: A secondary analysis of data from the International Orthopaedic Multicentre Study in Fracture Care (INORMUS). Lancet Healthy Longev. 2024;5(8):e552–62. pmid:39025101
- 13.
Elsevier H, Kiani S, Miclau T. Geriatric hip fracture care in low- and middle-income countries. In: Danford NC, et al. editors. Geriatric hip fractures: A practical approach. Cham: Springer International Publishing; 2021. pp. 205–37.
- 14. Rath S, Yadav L, Tewari A, Chantler T, Woodward M, Kotwal P, et al. Management of older adults with hip fractures in India: A mixed methods study of current practice, barriers and facilitators, with recommendations to improve care pathways. Arch Osteoporos. 2017;12(1):55. pmid:28577286
- 15. Armstrong E, Yin X, Razee H, Pham CV, Sa-Ngasoongsong P, Tabu I, et al. Exploring barriers to, and enablers of, evidence-informed hip fracture care in five low- middle-income countries: China, India, Thailand, the Philippines and Vietnam. Health Policy Plan. 2022;37(8):1000–11. pmid:35678318
- 16. Meara JG, Leather AJM, Hagander L, Alkire BC, Alonso N, Ameh EA, et al. Global Surgery 2030: Evidence and solutions for achieving health, welfare, and economic development. Lancet. 2015;386(9993):569–624. pmid:25924834
- 17. Wyke S, Adamson J, Dixon D, Hunt K. Consultation and illness behaviour in response to symptoms: A comparison of models from different disciplinary frameworks and suggestions for future research directions. Soc Sci Med. 2013;86:79–87. pmid:23608096
- 18. Rosenstock I, Strecher V, Becker M. The health belief model and personal health behaviour. Health Educ Monogr. 1974;2:324–508.
- 19. McLeroy KR, Bibeau D, Steckler A, Glanz K. An ecological perspective on health promotion programs. Health Educ Q. 1988;15(4):351–77. pmid:3068205
- 20. Thaddeus S, Maine D. Too far to walk: Maternal mortality in context. Soc Sci Med. 1994;38(8):1091–110. pmid:8042057
- 21. Scott SE, Walter FM, Webster A, Sutton S, Emery J. The model of pathways to treatment: Conceptualization and integration with existing theory. Br J Health Psychol. 2013;18(1):45–65. pmid:22536840
- 22.
Drew S, Paruk RC, Lukhele M, Zinyemba C, Abraham A, Costa ML, et al. Understanding the implementation of hip fracture services in South Africa: An ethnographic study using extended normalization process theory. 2025.
- 23.
Association WM. Declaration of Helsinki: Medical research involving human participants. World Medical Association; 2024.
- 24.
Dorrington TAM. The 2022 South African census. Technical report prepared for the South African Medical Research Council Burden of Disease Research Unit. Cape Town: South African Medical Research Council; 2024.
- 25.
Gini Coefficient by Country 2025. 2025. Available from: https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/gini-coefficient-by-country
- 26.
Quarterly Labour Force Survey. Statistics South Africa (StatsSA); 2022.
- 27.
Current health expenditure (%GDP) - South Africa. Available from: https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SH.XPD.CHEX.GD.ZS?locations=ZA
- 28. Xu K, et al. Exploring the thresholds of health expenditure for protection against financial risk. World Health Rep. 2010;3:328–33.
- 29. Alhassan AL. Financial health of medical schemes in South Africa. Fin Res Lett. 2023;51:103403.
- 30.
Annual report 2023/24. Pretoria, South Africa: Department of Health Republic of South Africa.
- 31. Obuaku-Igwe CC. Health inequality in South Africa: A systematic review. Afr Sociol Rev/Revue Africaine de Sociologie. 2015;19(2):96–131.
- 32. Achoki T, Sartorius B, Watkins D, Glenn SD, Kengne AP, Oni T, et al. Health trends, inequalities and opportunities in South Africa’s provinces, 1990–2019: Findings from the Global Burden of Disease 2019 Study. J Epidemiol Community Health. 2022;76(5):471–81.
- 33. Pauw TL. Catching up with the constitution: An analysis of National Health Insurance in South Africa post-apartheid. Dev Southern Afr. 2021;39(6):921–34.
- 34. Whyle EB, Olivier J. A socio-political history of South Africa’s National Health Insurance. Int J Equity Health. 2023;22(1):247. pmid:38037083
- 35. Coovadia H, Jewkes R, Barron P, Sanders D, McIntyre D. The health and health system of South Africa: Historical roots of current public health challenges. Lancet. 2009;374(9692):817–34. pmid:19709728
- 36.
2024 Mid-year population estimates. Republic of South Africa: Department of Statistics South Africa; 2024.
- 37. Palinkas LA, Horwitz SM, Green CA, Wisdom JP, Duan N, Hoagwood K. Purposeful sampling for qualitative data collection and analysis in mixed method implementation research. Adm Policy Ment Health. 2015;42(5):533–44. pmid:24193818
- 38. Burton A, Drew S, Cassim B, Jarjou LM, Gooberman-Hill R, Noble S, et al. Fractures in sub-Saharan Africa: epidemiology, economic impact and ethnography (Fractures-E3): Study protocol. Wellcome Open Res. 2023;8:261.
- 39.
Hammersley M, Atkinson P. Ethnography: Principles in practice. Routledge; 2019.
- 41.
Lewis-Beck MS, Bryman A, Liao TF. Snowball sampling. The SAGE encyclopedia of social science research methods. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications, Inc.; 2004.
- 42. Malterud K, Siersma VD, Guassora AD. Sample size in qualitative interview studies: guided by information power. Qual Health Res. 2016;26(13):1753–60.
- 43. Gale NK, Heath G, Cameron E, Rashid S, Redwood S. Using the framework method for the analysis of qualitative data in multi-disciplinary health research. BMC Med Res Methodol. 2013;13:117. pmid:24047204
- 44. Vindrola-Padros C, Johnson GA. Rapid techniques in qualitative research: A critical review of the literature. Qual Health Res. 2020;30(10):1596–604. pmid:32667277
- 45. Carter N, Bryant-Lukosius D, DiCenso A, Blythe J, Neville AJ. The use of triangulation in qualitative research. Oncol Nurs Forum. 2014;41(5):545–7. pmid:25158659
- 46. Espinosa KA, Gélvez AG, Torres LP, García MF, Peña OR. Pre-operative factors associated with increased mortality in elderly patients with a hip fracture: A cohort study in a developing country. Injury. 2018;49(6):1162–8. pmid:29674111
- 47. Grimes CE, et al. Systematic review of barriers to surgical care in low-income and middle-income countries. World J Surg. 2011;35(5):941–50.
- 48. Tewari A, Pati S, Nallala S, Webster P, Rath S, Yadav L, et al. Care seeking behaviour of older adults with hip fracture in India: A qualitative study. J Pat Care. 2017;03(01).
- 49. Tshuma N, Elakpa DN, Moyo C, Ndhlovu TM, Mokgatle MM, Moyo S, et al. Community perceived barriers to uptake of health services among men at Sedibeng district in South Africa. Health SA. 2024;29:2548. pmid:38841348
- 50. Hasumi T, Jacobsen KH. Healthcare service problems reported in a national survey of South Africans. Int J Qual Health Care. 2014;26(4):482–9. pmid:24840002
- 51. Whitaker J, O’Donohoe N, Denning M, Poenaru D, Guadagno E, Leather AJM, et al. Assessing trauma care systems in low-income and middle-income countries: A systematic review and evidence synthesis mapping the Three Delays framework to injury health system assessments. BMJ Glob Health. 2021;6(5):e004324. pmid:33975885
- 52. Kironji AG, Hodkinson P, de Ramirez SS, Anest T, Wallis L, Razzak J, et al. Identifying barriers for out of hospital emergency care in low and low-middle income countries: A systematic review. BMC Health Serv Res. 2018;18(1):291. pmid:29673360
- 53. Tabu I, Goh EL, Appelbe D, Parsons N, Lekamwasam S, Lee J-K, et al. Service availability and readiness for hip fracture care in low- and middle-income countries in South and Southeast Asia. Bone Jt Open. 2023;4(9):676–81. pmid:37666496
- 54. Grimes CE, Law RSL, Borgstein ES, Mkandawire NC, Lavy CBD. Systematic review of met and unmet need of surgical disease in rural sub-Saharan Africa. World J Surg. 2012;36(1):8–23. pmid:22057752
- 55. Schneider H, Mianda S, Odendaal W, Chetty T. Managing local health system interdependencies: Referral and outreach systems for maternal and newborn health in three South African Districts. Systems. 2023;11(9):462.
- 56. Matolengwe A, Murray D, Okafor UB. The challenges of implementing a health referral system in South Africa: A qualitative study. Risk Manag Healthc Policy. 2024;17:855–64. pmid:38623578
- 57. Mothupi MN, Ndimande JV, Nkoane MA, Steyn C, Bongongo T. Doctors’ experiences regarding patient referral to tertiary care in Pretoria, South Africa. J Coll Med S Afr. 2024;2(1):46. pmid:40949641
- 58. Dell AJ, et al. Orthopaedic Surgeon Density in South Africa. World J Surg. 2018;42(12):3849–55.
- 59. Geduld H, Sinclair M, Steyn E, Chu K. Road traffic injuries in South Africa: A complex global health crisis. Ann Glob Health. 2024;90(1):26. pmid:38618273
- 60. Howell D, Hart R, Smith A, Macleod U, Patmore R, Roman E. “Unpacking” pathways to lymphoma and myeloma diagnosis: Do experiences align with the Model of Pathways to Treatment? Findings from a UK qualitative study with patients and relatives. BMJ Open. 2020;10(2):e034244. pmid:32054627
- 61. Walter FM, Penfold C, Joannides A, Saji S, Johnson M, Watts C, et al. Missed opportunities for diagnosing brain tumours in primary care: A qualitative study of patient experiences. Br J Gen Pract. 2019;69(681):e224–35. pmid:30858332
- 62. Moodley J, Cairncross L, Naiker T, Momberg M. Understanding pathways to breast cancer diagnosis among women in the Western Cape Province, South Africa: A qualitative study. BMJ Open. 2016;6(1):e009905. pmid:26729392
- 63. Mbuthia GW, Olungah CO, Ondicho TG. Health-seeking pathway and factors leading to delays in tuberculosis diagnosis in West Pokot County, Kenya: A grounded theory study. PLoS One. 2018;13(11):e0207995. pmid:30485379
- 64. Badkur M, Kharkongor M, Sharma N, Singh S, Khera P, Puranik A, et al. Factors influencing treatment delays in trauma patients: A three-delay model approach. J Emerg Trauma Shock. 2024;17(3):172–7. pmid:39552825
- 65. Actis Danna V, Bedwell C, Wakasiaka S, Lavender T. Utility of the three-delays model and its potential for supporting a solution-based approach to accessing intrapartum care in low- and middle-income countries. A qualitative evidence synthesis. Glob Health Action. 2020;13(1):1819052. pmid:33040697
- 66. Kruk ME, Gage AD, Arsenault C, Jordan K, Leslie HH, Roder-DeWan S, et al. High-quality health systems in the Sustainable Development Goals era: Time for a revolution. Lancet Glob Health. 2018;6(11):e1196–252. pmid:30196093
- 67. Graham SM, Chokotho L, Mkandawire N, Laubscher M, Maqungo S, Haonga B, et al. Injury: A neglected global health challenge in low-income and middle-income countries. Lancet Glob Health. 2025;13(4):e613–5. pmid:40155097
- 68. Hipgrave DB, Alderman KB, Anderson I, Soto EJ. Health sector priority setting at meso-level in lower and middle income countries: Lessons learned, available options and suggested steps. Soc Sci Med. 2014;102:190–200. pmid:24565157
- 69. Nouhi M, et al. Explicit priority setting approaches in health care coverage policies: A critical review and implications for further research. Evid Based Health Policy Manage Econ. 2018;2(2):125–32.
- 70. Waithaka D, Tsofa B, Barasa E. Evaluating healthcare priority setting at the meso level: A thematic review of empirical literature. Wellcome Open Res. 2018;3:2. pmid:29511741
- 71. Derose KP, Varda DM. Social capital and health care access: A systematic review. Med Care Res Rev. 2009;66(3):272–306. pmid:19174538
- 72. Patton MQ. Enhancing the quality and credibility of qualitative analysis. Health Serv Res. 1999;34(5 Pt 2):1189–208. pmid:10591279